what sadhna is doing, its WRONG!!! - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

36

Views

4k

Users

20

Likes

119

Frequent Posters

-SalShah4eva- thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Elite Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 15 years ago
#11

Originally posted by: --Anu--

Sadhana is a wise young woman but she is so naive and innocent. This is how her character has been sketched from the beginning.
She has lied or hid the truth many times (as per the circumstances) not to hurt others and her intentions are always pure. She ends up causing self pain due to her selfless actions but she never complains or even wastes a single minute in self pity. Instead she moves on with the flow and makes something good out of it.

I couldnt more agree with u
u said everything i wanted to say👏
Sweet-Violet thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#12

Originally posted by: KiNnY-pArTnEr

I couldnt more agree with u

u said everything i wanted to say👏



Thanks dear.
Omshanti1111 thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#13

Originally posted by: --Anu--

Sadhana is a wise young woman but she is so naive and innocent. This is how her character has been sketched from the beginning.
She has lied or hid the truth many times (as per the circumstances) not to hurt others and her intentions are always pure. She ends up causing self pain due to her selfless actions but she never complains or even wastes a single minute in self pity. Instead she moves on with the flow and makes something good out of it.



She is not naive, she is just compulsive to give Ragini happiness. She is a true mom for Ragini, her actions prove her affection towards Ragini. She tries to get and do the best for Ragini, thats the only flaw of her character.

Sweet-Violet thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#14

Originally posted by: Omshanti1111



She is not naive, she is just compulsive to give Ragini happiness. She is a true mom for Ragini, her actions prove her affection towards Ragini. She tries to get and do the best for Ragini, thats the only flaw of her character.

I am not talking about her compulsion to give Ragini happiness. Its her behavior in general...she is too simple.."Sedhi-Sadhi. She doesn't know much about "Duniya Dari"...so she gets used and abused by everyone else.

-shabz- thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#15

Originally posted by: *queenme*

i dont think sadhna should have let ragini win the competition.. she worked so hard to get where she did... and one selfish comment by ragini made her forget all of it.. which is really sad.. i think ur right that sadhna needs to have more self respect..however, i do understand that her case is a bit more complex because in order to be a strong and confidant person.. u need to recieve that feeling from somewhere and so far nobody on this show has given her any kind of respect.. im surprised that she is coping so welll given the things people have said and done to her.. anyone could go crazy.. but i feel it was wrong of her to lose on purpous... losing on purpose signifies that her sisters happiness is of utmost importance to her... even more important than saving someone's life... thats how i interpreted it.. if she hadnt lost... she would still be married.. and things would eventually settle with ragini once she found out why sadhna competed in the first place...

u said it yourself.....her sister happiness is of utmost importance to her.....isnt that why she got married to alekh in the first place......for her sisters happiness....she saw ranvir as a suitable groom and married alekh....didnt even think twice about it..........so why would it be different now............she knew she had the option of vasu if she looses.....so she did.....if vasu hadnt offered her money for divorce maybe then she would have not lost on purpose.....because the prize money would have been her only option........so again she sacrifices her marriage to bring her sister happiness.............dont u get it.........she lives and dies for ragini happiness.😊
Omshanti1111 thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#16

Originally posted by: unhappyviewer

u said it yourself.....her sister happiness is of utmost importance to her.....isnt that why she got married to alekh in the first place......for her sisters happiness....she saw ranvir as a suitable groom and married alekh....didnt even think twice about it..........so why would it be different now............she knew she had the option of vasu if she looses.....so she did.....if vasu hadnt offered her money for divorce maybe then she would have not lost on purpose.....because the prize money would have been her only option........so again she sacrifices her marriage to bring her sister happiness.............dont u get it.........she lives and dies for ragini happiness.😊



there cannot be question about Sadhna's unconditional love for Ragini..its like asking the sun to prove that indeed it rises in the east.
I dont understand why Sadhna needs to be criticised, Sadhna's criticism can never prove Ragini right...

suman2 thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#17
Being Selfless is one thing and being logical and handling life in a practical manner is one thing. Sadhna is a good human being but I didnt like her during this Mamiji sickness episode. Here are few things -
1 - She didnt tell anyone about Mamiji's sickness and promised the doctor she will arrange money. By this she unintentionally worsen Mamiji's condition. If Ragini would have known this she would have given this money and her mother would have been better.
2 -What if something would have happened to Kaushalya ji in those days when Sadhna was trying to arrange money ?
3 - Why didnt she tell Ragini ? I mean whatever differences she has with her, she has no right to take away the RIGHT of a daughter. A daughter should have right to serve her parents in time of need. If anyone would have hide something so serious about mother (even though I am going through my own share of pain) I would have never forgiven that person. Very few children get chance to serve their parents and I wont allow anyone to take the right away from me.
4- Losing in the dance competition ?? Why ?? Ragini would have felt bad ..thats fine..She can explain it to her..that its for her own Mom. I agree to the topic starter that there is something called Self dignity and by signing the divorce paper she lost it.
This is my POV and as I said earlier..being selfless is one thing..being good is one thing..but being foolish is another.
Suman
479445 thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#18

Originally posted by: pricey28

i am NOT saying she is a bad human being, in fact, she is a very good human being, i think we would all agree on that. but what sadhna is doing, MUCH of it (NOT ALL OF IT), is WRONG!!!! i really hope no woman will ever follow her example in thinking what she's doing is righteous. i'm not saying its bad to be self-less or to sacrifice for others, but its also not good to have no self-respect, no self-esteem, both of which, sadi has absolutely NONE of!!! i hope after watching this show, no woman ever feels that this is what we're supposed to do, what sadhna is doing. we (women) should feel empowered, we should feel that we have the right to stand up for ourselves when needed. being selfless is a great and necessary quality, but being selfless doesn't equal having no pride for yourself nor does it equal staying quiet when everyone treats you like dirt. i remember once reading a member say here, "why doesn't sadhna have any happiness...?" wanna know why, cause sadhna HERSELF won't let her have any happiness!!!! forget vasu, she, herself is her greatest enemy!!!

@RED: Sadhna is the only character in Bidaai or any of RS ji's production to have the most and growing amount of self-respect. She has joined the job, and she is not a dog to Mallika. She was not a begger infront of Vasu or even Guru Ma. Well she went those places, gave her mind at times ... and had very straight conversation.
Guru Ma was her teacher, so she respected her. But she didnt bow down to abuse or misbehavior.
Sadhna gave Vasu some good tough words ... she did not let Vasu bully her ...

She went to try and earn the money ... she couldnt ... she came in fair terms to Vasu. It was not begging ... although she was desperately trying to contact (we all do at times when we are at the grunt) ... and Vasu gave her the money as per an exchange... SIMPLE. Yes, Sadhna sold her soul ... but I think you better see Baghban. Sadhna, being an orphan and cared my Sharma Ji ... has some form of innate obligation ... She also keeps the respect of her deceased parents ... she gave Sharma ji million times more in return of his care. in all forms (be it monetary or love/respect/care/sacrifice for his entire family etc etc etc).

Sadhna still has the courage to stand for herself, earn her a living, and help Sharma's in their greatest needs.... WITH RESPECT!

@BLUE: No one dare treat her like dirt. When you walk the straight and rightful path .. thorns may pierce your feet .... does that mean you are meaningless and weak?...NO ... the thord is a part of dirt, its work is to do dirty and painful things ... its not human to act like a thorn ... Sadhna doesnt sit and try to pierce the thorn ... instead she tried to help herself take the thorn away, or to try and clear the path so that no one else can get injured by the thorn....AND WALKS FORWARD WITH HONOR AND LOVE AND GRACE....


SADHNA CAN NEVER BE WRONG. SIMPLE.

Silentsoul thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 15 years ago
#19

Originally posted by: pricey28

i am NOT saying she is a bad human being, in fact, she is a very good human being, i think we would all agree on that. but what sadhna is doing, MUCH of it (NOT ALL OF IT), is WRONG!!!! i really hope no woman will ever follow her example in thinking what she's doing is righteous. i'm not saying its bad to be self-less or to sacrifice for others, but its also not good to have no self-respect, no self-esteem, both of which, sadi has absolutely NONE of!!! i hope after watching this show, no woman ever feels that this is what we're supposed to do, what sadhna is doing. we (women) should feel empowered, we should feel that we have the right to stand up for ourselves when needed. being selfless is a great and necessary quality, but being selfless doesn't equal having no pride for yourself nor does it equal staying quiet when everyone treats you like dirt. i remember once reading a member say here, "why doesn't sadhna have any happiness...?" wanna know why, cause sadhna HERSELF won't let her have any happiness!!!! forget vasu, she, herself is her greatest enemy!!!




I agree...simple....to the worse..Sadhna was always without self respect....whatever....its called....but I dont preach this thing .....for any damn reason on this earth....She should have told Ranvir not Ragini...about Mamiji health...when Ranveer can ask for help...she too....but no....but as charcter...designed by creatives....we cnat do much about it....they go according to it only....But definitely I really hope no women should follow her ...because she has no self respect.....love for sister is one thing...respect for elders is one thing....but self respect is another thing...anyway......I dont find her self less attitude without any self respect as good quality....
Edited by kuls11 - 15 years ago
Veritas thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#20
I agree with the topic maker,this was one time Sadhna could have stood upto Vasu.
Sadi is lawfully wedded to Alekh.
She had every legal right to go an live in Rajvansh house.
She had a right to an alimony.wht she begged of Vasu she could have demanded.
Its not about the money.Its about standing up for your right.If she had done any of that she would have forced Alekh's stance long before.
Kootniti karne walon se kootniti se hi pesh aana chahiye.
And for all those people who are singing paens to selflessness.

The kurukshetra war would have never happened if the pandavas didn't fight for their right.
Galat baat ko sehna galat karne ke barabar hai.
Sadi is insulted ,browbeaten and tortured because she allows it.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".