Alka Yagnik Vs Anuradha Paudwal - Better Voice Quality ?

was listening to Muskaan songs and they both had hits in it 

Janeman Chupke Chupke - Udit Narayan & Alka Yagnik 

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zbET5EsM_gs

Woh Ho Tum - Sonu Nigam & Anuradha Paudwal

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BZfo4Wve1f8

Anuradha Paudwal  much better than Alka as her voice is very powerful. Alka though good, but very overrated. Sadhna Sargam is  better than Alka.

Churake dil mera, though originally sung by Alka, Anuradha too sang it under T Series cover version. I find Anuradha's more beautiful than Alka's original.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_FD0HTkTKyo

Alka without any doubt.

Alka for sure! She had a very melodious voice that could be romantic as well as sensuous. Also felt her voice suited more heroines

Alka yagnik definitely has bigger range 

Anuradha Paudwal  became very popular in early 90s  among the public.  Those people who have seen her era  know it very well how she became very popular amoung the audience and also known for her beauty.  She was the first Bollywood singer whose face featured on the cassette covers more than the  film actors. She quit at peak and thereafter Alka had  strong associations with Nadeem/ Shravan , Anu Malik  and other new music directors through Tips and Venus. They all gave many hit songs together and Alka became a sensational and favourite among the audience because of huge collection of her songs.  The public liked Alka's voice but I don't understand why Sadhna Sargam is so underrated. 

Has anyone heard Alka’s voice recently when she sings along in reality shows where she’s the judge?

It is unbelievably bad! It’s very squeaky or screechy. The first time I heard it I thought it was joke, she’s doing this on purpose 

I don’t know how AP’s voice has aged but quality wise she might be better, maybe AY emoted better in some 90s songs and her voice suited most of the 90s heroines better 

Although Sadhana Sargam might be better than these two :)

Originally posted by: Tippy-top

Anuradha Paudwal  much better than Alka as her voice is very powerful. Alka though good, but very overrated. Sadhna Sargam is  better than Alka.

Churake dil mera, though originally sung by Alka, Anuradha too sang it under T Series cover version. I find Anuradha's more beautiful than Alka's original.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_FD0HTkTKyo

TFS, hearing it for the first time, sounds good but I feel AY’s voice suites SS better or maybe it’s just nostalgia...

I heard both versions  of “Mujhe Neend Na Aaye” song and I preferred AP’s version bcz I though her voice was less squeaky 

Mujhe neend na aaye | Alka yagnik vs Anuradha paudwal

https://youtu.be/rEDAI4Zwctc