Originally posted by: austenrox
i think abhay and piya are both right in their own ways...i agree that it is better to trust your impulse react first - immoral or moral faraq badh mein parta hai..first react on what your heart says...talk to your loved one...you are busy sulking instead which is not going to do you any good , or your sister any good and make abhay feel guilty and sad for no reason...but also piya is at crossroads and poor girl really is confused between the realms of action and reaction..rationality and irrationality...remember that one time when piya listened to her impulsive instincts aur apna chain locket sid ke neck pe press kiya aur bahhg gayi?!?! impulsive aur rational both tha...lekin uska nateega toh abhay ko bhoogat naa para right...aur that also made piya a porcelain doll with no life...as her heart , life and soul are trapped in the ice with abhay's body ...jab bhi ladki kuch rational and impulsive karti hai...usee consequences bhoogath naa parta hai...aur jab bhi kuch irrational karti hai like now...tab auro ko bhoogath naa parta hai 😕..bechari 😳 ...ya and i did not like it when piya called chandeena darindey 😡...that time i wanted to ask her " accha bacchi..toh ab woh darindey hai? tab tumne apne poori zindagi kiske naam kardi ? ek phool kumari ke? yeh ek vampire ke ? ya abhay itne saalon se humme chakma dey ke phool kumari hi tha ke ab tum " darindey anthem" gaa rahi ho ? " 😕...hmph. lol. i think piya is both wrong and right...as usual...😕...again i want to say i am not justifying her but i am trying to explain her thoughts of why did not want abhay to go...it does not need to be rational...but it is just her irational insecurities one gets when they are in love with the king of fire and morbidity...even though abhay became human...piya ko abhay bauhaut consequences turmoils aur emotional disorders ke baad mila hai..we cannot deny that , can we? 😕...that episode where piya's heart growled against every figment of her body , flesh , blood , organs and even soul when all these factors of her body insisted her heart to give abhay up already and piya knelt down against her heart battling fighting , sermonizing all the figments of her body that how could they even think of removing abhay from herself when her heart has clung onto his chest for more than a year and she has finally got it back by him coming back...i don't think we can ever forget that episode because of piya...what an episode that was...it got us thinking i think that if anyone can go to this extent of insanity for their beloved and that also when they don't remember anything at all...we can't forget how many agneepariksha's of going faana emotionally over abhay did she have to face to geet abhay..to convince him that they can be together...i don't think she could even risk her dark knight getting back to the dungeons...and in a way , piya did do the right thing of stopping him...cause now look..chandeena went back and now the vampy superiors are killing them slowly...if abhay went back...they kill him in front of chandeena's eyes...chaand even said " accha hai ke abhay nahi hai...vaarna yeh log usse bhi maar daalte"......so piya was vwery wrong in calling chandeena darindey ...😡...nikammi kahi ki 😆...but in a way...she was right in not sending abhay back..or else piya would seriously lose him forever this time..as abhay would be locked in the balck marshes of the betraying vampy sardars...and piya could not possibly let him go cause whether abhay is a human or a VAMPY ..HE IS A LVING DREAM that can go away from her hands like sand granules slipping through her finger gaps anytime...and anywhere...that is why abhay is our aag...and piya is our pataanga..and always will be....one more thing..i am not saying piya was not wrong in trusting sid more..she was..she really was and she realised that the minute she ignored her impulses...but the thing is...abhay always thought she was not strong enough to ever succumb to truths ..which is kind of true...looking at the way she reacted to the vampire revealed track...but later on she realised what a fool she was...Abhay was also in a way wrong to always never tell her anything and always have things the way he thinks is right..for a long time it felt like only abhay made decisions in their relationships..those decisions which even lead to piyas memory loss but000000 it was not his fault either...i mean he was ready to get buried in ice but not ready 0to l0et all those memories0 0torment her for his loss...that torment which Haseena and Chaand had to face...gaaah Abhay Raichand i love you! but saying that Piya did not suffer at all i think is stretching it quite a lot. no offence/