By Jay Mamtora, AllBollywood.com Staff
December 08, 2006
Ravi Chopra returns with Baabul after his surprise smash Baghban hit the theatres three years ago. In an age where we're dealing with groundbreaking movies a la Omkara, Rang De Basanti, Krrish and to a certain extent D:2, he opts for a social drama focusing on widow re-marriage and emancipation of women. But alas great intentions are not enough to make a great movie. At a time when the validity of marriage itself is being questioned in movies like KANK, Baabul is unquestionably a few years too late.
Balraj (Amitabh Bachchan) and Shobhna Kapoor (Hema Malini) are a wealthy couple who dote on their foreign returned son Avinash (Salman). Your typical picture perfect family that's made even more perfect when Avi meets Millie (Rani) and they predictably fall in love and get married. A few blissful years and a sprog later, Avi dies in a freak accident leaving Millie's life in tethers. Unable to see his daughter-in-law pining away for the void left behind by his son's death, Balraj decides to take matters into his own hands, and to ensure her happiness, attempts to set her up with her childhood friend (and you guessed it her secret admirer) Rajat (Abraham).
How he defies traditions and the social taboos surrounding widow remarriage form the crux of Chopra's sickly sweet and overtly melodramatic fare.
If I'm honest Baabul is a very watchable film. There are some light humorous moments (courtesy Salman's antics), a few memorable songs, great cinematography and a few truly tear inducing moments – yet something somewhere is amiss. While Baghban was a little far fetched it was still convincing due to the Amitabh-Hema chemistry and their sweet romance track. Although Baabul re-creates that unmistakable chemistry, the focus this time is more on addressing a social issue (which technically is ONLY an issue in India and not anywhere else in the world), and in doing that the whole impact of the film is completely diluted.
Of the cast Salman shines and pretty much (almost) outperforms everyone else. There's something very likeable about his impish grin and his rapport with the cast – be it Amitabh, Hema, Rani or the cute little kid that's extremely endearing. Ageless Hema looks stunning yet again and gets a few sequences to show sparks of her talent but undoubtedly deserved a better etched out role.
I'm sorry, I don't know if it's just me but Rani seriously needs to do something different now. It's like she walked straight out of a KANK set to come and shoot for this – only this time wearing specs. Otherwise her look is the same, her clothes are the same and the copious glycerine induced tears that she sheds are – you guessed it – the same! It's all getting a bit boring now. The next in line of disappointments is John. His character fails to evoke any sympathy, his expressions are bland and his pairing with Rani is just not happening.
Right did I forget anyone else? No? Oh yes Amitabh. What can you say about his performance? He's ALWAYS good and he's the best thing in Baabul too. He pretty much holds it together with his author backed role – but as I already implied, that was already a given when I sat down to watch the film.
Besides the front line cast, the supporting cast barring Sharat Saxena is pretty trite. Om Puri is loud and ridiculously over the top. Rajpal Yadav is wasted and Smita Jaykar, Parmeet Sethi, Sarika and Aman Verma are mere space fillers.
It's quite a shame really. Baabul was supposed to end an already successful year in Bollywood with a bang but sadly it doesn't quite get there. It will definitely appeal to the family crowds and rural audiences, but youngsters in the Dhoom frame of mind will most likely ignore it.
In conclusion – a very watchable yet eminently forgettable film.
- Jay Mamtora -
Final Rating: * * .