Why the desperate attempt to kill a perfectly good

DesiShowFanatic thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago
#1
Scene???? 😕 🤢 😡

Hi guys...remember me...Yes it's Pinky.🤗

Thankyou for all the warm welcomes and for accepting me into the QH Family/Forum.

It was a perfectly good scene and they spoiled it
It was a perfectly good feel and they ruined it 😕

Why? Why?? Why???

I know you are wondering which scene...it's the one at the dining hall 😡

To understand what i am trying to tell lets have a quick precap...With QH's last episode the makers left us, the viewers with a heavy heart. The precap too gave us a hint that we were in for a heart-break...and well it did happen too but it's after effect was short-lived...They did not even give us time for the feeling to sink in...😡

What was this desperate need of the makers, 4 Lions to show the lead actress in a Comical Light when the occasion does not call for it??? 😡 😲 Zoya was hurt, she was in pain but the over all feel they gave to the scene, the way it was executed was more
on a humorous note. Why?

Did Zoya not tell Asad the previous day that she could take care of herself? Did Asad not see and understand that Zoya was upset then how did the makers turn the table today? Suddenly Zoya wanted attention and Asad was least bothered???

I have been an avid follower of all 4 Lions Show, i am sure there are others too and i know i am not supposed to judge QH based on their previous work but when you see a particular track going in a similar fashion you can't help but tell...by no means am i comparing...Please don't think that way but seriously when i saw the scene i was like why? Why did they have to give a comic touch to it, why did Zoya have to try and get his attention shouldn't it have been the other way?

I am not against comedy...but definitely do not want one in the wrong time, at the wrong place.

What do you think guys??? Do you agree??? Feel remotely the same way? 😭


Edited by pinkydiva - 12 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

14

Views

3k

Users

12

Likes

28

Frequent Posters

GroverAddict thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 12 years ago
#2
i think zoya is confused abt feelings nd i m lovuing current things in QH
rickks thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 12 years ago
#3
It's 4 Lions what do u expect...After a long long time, i felt the pain of a fictional character...I myself couldn't believe it...I kept telling myself show hai...But that was the effect Zoya's Heart Breaking Scene, followed by Do Pal Ruka, Followed by I don't need anybody scene had on me...

The scene was so impactful that i was too stunned after watching it and while i expected the makers to carry it on tonight as well so that it would have that expected effect and result...I was shocked to see them turn it into comedy...Itni Serious feelings ke saath deal kar rahi hai...I am not looking for an Ekta type rona dhona...But i am also not looking for a 4 Lions typical Comedy in emotional scene either...No offense to anybody...
Joavssk9 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#4
i am wondering...y cvs are showing Zoya been despo to seek attention...i know its natural for a girl to fall for a guy n seeking his attention...but is it always the girl who has to make this attempt...y can't boyz be in that position...y d hell girls always has to surffer...its mr asad problem that he is not accepting the fact...y zoya is getting hurt everything bcoz of asad misjudgement...y...let boyz too have the fun alwayzz...plz comment why u guys think on this...plz
FireSafireFiree thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 12 years ago
#5
Ehhh... Maybe you need to think how they r in dinial mood and trying to avoid getting rejected.

The scene was perfect, i am not sure what you r talking about.
Today was great. It was dilshad day.



And highly disagree with your POV. The curent track is amazing. Hats off to cvs. Justice to every chracter and there feeling.
Edited by FireSafireFiree - 12 years ago
merrydock thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 12 years ago
#6
i understand what you mean, but i think that first love however intense, is also a bit comical, espicial when the eyes say "Yes I love you," " yes I want you" " you and every thing related to you means the world to me." but the lips say "NO" and both know that the "NO" means nothing.
Asad loved saying "Zoya, getting engaged to you is the best thing that happened to me." is was evident in the small smile on his face, he enjoyed the blush in her cheeks and her breathlessness.
Zoya long and earnest speech screamed "I WANT YOU MR KHAN TO TELL ME, THAT YOU LOVE ME. AND THAT THIS ENGAGEMENT IS REAL. ALL I WANT IN THIS WORLD IS FOR THIS ENGAGEMENT TO BE REAL AND THAT YOU ARE AS MUCH IN LOVE WITH ME AS I AM WITH YOU" but then her pride make her lips say "NO"
but like Dilshad told tanveer, you dont make these decisions because Kismet makes it for you. while Asad and Zoya were playing emotional Tug of War. on the other side of the wall Kismet was very neatly playing a good game of chess and checkers. Dilshad has let the cat out of the bag officialy that Asad is engaged and now he is going to marry in 10 days.
that was really funny😆😆👏 way to go Kismet
sahuja thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#7
Simple guys it's zoya's turn to realize her love feelings... Though I Would have enjoyed a scene where they would have taken this seriously and zoya avoiding asad and thinking why she is so affected but zoya being zoya turned it to a light scene by this humor . I don't think she was trying to gain attention but was having more fun to see asad irritated
eastmeetswest thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: pinkydiva

Scene???? 😕 🤢 😡

Hi guys...remember me...Yes it's Pinky.🤗

Thankyou for all the warm welcomes and for accepting me into the QH Family/Forum.

It was a perfectly good scene and they spoiled it
It was a perfectly good feel and they ruined it 😕

Why? Why?? Why???

I know you are wondering which scene...it's the one at the dining hall 😡

To understand what i am trying to tell lets have a quick precap...With QH's last episode the makers left us, the viewers with a heavy heart. The precap too gave us a hint that we were in for a heart-break...and well it did happen too but it's after effect was short-lived...They did not even give us time for the feeling to sink in...😡

What was this desperate need of the makers, 4 Lions to show the lead actress in a Comical Light when the occasion does not call for it??? 😡 😲 Zoya was hurt, she was in pain but the over all feel they gave to the scene, the way it was executed was more
on a humorous note. Why?

Did Zoya not tell Asad the previous day that she could take care of herself? Did Asad not see and understand that Zoya was upset then how did the makers turn the table today? Suddenly Zoya wanted attention and Asad was least bothered???

I have been an avid follower of all 4 Lions Show, i am sure there are others too and i know i am not supposed to judge QH based on their previous work but when you see a particular track going in a similar fashion you can't help but tell...by no means am i comparing...Please don't think that way but seriously when i saw the scene i was like why? Why did they have to give a comic touch to it, why did Zoya have to try and get his attention shouldn't it have been the other way?

I am not against comedy...but definitely do not want one in the wrong time, at the wrong place.

What do you think guys??? Do you agree??? Feel remotely the same way? 😭


yeah i agree with you, it actually killed and lessened the intensity of the scene and made it trivial...i did not enjoy that scene nor did i think it was an approriate response to be made by the character.. that jus did not fit👎🏼.
Yazzi thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
#9
I completely agree with you. I too have nothing against comedy but it should be at the right time when the situation demands it, and honestly comedy all the time becomes monotonous and doesn't leave a sense of enjoyment but annoyance. Especially, when the situation at hand should be serious throwing comedy in there is tasteless and takes away the essence of the situation, like today in the hallway she seemed so choked up, she seemed sick of Asad and his Emotionally challenged self and it really made an impact but then the next second the whole scene is ruined because of the comedy element added to it. I honestly would have thought that the PH team would have learnt that comedy is all good and glory but not all the time, especially not when the scene should be serious and emotional.
mochhug thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 12 years ago
#10
I think it was good. I do agree that when he asked her if she wanted the engagement to be real, it could've been a little more serious but i still enjoyed it

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".