Why did Aman deceive Naina into marrying Rohit?

Posted: 6 months ago

just a different perspective from my side.

I do not deny that it was a supreme act of sacrifice and that he wanted her to be cared for after his death.

But my point is: why deceive her and create confusion and pain for everyone involved?

Why not lay out the cards before her (including expressing his love for her) and let her decide what to do?

Why take away her agency?

Why take away her right to choose?

Also, if intervention is required to fall in love, is that actual love? Can that love sustain?

Just some questions popped into my mind, and I wondered if u guys also thought that sacrifice was not needed in the film, and that Naina's  and Rohit's characters was manipulated.

Posted: 6 months ago

I kinda agree. Rohit and Naina were better off as friends. Eventually some time after getting over Aman may be she would have given Rohit a chance perhaps? It’s another one of KJo’s crapfest with over emotional beings so we don’t have to think too much about it 😆 Aman was right from his perspective but you can’t force people to fall in love. “ 6 din ladki in” was cringe. 

Posted: 6 months ago

As for him not confessing to her I think then it would have been harder for her to move on. She did realise he loved her back but it was too late anyway, she was already engaged and he was on his death bed. 

Posted: 6 months ago

6 din ladki in is misogynistic, crap, and shallow.

 Love is a feeling that cannot be manufactured. It is an emotion that comes naturally from within and cannot be forced or fabricated.

This basic premise was overridden in Kal Ho Naa Ho.

In today's society, many people believe that love can be bought with material possessions or manufactured through online dating apps. However, this is far from the truth. True love requires more than just physical attraction or the exchange of gifts; it requires emotional connectivity.

Posted: 6 months ago

Aise hi, he was getting bored and needed time pass🤷‍♀️

Posted: 6 months ago

Aman could have taught her how life is beautiful with love but setting Naina Rohit was cringe. Aman chose Rohit for Naina like he is her father 😆 n then manipulated both to marry. 

Posted: 6 months ago

So he could do her kanyadan before he is gone. 

Posted: 6 months ago

Aman was a self-righteous prick, IMHO

He held back from expressing his love for Naina due to his own twisted thinking, thus denying her the right to choose what to do.

Maybe twisted is too strong a word, but self-righteous definitely.

Same with Katrina's character in Jab Tak Hain Jaan.


Related Topics

doc-text Topics pencil Author stackexchange Replies eye Views clock Last Post Reply
Why Sush why!!

pencil cougarTown   stackexchange 23   eye 3678

cougarTown 23 3678 1 months ago anonymouse1
Why Tamil remakes? Why the same mistakes..

pencil Bharathi_gurti   stackexchange 14   eye 1040

Bharathi_gurti 14 1040 2 months ago Bharathi_gurti
Why salman bhai why? #blacktiger

pencil Briaahna   stackexchange 21   eye 2189

Briaahna 21 2189 5 months ago oh_nakhrewaali
I once dreamed of marrying Hrithik

pencil mintyblue   stackexchange 7   eye 575

mintyblue 7 575 4 months ago Hello_kitta
Kajol would have chosen Aman over Rahul in real life

pencil 2RsFan   stackexchange 121   eye 7124

2RsFan 121 7124 5 months ago MochaQueen

Topic Info

20 Participants 62 Replies 3072Views

Topic started by mintyblue

Last replied by MochaQueen

up-open TOP