Why people differenciate between Shiva & Vishnu!???

Share
Posted: 2014-03-26T19:28:57Z

Are Shiva And Vishnu Different?

Some people still talk about the differences between Shiva and Vishnu...yes,I've seen people critisizing Shiva,some Vishnu.Some even critisize Divine Mother,what can be said about them!???I'm unable to describe!???How to increase the devotion of people following a form/sect?By critisizing the other!???Also I've heard something like 'Demigods'!What does this mean?What makes this differentiation!???Why they just don't say Brahma,Vishnu,Shiva and Divine Mother are one and the same!!I feel true Vaishnavites or Shaivites or Devi Worshippers visualize them as one in different forms,for universal wellbeing.

Have you read this Sholoka?

shivaya vishnu roopaya | shiva roopaya vishnave |
shivasya hridayagam vishnum| vishnoschya hridayagam shivha|
yadashhivamayo vishnuhu|yevam vishnumayah shivaha|

** Those who think the trinity and Divine Mother are one plz support my view!Smile


Edited by Stalwart. - 2014-03-26T21:19:28Z
4 Likes this
Posted: 2014-03-26T22:26:30Z
Nice question. The very purpose of myriad forms is, I believe, for our choice. We are free to choose whichever god we like and pray. The bottomline is, everyone is same, so whoever you worship, you are all worshipping the same God, as Krishna rightly put in the Bhagavad Gita.
But the problem with us is, we like competition.
You see, if you are a CSK supporter, and your friend is MI supporter, both of you will always be trying to convince the other that this team is better than the other. Same thing happens here also. Since people choose their favourite God and worship him or her, they try to show people that Vishnu or Shiva is greater. Like for example, me.LOL

So, this is something like democracy. While everyone has different views, it is always healthy for a little competition between groups. But that does not mean that there should be some verbal fight or anything about these topics.
Bottomline: Whoever is greater than whoever, is not the question. They are all greater than us, that is why they are God.
3 Likes this
Posted: 2014-03-27T00:36:45Z

Really beautiful topic, dear friend! I always get emotional while discussing about this LOL. Let me explain my POV Smile.

I believe that God is devotee-lover. Bhaktavatsal. Generally devotees worship God in a specific form of their wish. May it be Purush form, or Prakriti form, or without form (Niraakar). That is called the own Ishta of that devotee. Devotee thinks about only that particular form of his Ishta whenever he thinks about God. So devotee-lover God understands his desire, & Bless him/communicate with him in that desired form. If children is happy, then parents also become happy, so God wants to make His devotee happy by providing his desired Ishta roop. There is no problem in loving one particular form of God as own Ishta, as it helps us to concentrate our mind on that desired roop. We can fix our focus on that roop which increases our devotion. And at the end of journey devotee wants to see his desired form & becomes one with that form.

But, problem arises when devotee starts to think that his Ishta is the best & all other forms are worst. He then forgets that the other forms are also His other forms Who is his Beloved! Being a Krishna devotee if one disrespects Shiv then he is obviously agyaani, ignorant, who does not know that Shiv is none but another form of Krishna only. If Krishna devotee disrespects Shiv then that disrespect will fall on Krishna Himself! This type of devotee can't be a true devotee, I think. True devotee receives this vision from Him so that he can understand that every form is His form only! There is nothing in this universe except God! When a soul ends own journey then can see that like it all other souls are ending their journeys & become one with God. And the fun is: there are many ways to reach God, & if you start walk in one of them, reach at the end, you will find that many other souls are reaching at the same place with you in spite of the case that their ways were different from yours! Then why should we devotees fight with each other when all of us are going to reach at the same point at the end of journey? Rather if we fight with others then it will divert us from the path, then why to take that risk? Whatever path we choose is completely okey until & unless we fall or divert from the path. So let's keep ourselves firm in our chosen paths, & pay respect to all devotees who are in different paths too. When you are meditating, if you get a vision of any Idol other than your Ishta, you must have to take that Idol as your Ishta only who have come in another form suddenly! If you can't think so then you are narrow minded who thinks that God has only one form which is my favorite, or God can't appear to others in any other form, only my Ishta is the true rests are false. But if you are a true devotee & believe that God is Almighty, then why is this limitation? Can the Sarva Shaktimaan not change own form? If you say no, then are not you thinking that His power is limited?  

Sri Ramakrishna said: "The main intention is to climb on the roof (to reach the Ultimate). Now you may do this job by using the straight staircases, or by using a ladder, or by using a rope, even by using a bamboo. (The path is immaterial, keep your goal fixed) But whatever process you adopt, make sure that you will not fall at the midway! Do not dance while you are on the way to roof, if you dance you will fall (dancing = disturbing the devotion & knowledge)."

Also, He said, "If a mother has 5 sons with 5 different tastes, then the mother has to cook the same dish in 5 different ways to please all of them (same God has to take different forms to please different devotees)." But they can't fight with other as all of them are eating dish made by their mother only. Their mother knows which dish suits whom, so children must obey her decision. You are not His only child, right?

I live in Bengal. In Bengali culture, Divine Mother is most commonly worshipped as house deities & also as annual Durga Puja in autumn. We have bhajans of Divine Mother which says, "Don't know whether you are Purush or Prakriti, who can know it unless you Bless us with that realization? You took the form of half Radha & half Krishna in Vrindavan!" another one says, "Mother is Purush sometimes, Prakriti sometimes, & sometimes She becomes Niraakar!" also, "When you take the bow, we call you Ram, when you take the flute, we call you Krishna, when you take Trishul we call you Shiv & o Mother! When you take your sword we call you Kaali!" all song lines I quoted have the same indication.

One more thing I must add here. We do not know about our previous or next births. We might have worshipped God in different form in last birth, also may worship a different form in next one. Will that deviate us from our journey? No, never! But keeping this in mind, we should not disrespect other forms & devotees of those forms. I personally become overwhelmed while I think so! There is a song which expresses my emotion, "who knows in which names have I called you before! Who knows in which form I have made your Idol before! My endless journey towards you, that has not been started today!" I always tell everyone that, call Him with whatever Name you wish, but never stop to call Him! Love Him in whatever form you wish, but never stop to love Him!

And yes, the shloka you have quoted is known to me & it's one of my favorite shlokas! Smile


Edited by Urmila11 - 2014-03-27T00:35:28Z
11 Likes this
Posted: 2014-03-27T00:47:06Z
Relation between Hari and Har has been discussed in this thread also -


'The Adbhut Leelas of Harihara'

http://www.india-forums.com/forum_posts.asp?TID=1636075



Interested members can have a look Smile
6 Likes this
Posted: 2014-03-27T04:46:33Z
Tulsidas ji kehete hain
Jaki rahi bhavana jaisi
Prabhu murat tin dekhi taisi

I think God is one and why only Shiv and Vishnu? All aspects of God are one only 


4 Likes this
Posted: 2014-03-27T09:04:59Z

Nice Topic!

I have a question.All the 18 Puranas were written by Ved Vyas.But why in Srimadbhagavatam Krishna/Vishnu is projected as the Supreme and in Siva Purana, Siva has been described as Lord of all; rest are spoken as servants. Vishnu Purana holds Vishnu on highest pedestal and Shiva and other Gods as servants. For Devi Purana , Devi is Supreme and others totally subordinate; In this way, Shiva Purana describes Siva; Vishnu Purana, Vishnu ; Devi Purana, Devi; Ganesh Purana, Ganesh; Surya, Surya; Vayu, Vayu; etc as author of creation and destruction of universe, but each of them consider the other as created ones, how then a devotee can understand who is the First Cause?
Why did Vyasa present them in a conflicting manner!?Confused

Ok,let us believe Vyasa concentrated on the particular aspect Brahma /Vishnu /Shiva /Devi /Ganesh /Kartikeya, whom he was describing in each text he had written.But why do these puranas while praising their divine character defame and talk low of other embodiments!?!?




Edited by Cool-n-Fresh - 2014-03-27T09:08:32Z
2 Likes this
Posted: 2014-03-27T09:35:00Z
Originally posted by Cool-n-Fresh



Nice Topic!

I have a question.All the 18 Puranas were written by Ved Vyas.But why in Srimadbhagavatam Krishna/Vishnu is projected as the Supreme and in Siva Purana, Siva has been described as Lord of all; rest are spoken as servants. Vishnu Purana holds Vishnu on highest pedestal and Shiva and other Gods as servants. For Devi Purana , Devi is Supreme and others totally subordinate; In this way, Shiva Purana describes Siva; Vishnu Purana, Vishnu ; Devi Purana, Devi; Ganesh Purana, Ganesh; Surya, Surya; Vayu, Vayu; etc as author of creation and destruction of universe, but each of them consider the other as created ones, how then a devotee can understand who is the First Cause?
Why did Vyasa present them in a conflicting manner!?Confused

Ok,let us believe Vyasa concentrated on the particular aspect Brahma /Vishnu /Shiva /Devi /Ganesh /Kartikeya, whom he was describing in each text he had written.But why do these puranas while praising their divine character defame and talk low of other embodiments!?!?


Vyasa is the root cause of all confusion.LOL
I guess this is because, he didn't actually compose the Puranas. It was all in Brahmaloka already, and a portion of this was given to Vyasa, who split it into 4 Vedas and 18 Puranas. To Thoda confusion toh banta hai..
1 Likes this
Posted: 2014-03-27T19:27:25Z

Thanx to all for supporting my view!

Urmila 11 you've made such a beautiful postClap...I will save it!

Debipriya thanx for the link...will refer!
Edited by Stalwart. - 2014-03-27T19:26:04Z
2 Likes this

Related Topics

Topics Author Replies Views Last Post Reply
Love So Pure- a poem on Shiva-Parvati

KrishnaPriyaa   12   1156

KrishnaPriyaa 12 1156 2018-01-21T01:56:05Z MaYa.B
Kailash, the Abode of Lord Shiva

KrishnaPriyaa   74   2617

KrishnaPriyaa 74 2617 2017-12-10T00:32:19Z Vanshikrishna
Vaikunta, the Palace of Lord Vishnu

KrishnaPriyaa   513   8679

KrishnaPriyaa 513 8679 2017-12-05T22:49:58Z Seraphina231
KrishnaPriyaa 120 2645 2016-11-14T19:31:11Z KrishnaPriyaa
Shree Vishnu Chalisa # 1

Nehageet.   1185   15914

Nehageet. 1185 15914 2016-06-27T11:54:02Z mnx12

Topic Info

  • 13 Replies
  • 2312Views

Topic started by Stalwart.

Last replied by srishtisingh

FORUM QUICK JUMP

TOP