Why is sadhna doing this:Mod's Final Note on PG16 - Page 5

Created

Last reply

Replies

121

Views

9.6k

Users

28

Likes

332

Frequent Posters

chinky801 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#41
Seeing mamaji's condition, she choose not no reveal, I think pure logic is there..

And ragini even didn't want to see her face , let alone to think that she will talk to her.


She did what any sensible person would have done at her place..
dharaa thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 15 years ago
#42
@agun, if Ragini loses deliberately it wont surely be for kaushi ji's treatment cuz the treatment can happen even if Ragini wins. So that toh def wont be the reason and if Ragini is losing to make Sadhna win then there must be some really strong reason behind it. I just hope, the CT's compensate for every illogical things they showed. I want SaGini reunion to be shown in a very special way


Edited by dharaa - 15 years ago
Sweet-Violet thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#43

Originally posted by: agun



I agree with you on Vinu's behaviour.....it is definetly not acceptable....but Sadhna being wrong is compeltely not true in my POV.

Any girl in her position would never go for help to a family in which every member have used her and thrown her out....Why should she go to Ragini when Ragini doesnt want to see her. Vinu who knows the whole situation should have informed Ragini. Sadhna as any person with an iota of self respect grabbed at the oppurtunity of the dance comepetition and is working hard to make it work. Only because she thinks about her sister (even now after all the drama) she made sure her sister's name is not in the list of participants.

Ragini should have followed up on her mother after she saw her sick....yes she was upset when she knew that her mom didnt tell her but what did she do about it....she didnt follow on her...visit her or even talk to her brother or father about it.....

Why do we expect only Sadhna to beg and be humiliated in Bidaai for other's happiness...is that the only way......I am very happy that for a change she thought to not beg any body for money...



Couldn't agree more. Lovely post Anu.

Sadhana entering the dance competition was a positive signal/sign from Almighty. She saw the ad in the newspaper clipping that had prasad given to her by a coworker. Then Vasu took her to the same mandir where she got married to Alekh and asked her to sign the divorce papers. It was Radha-Krishan temple....a symbol of love and purity.(Ref Bani)

@bold: Very well said. 👏
vishmewell thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#44
Dhara, let's connect the dots here...

Originally posted by: dharaa

@vishmewell, Sadhna didnt even told them about kaushi ji's illness...remember? Only that evening. The same night Vinu and Sadhana had a looong discussion about Kaushi's condition and the money part. Vinu confesses that he mortgaged the house to buy a house for Malti. So, Vinu knows he has to raise money, ifnot ghar ka girvi, office se loan tho ek optio tha hi...

When no one other than her knew about Kaushi ji, they only did not know there was a clot in the brain. But they do know she is very sick. Chal phir nahi paarahi hai and she faints ?
how could they inform Ragini? This is again wrong because Vinu knew it.
And she herself stopped Vinu from telling anyone about the ghar ki girvi part and of course if mamaji knew about it, then he would first want to mortgage his house. That was proved right today's epi mamaji wanted to girvi the house. Sadhna saved the day for Vinu again. So instead of created more problems, Vinu and Sadhna decided to raise money. Sadhana is trying to do everything to get money and Vinu did nothing.
so why would Vinu do that??? Why? Sadhana never uttered Ragini's name even once. because his mother is dying and as an older brother he had the duty. Not Sadhna. She was strictly ordered by Vasu and Kaushi not to even utter Raginis name.
Mamaji who stays with kaushi ji 24/7 didnt get to know about Kaushi ji, he is with her 24/7 thabhi unko ehsaas hone chaahiyetha ki something is really bad. Waise patha chaltha bhi, ghar me ghar ko leka hungama. That would have killed Kaushi right there because Dr. told Kaushi ko tension naho hone chahiye. Thats why Sadhana suggested Vinu to bring Malti and munna home so that if she is happy, problem jaldi badegi nahi at least until after the dance competition.
so how can we expect Ragini to understand that in few minutes??? She did ask them about kaushi ji, but they told that she has BP problems. You agree that they simply told Kaushi ko BP problem hai... person who is suffeing from BP should know very well that is not due to BP. They don't feel nausea. They chose not to tell Ragini because they wanted her to be khush w/Ranvir.



So we now connected all the dots and answered all your questions just the way things happened and I did not add anything that did not happen? Isme Sadhana ki kya role hai? She is taking the grunt for everyone's selfishness and well being. People told her to keep her mouth shut and even slapped her to do it. She is quiet.
agun thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#45

Originally posted by: dharaa

No one is blaming Sadhna here. We are just saying she could have informed everyone spcly Mamaji and Ragini as soon as she got the news. Ragini would def nt hv insulted her, cuz this time it was abt her mother's life. Things become easier when all our close ones are with us. One cant win every situations as a one man army.



I agree that she should have informed Mamaji but Ragini....no way!!!...why should she do that...Mamaji being a self respected man whouldnt have accepted their money anyway...more after they throw-ed Sadhna out in a most humiliating way. you have to remember that Sadhna is a stranger for Ragini and the rajvanshes...she should be the last person to blame for not telling them.

Her brother should have informed because he has nothing better to do....he should also arrange the money...he used his dad's house for his own flat....he is plain selfish....only by talking good things one person doesnt become good...actions/deeds/karma should be good.
kinny_ranvir thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#46
Ragini knows her mom has BP problem..not some major problem...so y blame her for not visiting personally her mom again..infact when she came 2 know , she felt bad and 2 make her mom happy n content..she danced n twisted her ankle by mistake...so y blame her...

Sadhana didnot intend 3 tell any1 ..not mamaji,not vinu...she thot she cud manage 5 lakhs within 4 -5 days all by herself...funny..
If she had told mamaji n Ragini at first place initially , though they feel bad n worry n hyper intially, by maintaining the self respect of mamaji, they cud have found many ways 2 arrange the money like loans, debts even competion..without taking from their sasural...that wud lead 3 the re-union of the sisters as well without degrading of the characters of the sisters... .purely maayka problem solved by both sisters...
vishmewell thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#47

Originally posted by: dharaa

@agun, if Ragini loses deliberately it wont surely be for kaushi ji's treatment cuz the treatment can happen even if Ragini wins. So that toh def wont be the reason and if Ragini is losing to make Sadhna win then there must be something really strong reason behind it. I just hope, the CT's compensate for every illogical things they showed. I want SaGini reunion to be shown in a very special way



@dhara: The reason why Ragini would lose gracefully if knows the cause Sadhana is there, is only because her bauji will not accept bheek from Vasu. He is vusoolonka bada pakka. This way her sister ki mehnath ki rupay se ilaaj karaajenge.
Veritas thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#48
If mamaji comes to know about the house what would b the worst that could happen.
He would be disgusted with Vinu's behavior which he already is,so no big loss there.
And Kaushi went and mortgaged the house herself .
I think mamji should have been informed .he would have definitely found another way.

And everyone talks about mamaji 's self respect,but he has self respect only in the case of Rajvansh's.
Didn't Sadhna spend her 10 lakhs on mamaji.
when did he try to return it.
Sadhna is his neice not daughter and an orphan at that and also was married to a retard on the top of that.
If mamaji had any self respect he would have tried to return that money or put upsomething for Sadhna's future safety.
Edited by Veritas - 15 years ago
--Pinky-- thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 15 years ago
#49

Originally posted by: agun



Dharaa - I want the creatives to think about a good way to redeem Ragini before their union.....that is the call of the hour....Even if Ragini loses the mahotsav to make Sadhna win for the money...she is not doing it for Sadhna..She is doing it for her mother....so there is no way they can redeem her by just showing that. Ragini has dismissed a 20 year old relation and there should be solid reason why she wants that relation back....a person cannot disown thier sibling one fine day say them 100 things and cannot hug them the next day saying "Sorry"...it wont work that way in reality.



It will still make the love from Ragini's side "conditional", and will not help redeem her character, in fact it will do just the opposite.

If Ragini already knows about Kaushi's illness and Vasu's plan then she should have anonymously deposited the amount needed in the hospital. Ragini's aim of going for the dance competition is Ranvir.



Sweet-Violet thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#50

Originally posted by: kinny_ranvir

Ragini knows her mom has BP problem..not some major problem...so y blame her for not visiting personally her mom again..infact when she came 2 know , she felt bad and 2 make her mom happy n content..she danced n twisted her ankle by mistake...so y blame her...

Sadhana didnot intend 3 tell any1 ..not mamaji,not vinu...she thot she cud manage 5 lakhs within 4 -5 days all by herself...funny..
If she had told mamaji n Ragini at first place initially , though they feel bad n worry n hyper intially, by maintaining the self respect of mamaji, they cud have found many ways 2 arrange the money like loans, debts even competion..without taking from their sasural...that wud lead 3 the re-union of the sisters as well without degrading of the characters of the sisters... .purely maayka problem solved by both sisters...



Sadhana was about to tell Vinu the same day but Mallika called her on the phone and she went to the party. She told him before leaving that she wants to talk him about some important thing. Kaushi was also in the same room.
By the time she came back from the party, Vinu had already read the medical report. So Sadhana had full intention to discuss this with Vinu and arrange for money with his help.
Edited by --Anu-- - 15 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".