Do you want Sireesha and Nachiket to return for wildcard?

shareShare facebook twitter
Posted: 13 days ago

Assuming they are invited, what are your thoughts? 

At one point I really wanted both to come back. But thinking it through, neither will ever be hyped enough by these judges to garner enough public support for top five. The channel is already set on who they want to continue till the end.

I’d rather they focus on getting playback opportunities instead of being disrespected again by returning to boost TRP only to be sent home in a week or two. They both have very bright futures, Sireesha has a promising future in the South having already sung two tracks for ARR and I’m sure Nachiket will be equally successful in the Marathi industry. 

Edited by Throwawayacc - 13 days ago
Posted: 13 days ago

Same goes for Anushka. Really hope some director picks her up because I seriously love her tone so so much.

Posted: 13 days ago

I agree. As much as I wanted to see them in the grand finale, what matters is that they grow in their careers and we, as an audience, are lucky enough to keep on hearing them sing. I'd only accept a wild card entry if they make it to the top 5. Like in season 11, Ankona entered by wild card and placed third (if I'm not wrong). On the other hand, Stuti also entered by wild card but was eliminated again two weeks later. If Nachiket and Sireesha aren't going to be given their fair share of screen space, then they shouldn't come back just to be eliminated again.

Posted: 13 days ago

Originally posted by Aditi_MM


I agree. As much as I wanted to see them in the grand finale, what matters is that they grow in their careers and we, as an audience, are lucky enough to keep on hearing them sing. I'd only accept a wild card entry if they make it to the top 5. Like in season 11, Ankona entered by wild card and placed third (if I'm not wrong). On the other hand, Stuti also entered by wild card but was eliminated again two weeks later. If Nachiket and Sireesha aren't going to be given their fair share of screen space, then they shouldn't come back just to be eliminated again.

Exactly. And I think they were primarily brought back because there weren’t enough girls in Season 11 (despite Ankona being the only voice I liked that season I always found it a little odd that they introduced an entirely new contestant so late in the season).


Also I just don’t see anyone aside from Pawandeep, Arunita, SMP, Danish, Sawai and Ashish making top six at this point. Always felt they sent away these two early because they were the only ones who could’ve posed a threat to anyone in the aforementioned six. 

Posted: 13 days ago

Originally posted by Throwawayacc


Exactly. And I think they were primarily brought back because there weren’t enough girls in Season 11 (despite Ankona being the only voice I liked that season I always found it a little odd that they introduced an entirely new contestant so late in the season).


Also I just don’t see anyone aside from Pawandeep, Arunita, SMP, Danish, Sawai and Ashish making top six at this point. Always felt they sent away these two early because they were the only ones who could’ve posed a threat to anyone in the aforementioned six. 

It is so messed up that Indian Idol does this. I mean, why? Even in season 10, Soumya was eliminated because he was apparently a threat to Salman. Is it for TRP? Are there backstage under the table dealings we don't know about? Favoritism/Nepotism? 

Posted: 13 days ago

Right from the beginning Nachiket and Sireesha were my favourites and I’d love to see them on tv again.

However, this time the bias is glaring. There’s always some sort of bias, but this year they’ve outdone themselves. I don’t want Nachiket and Sireesha or anyone for that matter to come and be the next two to leave. Defeats the purpose. 

I’m happy Sireesha has started singing for AR Rehman, hoping this is only the beginning.

Yesterday Nachiket put up a picture in his IG story, I’m not sure if it’s a studio but he sure working on it. 
I hope they both do well for themselves. 

In a way good they got eliminated, no Indian Idol winner makes it big. The only relatively popular one is Revanth, down south. But then he was already an established singer. He’d been singing for a few years before II. Other than that Abhijit Sawant got some fame that’s vanished. But he was the first winner so understandable.


However, after all the backlash they’ve recieved I have no doubt if there is a wildcard round Nachiket will be brought in.

Posted: 12 days ago

Are you sure there will be WC? I heard kaoil Sharma is coming back with his show in May.

Posted: 12 days ago

Nachiket also said in his interview that he is unsure about wild cards this year..

But if its happening he will surely get reentry


Indian Idol 12 


Related Topics

doc-text Topics pencil Author stackexchange Replies eye Views clock Last Post Reply
Sireesha eliminated

pencil Safsoo   stackexchange 50   eye 2980

Safsoo 50 2980 a month ago altgr
Is Sireesha going to be eliminated this week?

pencil Throwawayacc   stackexchange 4   eye 384

Throwawayacc 4 384 1 months ago ~Raina~
Why does Wikipedia say that Sireesha is going to be eliminated?

pencil Aditi_MM   stackexchange 13   eye 1047

Aditi_MM 13 1047 1 months ago rishimahajan
Why do they not praise and appreciate Sireesha?

pencil rishimahajan   stackexchange 24   eye 2210

rishimahajan 24 2210 1 months ago rishimahajan
This contestant was the least liked last week not nachiket

pencil Karkerrna3   stackexchange 0   eye 285

Karkerrna3 0 285 14 days ago Karkerrna3

Topic Info

7 Participants 10 Replies 723Views

Topic started by Throwawayacc

Last replied by altgr

FORUM QUICK JUMP

up-open TOP