Was PTSD was in mind of writer while writing Nandini - Page 2

I saw one post in IF trying to explain Nandini's character .Well PTSD is very wide and senstive subject to touch.I saw Abhinav shukla  liked fan comment where he mentioned that nandini is victim of abuse ,PTSD .As actors knows about script more than us .So i hv question my are writers going to touch subject of PTSD .I myself is in medical field and hv seen many patients of PTSD but never dealt with them because my specilization is different. Edited by TheMockingBird - 5 years ago

Till now,  they haven't explored it at all. It's doubtful if they will explore it now. 

I don't think so... And I guess Abhinav has just liked that post.

Edited by mas123 - 5 years ago

Originally posted by: mas123

I don't think so... And I guess Abhinav has just liked that post.

Writers failed to handle Ema...ptsd is way far for them. Better they don't touch such topics

But I feel there is more to Nandini's character than what we are seeing. Perhaps she was negative from the beginning in the disguise of bff or something else...

Nope Abhinav liked some fan comment Edited by TheMockingBird - 5 years ago

Post traumatic stress syndrome
Can be ...few traits of it
Many domestic violence victims go through it
Nandini was not fully recovered from the domestic abuse
All she was doing for yrs was "cooking , dressing up herself and getting abused by husband"
Her thought process wouldn't be clear .

But I personally know one lady she is a friend
People really didn't know things were very bad .
When she came out of that relationship ,
She just drpped the idea of a man in her life
She is just sick of marriage and relationships
CVs are faulted there ...

Kunal being a doctor is another flow
Many men out there prey on single vulnerable ladies
Even though peadiatrician won't be an expert in psychiatry
He must know PTSD & victims mental status
In that case ...Kunal is ...,

PTSD ...victims once out of the abusive relationship
They dread those things reminds them of it
Over here N was still decorating herself and being very much in to Kunal
She was indeed enjoying his advances
So She can't really be one [BR seeing this serial many are already doubting whether to trust a friend or not
I hope people wont distance themselves from real victims tooEdited by Rosh4rose - 5 years ago

Originally posted by: Banjaaran25

if that was the case the writers should have shown Nandini as such.. instead of repetitive crying scenes which made lot many people simply indifferent or plain annoyed now.

she was traumatized in one scene in the very next she is coy and flirty with her best friend's husband in that very friend's home.

abused in one sequence; having dates in next.

she came across as either bipolar or plain selfish. not as a trauma victim.

poor writing or execution.

turning the character into a victim at this juncture is completely pointless since the damage done to the character is so extensive that there is simply now way out. she will be despised regardless.

as the saying goes.. not only the horse has bolted... the barn is burnt too.

do they have two sets of writers and cvs or something?

coz last two episodes and the depth and range (and dialogues and emotions) given to Mauli were on whole new level.

how can the same writer and cvs fail so badly unfolding Nandini on screen?

Agree poor writing and execution.She would hv despised even if she was shown with PTSD becoz our audience are not mature enough to understand PTSD .They only like either pure white or pure black.

Originally posted by: TheMockingBird

Nope Abhinav hv replied to some fan 

Here is what is wrote

If two adults are in relationship,they know the consequences and they will face it.But there is nothing worse than domestic abuse.Nandini is victim of abuse,trauma,PTSD,violence from her husband,hence she has to rely on someone in beginning.Kunal had perfect relationship and mauli was very independent,so he never had to protect mauli.Therefore when he met nandini he fell in love with her while saving her multiple times.It is just law of nature.Rajdeep is another story,he is depiction of insecure men who abuses and is prevalent in our country because nobody reports it.And no body deserve domestic abuse.

Originally posted by: arshi_asya

Till now,  they haven't explored it at all. It's doubtful if they will explore it now. 

Hmm PTSD is senstive subject and needs maturity to handle it which i find lacking in Silsila team.Off topic you are my favorite person on forum becoz you are senstive and sensible.

Originally posted by: TheMockingBird

Nope Abhinav hv replied to some fan 

Here is what is wrote

If two adults are in relationship,they know the consequences and they will face it.But there is nothing worse than domestic abuse.Nandini is victim of abuse,trauma,PTSD,violence from her husband,hence she has to rely on someone in beginning.Kunal had perfect relationship and mauli was very independent,so he never had to protect mauli.Therefore when he met nandini he fell in love with her while saving her multiple times.It is just law of nature.Rajdeep is another story,he is depiction of insecure men who abuses and is prevalent in our country because nobody reports it.And no body deserve domestic abuse.