RJ Task Review - Page 5

Originally posted by: NathuPyare

No I have not.

I have seen debates on Indian news channels (the Hindi ones specifically) and that's what I'm talking about. Also I'm talking about the norms not exceptions.

people do lose their cool during debates and that quite normal... I'm not expecting deepika to match some Gold standard of maintaining cool while debating.

Originally posted by: ayaan786

but you forget to mention

that the people who do loose their cool are the ones who automatically loose the argument as well

and no i refuse to accept indien news channels as the "norm"

if you argue with someone you dont scream their head off do you?

people are cabable of conversing with each other peacefully which romil clearly proved and dipika failed at

Originally posted by: shubhzie

It's because of Indian channels, that there is a general consensus that people should shout in a debate/ elocution. It is not. The first rule while taking part in a debate is you listen to other people, keep your points in a non-aggressive manner. Just because politicians are shouting in tv channels doesn't make them any kind of standard. Also, why shout, and reply in such snooty manner and cut Romil's each, and every reply when he on the other hand was calm and composed.

Originally posted by: NathuPyare

no i dont believe that people who loose their cool automatically loose their argument...

I never said Indian news channels are the norm... I said losing cool in debates is a norm... maintaining perfect cool is an exception.

I agree that Deepika did indeed seem agitated and theatrical but "screaming their head off"?? that's stretching it too far 😆... but even then Its quiet frequent in arguments. You know its an argument and not a discussion when someone is shouting or screaming. 😉

well, I cant blame Deepika cos Romil does have that effect on many people (while still maintaining his holier than thou image) that people do get irritated by his mere presence...

Originally posted by: TheBigTamasha

Nehha had dat but wat did she get in return...an early exit n also d tag of boring n fake by dese very people 😆

@TM-agree wid everything xcept for d rankings lol...nahi thakta mein ye kehte kehte meri rankings mein last pe aata hai one n only Somi ka zabardasti ka bhaiyya who deserves to be evicted lete lete 😆

Originally posted by: NathuPyare

No. I didn't say that people SHOULD shout in a debate... I just said and i quote - "I'm seriously wondering - have people ever seen debates on Indian News channels." which means that I was surprised that is this the first time that people saw anyone get agitated or shouting in a debate, when debates in Indian news channels are hardly ever devoid of shouting and what not.

deepika already said that she doesnt like Romil at all...so i can understand her being snooty towards Romil...not a big surprise there.

Originally posted by: vitriolic

^^ shubhzie, that she will come out looking bad didnt cross her mind, I guess. Problem with ppl who ride on a facade is that they cant keep up with it for too long... after a while, the mask will slip. It's not news for many of us who saw thru this early on, but it perhaps is shocking for those who didnt. But am glad it is out before the season ended.. regardless of whther she is announced the winner or not.

ise kehte hein - dayare mein rehke apna vyaktitva dikhana. I, for one, am loving it 😃

Originally posted by: shubhzie

I was the one who disliked her from the beginning of the show but my reason was her rona dhona and her not having winner's charisma but despite this, I partially agreed with SK that she has been dignified, but since some episodes it seems the facade is actually wearing out. After family week, she goes on this rant, and after her yesterday's stint,I refuse to believe that she is even a celebrity as they know how to handle themselves in interview and stuff. Here Romil was the one looking sane and mature, she on other hand was immature, and vindictive.

@bold - Yes I too am loving it that her real crass nature is out but her incessant screeching give me headaches, tbh.😭

Originally posted by: shubhzie

I was not pointing towards you but talking about general tv thing and the rules of debate. She not liking Romil is fine, I don't understand what he has done to warrant such hate from her but that's her prerogative but she is someone hailed as dignified and graceful, and in the last episode when the person sitting against you talks in such a calm manner, the basic courtesy is to let him talk, and not make such awful expressions because by doing that she is the one who comes out looking like an immature, and vindictive person. It's not that people are surprised at someone shouting in debates, it's just that her unnecessary rant, and shouting was bit surprising and uncalled for.