These are our intellectuals - Page 3

Originally posted by: PranPriye

This thread already shifted to Debate Mansion 😆

Richa Chadda ab BW celebrity nahi hai kya?

Nahi..intellectual ban gai ab

That was fast

Isme debate karne layak kya hai mods

Ye to celeb ka mazak udane ke liye hai

Aryan ke thread to do do din rakhte hain , when he haven't even debut yet

Originally posted by: TheMinion

Wow, and Aryan Khan ki nautanki 3 din chal rahi thi BWF mein... 😆

Aryan Khan belongs to bollywood..to kya hua agar koi film nahi aayi.

More people know him..not Richa

Originally posted by: TheMinion

Wow, and Aryan Khan ki nautanki 3 din chal rahi thi BWF mein... 😆

Woh ab bhi chal rahi hai.

🎵Thread nayi, topic wohi 🎵

Vijay ji. If you can find some time from your busy schedule could you please look at this topic and check what qualified it to be shifted to debate mansion within minutes of creating, when topics made on Shahrukh khan's son who hasn't even made his debut yet are made and continuously allowed to run in Bollywood forum despite all sorts of debates ranging from politics to religion in the same topic. The most that is done is that those topics are locked after complaints. But this one topic despite being on a bollywood actress is sent to debate mansion within minutes.

Is there some special criteria that we innocent members do not understand?

Well I feel for more serious debates this place is apt compared to Bollywood Forum as such topics will get lost there.

I understand that you feel moving it here would restrict its reach and participation and that is something we want to work towards.

If you have suggestions please share.

Originally posted by: vijay

Well I feel for more serious debates this place is apt compared to Bollywood Forum as such topics will get lost there.

I understand that you feel moving it here would restrict its reach and participation and that is something we want to work towards.

If you have suggestions please share.

@bold - that is the problem Vijay. In this topic no debate or arguments was going on. Still it was shifted within minutes of making the thread. If you read other members' replies in the previous page, they are also shocked about the same. On the contrary i can give you tens of examples, in recent time, where threads were continuing on bwf for days despite arguments, debates on politics & religion as well as personal attacks on members.

So the question is - why this special treatment for this thread only?

P.S. this is me, NathuPyare only. I have been an old member of this site. Have been here for more than 7 years. I know all the rules and have never got a single WL in all these 7 years. Despite all this, the unruly and uncontrolled behaviour of your mods has forced me to deactivate my account and leave this site.

Originally posted by: vijay

Well I feel for more serious debates this place is apt compared to Bollywood Forum as such topics will get lost there.

I understand that you feel moving it here would restrict its reach and participation and that is something we want to work towards.

If you have suggestions please share.

Thread which was shifted wasn't debate worthy. It was Just a goof up tweet by Richa Chadda.

For serious debates to happen there needs to be a crowd to discuss. These days, no one comes to the debate mansion.

Solution 1 Let bollywood-political debate threads be continued in Bollywood forum and moderators should only intervene if Members are fighting or crossing line.

Solution 2 Revive Debate Mansion, with one hot issue per day and a thread on the India forums' main page (I'm not sure what it's called) global announcemens..

Originally posted by: Zeal17

Thread which was shifted wasn't debate worthy. It was Just a goof up tweet by Richa Chadda.

For serious debates to happen there needs to be a crowd to discuss. These days, no one comes to the debate mansion.

Solution 1 Let bollywood-political debate threads be continued in Bollywood forum and moderators should only intervene if Members are fighting or crossing line.

Solution 2 Revive Debate Mansion, with one hot issue per day and a thread on the India forums' main page (I'm not sure what it's called) global announcemens..

We are working on solution 2.

Originally posted by: Mangola

@bold - that is the problem Vijay. In this topic no debate or arguments was going on. Still it was shifted within minutes of making the thread. If you read other members' replies in the previous page, they are also shocked about the same. On the contrary i can give you tens of examples, in recent time, where threads were continuing on bwf for days despite arguments, debates on politics & religion as well as personal attacks on members.

So the question is - why this special treatment for this thread only?

P.S. this is me, NathuPyare only. I have been an old member of this site. Have been here for more than 7 years. I know all the rules and have never got a single WL in all these 7 years. Despite all this, the unruly and uncontrolled behaviour of your mods has forced me to deactivate my account and leave this site.

Nathupyare wapas aa Jaao...

I do see you tagged me but I am still recovering from COVID so could not revert to all messages.

We will work on Debate mansion and make it an active place.