Round 2: Alisha Chinai - Page 2

Originally posted by: Shreyacool

Its quite sad to see singers like alisha getting 2 or 3 from some people, I know the song isnt that good, but it shouldnt get such low score also. It is my request to risingabove, please donot conduct the poll 10-1, instead do it 10-5 or might be 10-4. Because I feel all of the singers are well established & donot deserve to get below 5. People giving 1s & 2s & 3s, means it is an insult to a talented singer.

Don't worry. The Average Audience Score Computer I use deals with this odd low scores. They are still counted though. But trust me, everything is as fair as possible with my Avg. Audience Score computer. Only someone999 knows how it exactly works. But things go well.

Well if a poll is created for all members to vote...People will vote according to their subective hearing, knowledge,experience and likes...No one should question someone's response....

Honestly, I have been liberal, very liberal in giving her a 6 just because of the effort that she had to put to save a sinking ship. Honestly, this is what I would call a waste of talent. Alisha is a superb singer and her throw of voice is one that deserves  much, much better tracks. Not this one.
She tries her best, but falls flat in virtually every area. I mean, its just a song that comes, goes and nobody even not have noticed it..sad!  This track would have worked in 1970s, not today.

She is one underrated singer who's true potential is not yet being exploited in the right manner. She needs just the right composers because she can bring something "different" to playback singing with her unique mezzo voice.

This is my POV, a bit harsh, hope that her fans are not disappointed.

Originally posted by: Dabulls23

Well if a poll is created for all members to vote...People will vote according to their subective hearing, knowledge,experience and likes...No one should question someone's response....

 

No one gives her low rating just for the heck...I am sure there is a reason for it...Than again judges will be voting too and the average between this poll and judges votes too...So it is all cewl...There should not be any issues...

 

My 2 cents..

All members should vote as they like, their wish, but thats not what I am pointing out. But there are a few people who purposely rate the song very low without even listening to it.

Hhhmmmm.. an up-beat song. Let's see now..

The starting is awful; the electronic effect tries to cover it up, but weakens the impact. The singing goes on flat, no as such difficulty in singing. The music is catchy that is one of the reason of its popularity. Otherwise, there is nothing worth admiring in the singing except the fact that the expressions are fairly apt with the situation of the song.

I would have given it a 4, but will give an extra mark for the naughty expression introduced in this song by Alisha, which was of course, quite appropriate. So, my score for this song sums up to be 5 out of 10.

this is a disappointing song from Alisha... if it was another song (like tinka tinka), it would surely have gotten better votes...

for me, it doesn't merit anything over 4 out of 10... average singing would get a 5, but this is less than average... it has nothing to do with whether alisha is a great singer or not, but only for this particular song... she seems disinterested herself... it should sound seductive, but the feeling is lost somewhere in the song.. the only salvaging factor is the fast pace and the music...

this is merely 'my' opinion of her song.. so fans need not take so much offense whether their favorite is getting less marks... those who have marked it low must have had their reasons.. it is not necessary that they put down their opinions and reasons for their low or high marks.. :)

also, as risingabove said, they have a fair system to account for the votes... if you want audience to also vote, you have to consider that not everyone has got to like, and similarly, not everyone need to dislike... please respect the views of others too, whether they coincide with yours or not.. :)

Originally posted by: Illogical

this is a disappointing song from Alisha... if it was another song (like tinka tinka), it would surely have gotten better votes...

for me, it doesn't merit anything over 4 out of 10... average singing would get a 5, but this is less than average... it has nothing to do with whether alisha is a great singer or not, but only for this particular song... she seems disinterested herself... it should sound seductive, but the feeling is lost somewhere in the song.. the only salvaging factor is the fast pace and the music...

1)  this is merely 'my' opinion of her song.. so fans need not take so much offense whether their favorite is getting less marks...

 

2)those who have marked it low must have had their reasons..

 

3)it is not necessary that they put down their opinions and reasons for their low or high marks.. :)

also, as risingabove said, they have a fair system to account for the votes... if you want audience to also vote, you have to consider that not everyone has got to like, and similarly, not everyone need to dislike...

 

4) please respect the views of others too, whether they coincide with yours or not.. :)