2nd Feb Episode Update - Page 5

Originally posted by: realmusic

But Ayesha had the best comments for Hema. What does that say? And so did Subash Ghai. I read that he even told Hema in the elimination round that he would give him a chance. A director of his stature won't commit to something like that on national TV if he is not sure.

Please rest your case. It is pure regional voting, nothing more, nothing less.

I response to bold face sentence, Do not count on promises of all these guys. Maximum thing they can do for new comers is to give chance in chorus. Do you guys think HR will give more than 2-3 songs to Vinit? My answer is never. Do you think AS will give more than 1-2 songs to Hema and Himani? My answer is never unless these two improved a lot. So do not believe on other, those are just political statements, in every election politician promises thousand of thing but never fulfill those. It is not only politics very few people in general life fulfill promises. Police start their job by vowing everything but they do entirely opposite.

Originally posted by: arrthegreatest

Hey guys im new here

Its sad to see a great talent like Hema go. I personally felt he did not have many pronunciation problems and only made a few mistakes. Aadesh stresses the fact that he has an original voice which is true. I think he will succeed in the future. My favorite performances were 'Saathiya' and 'Hai Rama' both ARR compositions. Hopefully Hema works with ARR in the future because I think the results would be brilliant.

Everybody has their original voice, nobody is singing in forefather's voice. If one can sing in other's voice there would be thousand of Rafi and Mukesh in each and every city of India. All these statement of AS or HR are just a marketing strategy. Every time I see in promotion of a movie, actor/actress claims their movie is entirely different but when you go to theater, it proved to be disaster. Accept whose which you feel, do not listen these statements of mentors.

Originally posted by: fm_qazi

Originally posted by: realmusic

To each his own. He sure has touched my wife's heart and mine. We play his
songs on the car stereo, and he sounds better than on TV. Quite often we
felt that he sang the songs better than the original singer. He sure touched
(eg.) Diya Mirza's heart and many more. Agree, that he could improve even
more. His potential is unbelievable.

Originally posted by: gramkuma

I am a Hema fan but I think his over all performance in
the last round was not up to the mark. Debo and Vineet were clearly better
than him in the last round.
Folks these are all elimination rounds. Based on past performances I would
surely vote for Hema, but this round it makes sense that he was eliminated.
For the next round I would wait an see how the two perform. It has to be
taken on a round by round basis.

Originally posted by: simranlaks_2005

I disagree, except for Karma song Hema excelled in all others!!

i disagree too. In any case, how come all of a sudden we think the person who made a small mistake (never in sur/taal) has to go? What about the many mistakes that came from the previous rounds? Did Nihira get eliminated because she made mistakes? Were Debo and Vineet flawless to make it this far? Sorry, I just don't agree.