The judges giving points after discussion !!

They always seem to discuss what points should be given to each contestant .  I don't think in "Dancing with the Stars" the judges discuss the points. So if JDJ is its desi version and follow the format, they shouldn't  be doing this, imo.  Edited by anjali10 - 12 years ago

I agree with you about the discussion thing?? I mean what else could they discuss after giving comments to the contestant?



they also shouldn't be doing a lot of things if following the DWTS format

-because the show has the be live,
-there has to be a live band performing
-the judges are WAY meaner,unbiased and bitchier on that show than on JDJ
-contestants are more whiner in DWTS (at least of what I saw of Kate Gosselin and Bristol Palin)

I'm glad that the judges aren't over the top mean (I mean its too early to say that but it doesn't seem to change). I wish however that the show was live atleast in India because then they would get rid of some of the editing issues with the playback clips and such....[in the grand premire they showed the SAME damn clip of Krusha clapping and Ragini smiling....the same damn one.....again they showed with Yana and Akhil too]

but maybe since this time its mostly the serial crowd I guess doing a live show might be a bit impossible for them

but one good thing I like about JDJ comparing it to NB...is that the cameras focus all the time on the contestant...in NB the cameras used to focus on the contestant and back to judges.....I like that in JDJ we get the full performance

Edited by Tani91 - 12 years ago

I noticed that too, it is wrong. They should give points independently....otherwise how can it be a fair decision?

It's strange to see all of them give the same score after discussion. Are they trying to seek mutual consent ?

I was gonna post a topic on this then I saw urs. I don't think it is fair to have a discussion before they give the points, it should be done independently. Also, I think that they are being biased. The reason I am saying this is because non-dancers like renuka and shekhar got more points than dancers like sushant and ankita, who, in my opinion, were clearly better. Even Remo said that this show is for non-dancers.

might be wondering if the dance worth giving marks ??... jokes apart , welcome to desi version of DWTS, when it comes to indian stuff , we agree to everything every one disagree format , its dead funny , even after long eye to eye sort of discussions the marks r different 

This didn't happen in previous seasons. The judges never discussed what scores to give. I wonder why it is happening in this season!