i swear all of them were acting

i have a feeling taht it was just to have a high trp as did u noticed

• all of the judges were like ready to put their heads down when mini was going to announce ameys name
• sonu nigam so immaturely left and anu malik didnt leave the mic y?
• after the judges the people suddenly got some energy and started screaming
• ameys mother was very angry but was later cooled down and said yes i believe in destiny y did she in the 1st place created a scene
• 👏 when i guy from the audience asked an important question if we have a re match who is going to sing again so anu malik was like bla bla u dont understand our emotions u this u that he is so stupid
• then at the end y did everyone at once agreed to the decision before amey saying i wont be happy it was like we will create a scene but do nothing if u say something stand up for it take it to the end dont just say and leave

Now this is wut i think happened wut do u guys think 😕😕

Maybe rhe judges are acting..but not everyone is a good actor..specially not someones mom!

Originally posted by: bushiii

i have a feeling taht it was just to have a high trp as did u noticed

• all of the judges were like ready to put their heads down when mini was going to announce ameys name
• sonu nigam so immaturely left and anu malik didnt leave the mic y?
• after the judges the people suddenly got some energy and started screaming
• ameys mother was very angry but was later cooled down and said yes i believe in destiny y did she in the 1st place created a scene
• 👏 when i guy from the audience asked an important question if we have a re match who is going to sing again so anu malik was like bla bla u dont understand our emotions u this u that he is so stupid
• then at the end y did everyone at once agreed to the decision before amey saying i wont be happy it was like we will create a scene but do nothing if u say something stand up for it take it to the end dont just say and leave

Now this is wut i think happened wut do u guys think 😕😕

I know!! especially anu"ji" - he was smirking the entire time...and he yelled at the guy for no reason!!!  (all the guy asked was if the rematch is going to be between 2 or 4 and anu went on a rampage about how he has emotions. pssh yeah right...)

what made me angry was that farah was yelling at the girl for supposedly being rude but hello! anu yelled at that guy who was clearly older than him and FOR NO REASON... besides, I don't see how farah is teaching others manners, I remember that one comment she made about yashashree "you had no personality" - wth

and YES, thank you for pointing out that his mother was angry and tried to leave as well (hey she picked up her purse and coat)... but I don't think she was acting.

and the end, OMG...so lame

this whole fiasco was nothing but demeaning to amey and anuj.

my thoughts...agreed it looked like a pre-plan...now i know why sonu didn't get famous in acting....rsn he is bad actor i guess but glad he took a good decision to stick w/singing...i think when they knew Amey got less votes and needs to be out, thought of taking advantage of the situation and create something big to increase the trps whatever crap that goes with these channels...also amey being a mumbaite, has advantage of home ground too....not sure if karu was in amey's place ystrdy they could have done the same 😕 ....if u notice they showed the girl(anuj's neice) on the camera even b4 both anuj and amey came in bottom 2...i didn't think amey's mom or the audience knew about ....i didn't expect this from sonu as i thought he is the guy very down to earth blah blah...

hi
i even feel that the judges knew amy was going out..
but i dont hink so amey's mother was acting..like me evry1 were shocked abt the result
huzi

hi
i even feel that the judges knew amy was going out..
but i dont hink so amey's mother was acting..like me evry1 were shocked abt the result
huzi

Personally, I think that the entire show has been scripted this way, and it's
just another way to increase their ratings and make more money. Besides,
they're earning Rs.3 per vote, and I'm sure this entire drama will result in
people voting more for the remaining contestants, for fear of them
getting kicked out. After all, one of the hosts said something to that
effect at the end, asking the janta to vote more. It's all just a big drama,
and the way you guys seem to be getting worked up over it, it seems like
their trick has worked.

We should all just calm down, and understand that this is exactly what
the producers want to see. An outburst, more publicity for their show
AND CHANNEL. It really isn't about Amey or Anuj, the judges or the
remaining contestants. I bet the judges knew what they were supposed to
do (walk out and suggest a rematch later) way ahead! Seriously, as far as
the singers are concerned, the good ones have already been noticed, and
they will be signed on by music companies and music directors soon, if
they haven't already been snapped up. I'm sure we'll be seeing their
singles on the charts soon, and hearing their voices in movies.

Indian Idol, like all other tv shows, is just a scripted formatted show, and
the producers will insert shocks such as these to spice things up. It just
goes to show how believing and naive all of us are, lapping it all up, and
reacting just like they would expect us to.

Although, I do wonder what Amey's mother was upset about, when in the
end, she praised Amey for acting the way he did. Was she trying to
control the crowd or something? Telling them to stop protesting? It's all
so confusing, and I think it was all staged, anyway. One big drama to get
higher TRPs.

i dnt fink dey were acting

Edited by **sexynunu** - 18 years ago

i dnt fink dey were acting!! evry1 noes dat amey sings reali well anu, sonu and farah were only shoutin n shit coz dey were shocked eswell lik i wz!!!! dey were only stickin up 4 em wats a big deal jst coz sum ppl dnt lik amey dat dnt mean da judges were rong n dey were acting

i think the audience wasn't acting. definitely not. but i think the producers
and judges and hosts encouraged this kind of behaviour so that they could
have a show of this sort. the way mini mathur was commenting during that
show, it was so lame. in my view, the hosts knew this would happen. and it
was part of their script. the judges as well. i'm definitely not blaming amey's
mother, amey, or anuj's niece or the old man who spoke. they seemed
genuine enough, but i think SONY TV wanted the protest. if the judges
hadn't walked out, do you think people would have screamed and shouted in
the auditorium? the show would have just ended with amey singing,
everyone crying, but it would have stopped there. SONY TV set up the scene
for a protest and it happened. that's what i'm trying to say.

but that's just my view, and you guys can disagree.