Point to be noted - Page 4

Originally posted by: delena90

if u are a muslim then be in india middle east america ur dressing will be same it depends on culture of different countries but this short skirt no one will allow this

You do not speak for everyone.

Some Muslims don't wear this, others do. You cannot generalize and say every Muslim believes the same as you.
it is not what i believe it is what is written in our holy book quran n there it is written u can't wear such dresses which will show any part of your body without hands face n feet n if a muslim is saying no to that that means he is not muslim by keeping muslim name or born in muslim family never make u a muslim

i think we should now stop this because the whole debate is now going in wrong way plz stop all this because this wil leads to hurting all the muslim members of the forum

Originally posted by: simran45

You do not speak for everyone.

Some Muslims don't wear this, others do. You cannot generalize and say every Muslim believes the same as you.

it is not what i believe it is what is written in our holy book quran n there it is written u can't wear such dresses which will show any part of your body without hands face n feet n if a muslim is saying no to that that means he is not muslim by keeping muslim name or born in muslim family never make u a muslim

Originally posted by: delena90

The Quran which was written 1000s of years ago - before skirts were even invented says this?

The Quran doesn't say this. People do.

@Fizzi 🤗

are u a muslim then discuss n open suran nisa n see there what is written abioutdresses of girl n then talk weather it is in quran or not

Originally posted by: delena90

The Quran which was written 1000s of years ago - before skirts were even invented says this?

The Quran doesn't say this. People do.

@Fizzi 🤗

dont forget that zoya is from new york and their it is common for people to wear such clothes..

Originally posted by: delena90

I have said this many times. What is Islamic and Muslim to you (general you) is not necessarily what is believed by the general population of Muslims.

I have many Muslim friends who wear skirts, shorts, bikinis, dresses and jeans. It does not mean they are disrespecting their religion or culture. They still pray, they still fast and more importantly they are good people.

If god exists he isn't going to question you on what you were wearing. His concern will be if you were a kind, truthful and a good person.

Just my opinion. :)

I'm sure Allah does care more about a persons deeds than their clothes but the fact of the matter is that Islam does state that a person should not show their skin, and actually specifies that this means the whole body, except for the feet, hands and face. So although your Muslim friends might be great people they are not following Islam in it's true form, and unfortunately that is the truth.

It is not about perception of Islam. It is actually written down in religious books, it is not about opinions. Your statement that 'What is Islamic and Muslim to you (general you) is not necessarily what is believed by the general population of Muslims' can't really apply to this situation. I'm sure most Muslims know that they are not allowed to show their skin, but they choose to ignore it.

If the religion explicitly states you can't do something, then that is part of the religion, it isn't an opinion. It is factual to that religion.

So people who wear short dresses, bikinis, short skirts etc. are not following Islam correctly, and this isn't an opinion of mine, it is actually stated in the Islamic books and they will be questioned about it, and I'm sure most Muslims know this, but some wish to ignore it.

It means that people aren't following the religion properly. I don't think these people are bad or anything like that, but it does mean they are doing wrong in accordance with religion.

I don't think anyone follows a religion perfectly. We all do wrong.
We can still be good Muslims/Christians/Hindu's/Jews/Sikhs/Buddhists etc. even if we do some wrong, but we can't pretend something is permissable in a religion when it is not, we have to accept we are doing wrong.


No offence intended to anyone.
But if we really are basing this on factual stuff i.e. books etc. and not opinions, then wearing such clothes is wrong. Just like eating beef is wrong in Hinduism, or eating non-Kosher food in Judaism, having sexual relationships before marriage, these are wrong in many religions, but it doesn't mean everyone follows it.

i know that religion is no just about clothes n all...but still Islam has some limits and Muslims are supposed to follow that particular standard of dressing
but in QH i think thats what they'r showing... tht Zoya was in abroad so she wore it n Asad's family wont like that..

Originally posted by: simran45

are u a muslim then discuss n open suran nisa n see there what is written abioutdresses of girl n then talk weather it is in quran or not

Fact remains that ALL religious text was written by MAN not GOD.

And since you asked - No I am NOT Muslim. I am an atheist.