reality is that

this programme was no 1 till the judgement was in the hands of music experts.... when they give the decision in hands of public, the whole programme was massed......specially eleminating sharib, nihira and then himmani,....... janta is not choosing the best singer, they are choosing that this person is from assam, or any other state........

speacially the great wrong step was taken by ID for walking out coz he knows that day Debu did not sing up to the mark...that day his performance was weakest.....just to give the sympathey of janta to Debu ID walk out....and his this benefited Debu, and sufferer was himani whereas we all think last competition will be between Vinit and Himani.........



there is one suggestion they should repeat the programme with same contestants from where they give the decision in the hands of janta ..they should give all the decision in the hands of music experts otherwise we will not get a good singer but will get a good statesman

Originally posted by: Arshia

this programme was no 1 till the judgement was in the hands of music experts.... when they give the decision in hands of public, the whole programme was massed......specially eleminating sharib, nihira and then himmani,....... janta is not choosing the best singer, they are choosing that this person is from assam, or any other state........

speacially the great wrong step was taken by ID for walking out coz he knows that day Debu did not sing up to the mark...that day his performance was weakest.....just to give the sympathey of janta to Debu ID walk out....and his this benefited Debu, and sufferer was himani whereas we all think last competition will be between Vinit and Himani.........

You think that Debu was not up to the mark .. but Jatin (who at that point was a guest mentor and had nothing to gain gave him a 9)
It was a amazingly diffcult song and he pulled it off extremely well.

The competition is not about who can sing your favorite songs nicely.. but about one who could be the best playback singer and considering Debu's range, his voice , his mettle and obvious classical training.. he seems to be the best option among the remaining 3. Only Sharib and Hemu can give him some competition in the male category .. and obviously Nihira was always a class apart...

Also I stopped being a fan of the judges since the Jagjit Singh / Alka Y episode..( I dont know they never explained that situation ever)

there is one suggestion they should repeat the programme with same contestants from where they give the decision in the hands of janta ..they should give all the decision in the hands of music experts otherwise we will not get a good singer but will get a good statesman

And you talk about judges .. many of these from the 32 would fail if the show was conducted as before and they were made to sing songs of different genres impromptu...

Someone should ask Vinit to sing Manna Dey's songs or Himani to sing one lata/asha song

Dont take this is a wrong way .. they all could still find some sucess.. but to find sucess on the lines of somebody like Sonu or Udit they need to have good training and something special about themselves which no one else has in the industry now..

tantra u sound like debu's wife

Ek doosre par personal attacks kyon kar rahe ho bhai logon...
Waise bhi kam tension ho rahi hai kya? :)