EBSS Chat Club #2-Its Kabir's Turn(Page 2)

Share
Posted: 2019-07-04T13:09:42Z

Mahi I saw your comment in the last Chat Thread.

About the Mahabharat post, yes, you are right crimes against Draupadi, were also crime against womankind.

But murder and killing innocents is also crime against society. By that logic, Pooja's fight is also correct. 

The whole difference between civil wrong and criminal wrong, is that crimes are considered to be a wrong against society. 

Thats why the state is the prosecutor. 

For example, in a criminal case, it will never be Ajay v/s Vijay. Never, even if Ajay murdered Vijay's parents. 

It will always be Ajay v/s State of Maharashtra or  Union of India (for example).

Because it was the State's duty to protect its citizens, and Ajay violated the State's law by committing murder. Therefore the state will take action against him, and prosecute the criminal. 

Here, PK committed murder, and also indirectly killed hundreds of innocent people with his medicine. So, he is a criminal, and as such he would be punished by State. 

Pooja is doing what the State is supposed to do. It is not only private revenge, it is also about justice. 

That said, its the State's duty to prosecute PK, not Pooja, so she might suffer because she took law into her hands. 

Posted: 2019-07-04T13:21:36Z

Originally posted by SRKisLove


Mahi I saw your comment in the last Chat Thread.

About the Mahabharat post, yes, you are right crimes against Draupadi, were also crime against womankind.

But murder and killing innocents is also crime against society. By that logic, Pooja's fight is also correct. 

The whole difference between civil wrong and criminal wrong, is that crimes are considered to be a wrong against society. 

Thats why the state is the prosecutor. 

For example, in a criminal case, it will never be Ajay v/s Vijay. Never, even if Ajay murdered Vijay's parents. 

It will always be Ajay v/s State of Maharashtra or  Union of India (for example).

Because it was the State's duty to protect its citizens, and Ajay violated the State's law by committing murder. Therefore the state will take action against him, and prosecute the criminal. 

Here, PK committed murder, and also indirectly killed hundreds of innocent people with his medicine. So, he is a criminal, and as such he would be punished by State. 

Pooja is doing what the State is supposed to do. It is not only private revenge, it is also about justice. 

That said, its the State's duty to prosecute PK, not Pooja, so she might suffer because she took law into her hands. 

That's the whole point.

I'm not saying she's wrong. But she's not right either.

What I'm trying to highlight is the intention which matters the most. Had Pooja's intention been to clear AS' name or seek PK's repentance or get justice for the families whose members were killed - things would've been different. But she chose to kill PK to satisfy her own revenge and that, is grey.

Posted: 2019-07-04T13:31:43Z

Originally posted by Mishti_Dahi


That's the whole point.

I'm not saying she's wrong. But she's not right either.

What I'm trying to highlight is the intention which matters the most. Had Pooja's intention been to clear AS' name or seek PK's repentance or get justice for the families whose members were killed - things would've been different. But she chose to kill PK to satisfy her own revenge and that, is grey.

Yeah, for sure its grey. 

Posted: 2019-07-04T13:32:59Z

Okay but did you guys see Mittal's new house?

They are so unhappy, when more than half of India lives in worse conditions. 

Relative poverty smiley37

Posted: 2019-07-04T13:35:32Z

Originally posted by SRKisLove


Okay but did you guys see Mittal's new house?

They are so unhappy, when more than half of India lives in worse conditions. 

Relative poverty smiley37

Well , they need to see Real World ..Why Dhruv, Jai and Sonali not finding work , why its only Kabirs responsibility ?

Edited by Sumita18 - 2019-07-04T13:40:21Z
Posted: 2019-07-04T13:36:26Z

Congratulations smiley40smiley41

Posted: 2019-07-04T13:42:27Z

Originally posted by SRKisLove


Congos on 2nd chat thread!

This is the fastest moving thread in the forum smiley40

Yup smiley36

Posted: 2019-07-04T13:42:45Z

Why amnu is not active nowadays???

Related Topics

Topics Author Replies Views Last Post Reply
From kabir bhaiya to kabir - Janvi

vaishuarshi123   42   9124

vaishuarshi123 42 9124 2019-06-19T12:16:54Z Riana31
Best thing about EBSS

InCenDia   12   1776

InCenDia 12 1776 2019-08-02T20:17:13Z kasaf
EBSS 0.7 - This Week 27th June

BlueOcean   7   1587

BlueOcean 7 1587 2019-07-11T01:30:25Z TeenRose1
Riana31 44 5494 2019-07-11T00:02:18Z TeenRose1
InCenDia 24 2831 2019-07-10T20:49:10Z TeenRose1

Topic Info

  • 566 Replies
  • 32460Views

Topic started by Eternized_Blues

Last replied by subbuappu

FORUM QUICK JUMP

TOP