Colors of Life- Prithvi and Mrinal Part 30 updated page 48 - Page 38

Created

Last reply

Replies

385

Views

37.7k

Users

23

Likes

1.4k

Frequent Posters

shruthiravi thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 7 years ago
10/6/2016

Yesterday we came across the golden bird which GK has to return to mother earth. Once he returns the golden bird to mother earth his powers will go. So the question before GK is keep the bird and protect it always so that his power remains or fight the current battle and return the bird to earth, so that the bird can decide when to reappear. At that time there will be another GK. It kind of showed whether you want to keep power always or you allow the power to rotate, allow the new people to take the challenge. Because if you dont return golden bird to earth in the name of protecting it you can keep on waging war. Since you are GK you have the power and people will abide by you. So it is actually selfless from GK to return the bird and lose the power than to keep on waging the war.

Because it is a cyclic process. When change is eminent the bird will appear and once the process of change is done order has to be restored and bird disappears. For life to sustain change and order is needed. Presence of bird is change and continuos change is not going to help anyone. I have more to write about this bird, but I will write that in the farewell post.

Coming to Mrinal. She has under estimated Mehmood and has ended up in the captivity of Ghazini. To be frank in those days such a captivity means sex slave. And it was bold of Mrinal to take up such a mission. Neverthless GK team has Ismail and that is the card that will come to save Mrinal. But I feel she will do something else as she is a warrior princess.

In Malwa Kallari is wounded and Tailap is edging towards victory. Jakkala wants Satyashrey to be a good ruler. Dont know what all we will get. But I am not sure how everything would be rounded up in two episodes. I dont think except for golden bird nothing else would get a good closure and it deeply pains me as an analyst.
shruthiravi thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 7 years ago
Yes yes Visa and Aditi i had mentioned golden bird as the culture of India. I will make a seperate post on it for the farewell thread. I had mentioned that to Mano. Will send it tomorrow or latest by Friday
Vdvisa thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
Shruthi hoping the creators are able to close the main loops in the story and give closures to analysts and viewers.
Vdvisa thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago

Originally posted by: shruthiravi

Yes yes Visa and Aditi i had mentioned golden bird as the culture of India. I will make a seperate post on it for the farewell thread. I had mentioned that to Mano. Will send it tomorrow or latest by Friday



Sure looking forward to it. And also your guess on the end 😛
naq5 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
i am also very disappointed we will never get the whole story. n all ends loose. i hope they had taken atleast 2 more episodes to finish this off properly
and why did they waste time on kosha-jhakkala seene on saturday. 😡
Edited by naq5 - 7 years ago
shruthiravi thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 7 years ago
16/6/2018 and 17/6/2018
Today is my last analysis of Prithvi Vallabh. I would come to the moot question. Why was Malwa able to do treacherous attack on manyakhet when GK was weak. There was none to protect Manyakhet in GK's absence. Most importantly the women of GKs family were well versed in arts but none knew the fighting technique. Why did Prithvi vallabh survive because his lady love was well versed in war fare. When he was weak she fought and protected him.

What was the end result of GK Shivdutt's folly. His daughter Mrinal killed the feminine aspect in her. She banned arts, she denounced love and completely blocked out feminine emotions in her pushing the family the country to war and constant upheavals. When did she get the real peace. When her knowledge was able to protect a man. The red blood that flowed in multiple wars didnt satisfy her thirst. It was satisifed by a pinch of Sindoor that has red color.

Mrinal represents many young woman of today. Growing up seeing injustice done to their families, seeing their mothers not valued for their contribution they denounce anything feminine. They are in war with themselves and with the world. They suppress the natural instinct of nurture as it is treated weak and learn the destructive skills that has more value in this world.

Our cultural degradation and multiple invasion happened because of our mentality to shut our women folks to kitchen, arts and other things and never teaching them to fight and protect themselves. Women were taught to committ Jauhar to protect their honor not to kill their enemy. These unskilled, unprepared woman committed Jauher or the glorified suicide each time emboldening attackers and weakining us. It was needed only to defeat the men, woman could either be taken slaves or they would committ Jauhar. I ended up watching the Jauhar scene of Padmavati and felt like vomiting. Are you telling me it is a honorable thing to take very young girls and pregnant woman( believe me there was a pregnant lady) to the pyre to protect honor. Is this what our society should get inspired from. Is this how we are going to protect our culture.

Looking back I dont know was it just a coincidence or the light shown to us by destiny the path to freedom was cut by a woman who instead of committing suicide or surrendering dared the British and gave them night mares. Rani Lakshmi Bhai.Yes we were not invaded post that because our women were no longer Sati committing idiots, we have come a long way from there. We need to understand though one gender has primary responsiblity it is not that other gender shouldnt know about it. A woman has to know defense techiques and how to conduct herself in the world outside home, whereas a man has to know what happens inside the home. If the circumstance demands she should be equipped to fight and he should be equipped to cook or take care of children. Life skills should be imparted to both gender only then we can protect ourselves. Woman are a nurturing and protective force and if she fights for protecting she will get peace of mind. Man has to understand without a qualified woman in his absence his family is at risk. By educating her, by making her self reliant you are only ensuring life is sustained on earth. There is no life without her, there is no culture without her. If you want to protect your culture dont worship her, dont make her a doormat but just cherish her. This is the beautiful message of PV.

Once again I thank all my readers for taking time to read out my analysis. It was a pleasure interacting with you all.
CutiepieAD thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
Beautiful analysis shruthi di
Glad that you didn't have to change your analysis
There is a very thin line between being feminist and anti men
Infact we too sometimes don't understand, leave at all Mrinal, she has seen so much in past.
Finally Mrinal became a true feminist n strong woman in true sense.

Btw shruthi, long back you had made a similar analysis when Mrinal was saying her family is Tailap and his family and she doesn't need any man in her life.
So is it not good to remain independent or single, I mean in today's time?




Edited by CutiepieAD - 7 years ago
Vdvisa thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
A wonderful closure to Mrinal's thirst in life. You keep me wondering how you relate the blood to sindoor and beautifully described the loop. Awesome Shruthi.

Hemraj meant this GK is different maybe because he still survives after saving the golden bird???
maharathikarna thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
The act of committing jauhar needs to be seen in the time in which it was set. There is no way women and children or for that matter men could survive the onslought of Alauddin Khilji. The movie gives a wrong potrayal of him as a savage. All brawns and no brains. It is not the truth.
He is one of the first king in india to maintain a professional standing army which is paid through out the year. He is the only king in india who beat back the raging hordes of mongols who conquered pretty much everywhere in asia n europe but left only indian sub continent. It was no coincidence. They were defeated 4 times by armies of khilji. Khilji was a megalomaniac and Muslim fundemental who pretty much destroyed everything hindu. There was no way women and children would have survived his army. Becoming his slave would not be like what is shown in prithvi vallabh. It would be brutal. There is no way any respectable hindu women would have agreed for that. Though there were people who did that like khilji last 3 wives including kamala devi. Martially trained women would have been easy pickings for the muslim hordes. Please note that no hindu king had standing armies during those periods.
Edited by maharathikarna - 7 years ago
shruthiravi thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 7 years ago
@maharathikarna please understand I belong to a community who migrated from Goa due to atrocities from Portugese. It is said that forcible conversion happened, people who were refused were skinned alive, women raped and untold miseries were inflicted upon my ancestors. They also destroyed anything that can be termed Hindu. Many temples in Goa were rebuilt post independence. What I want to tell you is that I am here not because of that people who converted due to fear, nor because of people who committed suicide to protect their so called honor. But because of people who took an ardenous journey full of risks, dont know what they suffered in that journey and under what condition they lived. But the point is they gave a shot at life , they gave a chance to life and came to Kerala and sought aslyum. The culture and language owes it to those bravehearts who decided to live and not die.
So if Khilji attacked there is an option called migration other than Jauhar. Though the journey will be difficult, ardeous but still it is a shot at life. Just look at the people crossing the mediterraen escaping ISIS from Syria. Many die, but still they take that chance towards life and not death. Time doesnt matter. It is about will to live and will to die and I can never accept Jauhar as it is an option for death that kills a society, kills a community and allows the perpeuator to win.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".