Created

Last reply

Replies

61

Views

8.7k

Users

44

Frequent Posters

HariOm thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#31
Totally agree Vineet is a poor imitation of Sonu Nigam. In the Republic Day episodes his renditions of Ab tumhare havale and Jindagi maut na ban jaye, were horrible. Pronounciation of Sathiyon Yaaron, as Saathiyawn and Yaarawn is unacceptable. Hema's mistakes are nothing compared to Vineet's. Vineet sings nasal like his mentor.
Less ssaid the better about Debo, one with raw untrained voice. His voice is not stable.
When he sings looks as if he's struggling. Hemachandra and Nihira are the actual winners of this competition.
fm_qazi thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#32
Funny part if you do not count the home zone votes so you should tell people not to vote in SRGMP from that zone in the start of the Agnipriksha and I think in the beginning each of 12 contestants belongs to some zone, so tell all public not to vote entirely. So stop the voting concept in SRGMP.
aaabbb thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#33

Originally posted by: HariOm


Less ssaid the better about Debo, one with raw untrained voice. His voice is not stable.
When he sings looks as if he's struggling. Hemachandra and Nihira are the actual winners of this competition.

Did you watch Ayesha's reaction when Debu was singing "O hum dum". It seems like she is gonna start dancing soon she was enjoying so much. Hema's pronounciation is very bad in all song. He has to work on his hindi if want to do playback in Bollywood for long time. He is the best technically but he cannot perform when he is nervous and that is fact.

Shaan is always graceful to everyone's performance so leave his remarks apart. He is the one who is keeping these contestants going. He is their morale support.

I am not a fan of Debu either, I only liked Nihira the best and no one can replace her.

HariOm thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#34
Who cares what Ayesha Takia thinks. All she said was same things as others followed by a "God Bless You". Hemu may have diction problems, yet his voice quality is far superior than that of Debo and Vineet. He sounds like a trained singer whereas Debo does not.
Debo singing 1 song (O Humdum) well out of so many is not a great feat. It was a fast paced song, thats why Ayesh was dancing. Debo's singing capabilities, rather lack of them, were shown in other slow songs.
arrthegreatest thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#35
Hey guys im new here

Its sad to see a great talent like Hema go. I personally felt he did not have many pronunciation problems and only made a few mistakes. Aadesh stresses the fact that he has an original voice which is true. I think he will succeed in the future. My favorite performances were 'Saathiya' and 'Hai Rama' both ARR compositions. Hopefully Hema works with ARR in the future because I think the results would be brilliant.
realmusic thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#36
But Ayesha had the best comments for Hema. What does that say? And so did Subash Ghai. I read that he even told Hema in the elimination round that he would give him a chance. A director of his stature won't commit to something like that on national TV if he is not sure.

Please rest your case. It is pure regional voting, nothing more, nothing less.



Originally posted by: aaabbb

Did you watch Ayesha's reaction when Debu was singing "O hum dum". It seems like she is gonna start dancing soon she was enjoying so much. Hema's pronounciation is very bad in all song. He has to work on his hindi if want to do playback in Bollywood for long time. He is the best technically but he cannot perform when he is nervous and that is fact.

Shaan is always graceful to everyone's performance so leave his remarks apart. He is the one who is keeping these contestants going. He is their morale support.

I am not a fan of Debu either, I only liked Nihira the best and no one can replace her.

ajooni thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#37
thanks ankitat.I can now watch the episode tomorrow night without bawling.
gujju_boi_4eva thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#38
Thanks alot for posting info..would u mind posting vedio for us.please, 😭
somia thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#39
Hema is the best... and i hope he will be the most successful star amongs 12 and vineet is the worst singer and i don't care if debo wins because of regional votes as long as vineet and himesh is thrown out 😡
fm_qazi thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#40

Originally posted by: realmusic



What bad singing? Are you referring to the one flaw in the first Republic Day song? Did you hear his almost perfect renditions of difficult songs on the Subhash Ghai/Ayesha Takia show?

How about Debo and Vinit's screwups - missed words and missed sur, etc.?

Look, this comes down to regional votes, and the fact is that the South does not watch Zeetv as much as the North and NE do. Hema beat out a lot of other singers due to his superior talent.

There is nothing even Vinit can do to beat Debo. Debo is a very flawed singer, but NE is going to carry him to the victory. Those are the facts.

Rendition is not the only thing in playback singing. Being perfect technically is good but not the best thing. To me except one Jogi song from Taal not a single song of Hema touched my heart. He is technically perfect but he never give the feel of the song. If you want to judge the singer come out of the TV room and then listen the song by keeping your eyes closed. If you are missing feel of the song then singing is useless for public, public like only those singing which is close to them. It is my observation. But I wish best luck for Hema, he is very young and whole lot of year before him and I pray he establishes himself as a playback singer in bollywood because it is very difficult thing. All 3 needs to do lot of hard work to establish themselves.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".