How did a movie like Kabir Singh become so successful?

Posted: 2 years ago

People often bash old Bollywood movies for being "regressive" and not having aged well (even movies like DDLJ or KKHH get lots of criticism here) & act like people are sooo much smarter now.

Then we get a movie like Kabir Singh where the MC treated women FAR worse than many of the popular 90s-early 2000s movies (not sure about before, haven't watched them) and it was very successful and popular.

Posted: 2 years ago

it had great songs

shahid kiara had chemistry - shahid acted well in the role though the character was aggressive, kiara is a relatively fresh face 

Posted: 2 years ago

Kabir Singh/Arjun Reddy is the story of an individual with many problems and all his relationships were problematic not just with the woman he loved but with everyone who is connected with him be it with his family members or his friends.

The original film Arjun Reddy is a huge hit in Telugu. But in Telugu the movie seemed to have been perceived differently. It was seen as a journey of a flawed individual.

This movie came along when movie heroes are shown as angels who come to rescue people in distress. A story of a flawed man in the lead was a novelty and a welcome change.

I think Telugu audience saw him as just a flawed man who screwed up his life and relationships and how he redeemed himself.

Of course the chemistry of the ML and the girl who played his GF also added to its success.

Posted: 2 years ago
Originally posted by aparnauma


Kabir Singh/Arjun Reddy is the story of an individual with many problems and all his relationships were problematic not just with the woman he loved but with everyone who is connected with him be it with his family members or his friends.

The original film Arjun Reddy is a huge hit in Telugu. But in Telugu the movie seemed to have been perceived differently. It was seen as a journey of a flawed individual.

This movie came along when movie heroes are shown as angels who come to rescue people in distress. A story of a flawed man in the lead was a novelty and a welcome change.

I think Telugu audience saw him as just a flawed man who screwed up his life and relationships and how he redeemed himself.

Of course the chemistry of the ML and the girl who played his GF also added to its success.


I appreciate Anti hero protagonists a lot, they are popular in many Hollywood movies, shows etc. but the problem with Kabir Singh was that he didn't show much change and was even rewarded at the end. If he didn't get his love interest back and changed for the better I would be fine with it

Posted: 2 years ago
Originally posted by Journey95



I appreciate Anti hero protagonists a lot, they are popular in many Hollywood movies, shows etc. but the problem with Kabir Singh was that he didn't show much change and was even rewarded at the end. If he didn't get his love interest back and changed for the better I would be fine with it

I haven't seen the Hindi version but heard that it is scene to scene remake.After the hospital inquiry committee he did work on improving himself.

@Bold I agree with you on that. But I guess it is the girl's decision to take him back.But then we never really got to see what she saw in him in the first play anyways. May be for her the improved version is  acceptable. She seemed to have chosen her unmarried mother status and part with her family over this guy.I think she got tired of being all alone and took him back too quickly.

But yes they should have left it open ended with the scene implying that he would work on getting her back again and earn her trust.

Posted: 2 years ago

The target audience loves toxic masculinity.

Posted: 2 years ago

Sirf ek thappad se poora film regressive ban gaya wah bhai wah  ,thappad toh ladki ne bhi maara tha Shahid ko picture mein😆

Posted: 2 years ago

Devdas ko kuch kyon nahi bolta saala shadi k din Paro ko sarr pe maarta hai aur phir dialogue marta hai ki pyaar ki nishani hai  abe sale ðŸ˜†

Posted: 2 years ago

Originally posted by Daechwita


The target audience loves toxic masculinity.


Well everyone loves it. Even women. Otherwise men are called INCAPABLE  AND UNATTRACTIVE for being a potential partner. Yeh manly nahi hai yaar comes to mind by Sanju baba.


Another point is if Shahid's character wouldn't have been successful paisewala, the girl would have filed a complaint for harrassment. 

Related Topics

doc-text Topics pencil Author stackexchange Replies eye Views clock Last Post Reply
Ranbir loves successful women and leaves when they flop

pencil Terenaina   stackexchange 19   eye 1025

Terenaina 19 1025 2 months ago Minionite
Katrina Kaif: Most successful n humble outsider

pencil PardesiBabu   stackexchange 25   eye 2293

PardesiBabu 25 2293 6 months ago Sweet_polaroid
You Have Allowed Someone To Become SRK till today - Bushra Ansari

pencil khan.baba   stackexchange 19   eye 724

khan.baba 19 724 22 days ago snatch
What do you think about this junior artist, can he become a star?

pencil NoraSM   stackexchange 19   eye 591

NoraSM 19 591 1 months ago MostlyHarmIess
Why didn’t Bobby Deol become a superstar?

pencil Bird32   stackexchange 46   eye 1755

Bird32 46 1755 2 months ago JackSparrowcraz

Topic Info

23 Participants 40 Replies 3078Views

Topic started by Journey95

Last replied by infinity101

loader
loader
up-open TOP