Terrible Behavior! - Page 2

Originally posted by: scs07

i agree... it may all well have been scripted out...

If it is scripted out, I will be sooo mad. What do they think they are playing at?

Originally posted by: MonicA#1Actress

If it is scripted out, I will be sooo mad. What do they think they are playing at?

TRPs... i dont think we have the right to pass our judgement and hang the three without giving them a fair trial... the truth may never come out at all... best for us is to judge singing and just singing...

Originally posted by: scs07

TRPs... i dont think we have the right to pass our judgement and hang the three without giving them a fair trial... the truth may never come out at all... best for us is to judge singing and just singing...

I agree with you, I think they should redo everything. I personally think Debo did a good job, considering he sang a very difficult song. But even he wasn't cut out for the top 3, the others should not have acted so childish.

I think each singer should do like 5 performances and they should at least give 3 out of 5 good performances to make it into the Top 12 or Top 4 or 3. It would make more sense and we can see which singer has the potential to go far.

Originally posted by: MonicA#1Actress

I honestly felt Himani and Vinit and the other guys whos name I forgot were being unfair. Debo is a good singer and he pulled off Dholi Taro very nicely.

I personally feel those three are acting like kids. This is a competition, it doesn't always go as you want it to. I think they were beong childish and weren't able to hande the fact that they all weren't going to won. And only of them will anyways. There is only one winner. I say they should grow up. Poor Debo looked so upset. He did deserve to be in the Top 3 and I feel that those three are trying to get him out unfairly.

I am sorry, but that is not how a competition works. They should be able to handle rejection and the shock of not winning or making it into the final round. Sooner or later, only one will be left standing. When the other 2 realize they won't win, will they also walk out and act childish? Someone should let them know that they can't make the competition go their way. Only one of the thre will win anyways. They can't keep doing this "Oh if I don"t win or make it I will walk out". I say they should walk out now, because I am very well aware that they will create the same problem when the final winner is announced.

I am sorry, but That is life.

how will u justify the walkout of ID ??? some ppl say he was heart broken when nihira got out.....then why did'nt he stage a walk out on the same day when nihira was out ?

as an elder he should set an example to the youngsters by being brave....we all know nihira is very good ...but the format of the show is such....its decided by voting not by their singing talent....

Originally posted by: samdara

how will u justify the walkout of ID ??? some ppl say he was heart broken when nihira got out.....then why did'nt he stage a walk out on the same day when nihira was out ?

as an elder he should set an example to the youngsters by being brave....we all know nihira is very good ...but the format of the show is such....its decided by voting not by their singing talent....

I know, and this is what the result will be from Public voting. ID shoudl have set a better example, but now it is too late.

Those three should realize that only one of them will win anyways. There is no use acting like cowards and backing out.

What is, let's say, Himani is one of the singers chosen for the final 2, what is the other two decide to walk about because they can't handle having one or the other leave?

They can't do this because it is unfair, and it proves none of them are mentally prepared that only one of those three will win.

Originally posted by: MonicA#1Actress

I know, and this is what the result will be from Public voting. ID shoudl have set a better example, but now it is too late.

Those three should realize that only one of them will win anyways. There is no use acting like cowards and backing out.

What is, let's say, Himani is one of the singers chosen for the final 2, what is the other two decide to walk about because they can't handle having one or the other leave?

They can't do this because it is unfair, and it proves none of them are mentally prepared that only one of those three will win.

i dont think they did the walkout because they're not mentally prepared, they just probably thought that a contestant was getting votes for the wrong reason and only from a specific region. the point is as long as debo is in then it would be unfair if any of them got out before he did. everyone knows in the end only one person will win. but like i said before too that ULFA could be the big reason behind it. who knows

from what i see voting concept is a big mistake and bigger mistake is announcing the percentage of votes they got from different regions....this brought in the regional feeling into the show....otherwise if it simply announced that so much percentage votes for A and so much for B and so much for C....and select the max one....

Originally posted by: samdara

from what i see voting concept is a big mistake and bigger mistake is announcing the percentage of votes they got from different regions....this brought in the regional feeling into the show....otherwise if it simply announced that so much percentage votes for A and so much for B and so much for C....and select the max one....

yep that's true. but leaving it all to audience doesnt work either since best talent loses out

All thats been said is true.But did you notice something ?
Wasnt there a time gap between the 3 coming onto the stage and declaring the walk out and GS ji coming down to shout at them. Frankly, a good 10- 15 min had elapsed and in that cacophony GS (as Dwarakanath had pointed out) could have turned off the cameras the moment he knew something was amiss.- unless all this was scripted.
Beleive me i dont think that the 3 would do it on their own. They wouldnt dare antagonise their mentors or Gajji who are dangling so many golden carrots in front of them.
I thought AS and HR did not look the least surprised when they announced the walkout.They also probably planted that lady who shouted Assam ki voice etc.
What was so mindblowing about that duuuuumb remark?

You all are talking about the decision by the audience. Are we really deciding the participants. Since Nihira was thrown out, I really doubt public voting system is really working We can't check the estimates each week, it could easily be faked. Also, the childish behavior should be scripted and inspired by Ismail Darbar ji. It's like other mentors taking revenge on him and poor Debu.