Judging Analysis - 14th March

Page

Suspended

Posted: 16 years ago

Before i did open a perfomance Analsis for contestants in 1st Epi - i think we need a judges Analysis/Chaska Rating as they do my head in 😆

Mods if similar topics opened before - Please close 😛

Saroj - I expected more from her in terms of Judging. I feel as a choregrapher she should concenterate on the dancing aspects. I thought before the show she would be Harsh in her comments. So far she has not been. All the judges seem to nice nice type and not really concentrating on the Dancing seeing as its dance show. They are all TOO generous in marks, giving 8,9's and 10's. If they start LOW then when someone does brilliant the standard will be set, but atm because of marks there's no real competition as i felt KSG did not deserve 29 - there was nothing extra special in his perfomance (sorry his fans)

Judging Score : 6/10

****

Juhi - I don't get why they have her as a judge - she doesnt even know what to judge or say even. This has happened before - cant remember what contest i think it was shilpa shetty or someone as judge and she didnt have a clue - just followed others. I dont get why they add bollywood person in when they know nothing - just a pretty face.

Judging Score: 3/10

***

Vaibhavi Merchant - Again i didn't really hear any comments related to dancing from her, disappointing!

Judging Score: 6/10

Quote

Frequent Posters

sumanforums

@sumanforums

Navigator

Posted: 16 years ago

i sort of agree with you on rating....just that i feel Juhi does not really follow the other judges.....i am not saying she is good but does not really follow others.

Vaibhavi and Saroj are not strict at all. BUt they started with giving contestants 6 and 7. Only yesterday they gave Karan 10 10 and 9. I think a 9 9 and 9 were good for him.......i thought he was excellent but the better is yet to come from him. I have seen him performing with shraddha before and he was too good there.

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

Shruti

@JahanpanahBond

Dazzler

+ 2

Posted: 16 years ago

hmmmm...i dunno wat to comment...coz m a hardcore Ksg fan....i reali thnk he deserved da marks he gt...coz he ws tooooo gud ystrday...n moreova i thnk tat tey gav hm 10's coz of hs effort...if u c...tys prfrmance of hs ws full of energy...n i agree..tat da best is yet to cum frm hm....n m sooo sure he'l do tat too..n ten many of u...wil urslf say tat he dsrvd much muchhhhhhhhh muchhhhhhhhhh muchhhhhhhh more tan a 30 on 30😊

Quote

6508

Suspended

Posted: 16 years ago

Originally posted by: sumanforums
i sort of agree with you on rating....just that i feel Juhi does not really follow the other judges.....i am not saying she is good but does not really follow others.

Oh noo - i wasn't saying Juhi followed the others, was saying Shilpa did when she was a judge, was just showing how these celebrities just don't have a clue.

And well my point is about them judging...that they don't comment on the dancing itself.

Well of course all fans will say their person deserved marks, but they all can improve, so if judges started low with ALL then standard will improve....but if they just gace everyone like 8 and 9's you won't be able to see a difference in the scores from Now - first few weeks in and near the end of the contest.

Edited by anon - 16 years ago

Quote

jinnie

@missmasakalli

Inactive

Posted: 16 years ago

anyways these judges are entertaining and far more better than farah, daver,remo,geeta kapoor,karishma,arjun et al....

Quote

nandini

@Riddikulus

Rocker

+ 4

Posted: 16 years ago

i'm with you on the setting-the-standard bit...if they start with 9s and 10s for performances which are good but have promise for much more, how will the marking be any different an indication when they actually do perform really well? like if Karan ends up giving some kind of brilliant performance...tw...absolutely outdoing himself, and even Vaibhavi concedes a 10, it'll be only a mark above what he got today...wouldn't the value of those marks then be greatly reduced? I took Karan as an example coz he's scored the highest on Jhalak till now, but it applies to every contestant...

apart from that, as far as their judging goes, i think they are concentrng on dance, but are going rather easy on precision, especially on people like Baichung and Mohinder ji...sorry to their fans, just my opinion...

and i disagree about Juhi...i think she marks pretty fair eventhough she's too sweet to be mean to anyone while giving her comments...and as far as her not having a clue is concerned, well, neither do we, so if we can have our decisions on who deserved how many marks, so can she...and the one thing she does have is experience, of having danced in a dozen movies and worked with many choreographers...so she's not entirely alien to the field either...

cheers!

Quote

sunaena

@sunaena

Inactive

Posted: 16 years ago

Originally posted by: nandinidev
i'm with you on the setting-the-standard bit...if they start with 9s and 10s for performances which are good but have promise for much more, how will the marking be any different an indication when they actually do perform really well? like if Karan ends up giving some kind of brilliant performance...tw...absolutely outdoing himself, and even Vaibhavi concedes a 10, it'll be only a mark above what he got today...wouldn't the value of those marks then be greatly reduced? I took Karan as an example coz he's scored the highest on Jhalak till now, but it applies to every contestant...

apart from that, as far as their judging goes, i think they are concentrng on dance, but are going rather easy on precision, especially on people like Baichung and Mohinder ji...sorry to their fans, just my opinion...

and i disagree about Juhi...i think she marks pretty fair eventhough she's too sweet to be mean to anyone while giving her comments...and as far as her not having a clue is concerned, well, neither do we, so if we can have our decisions on who deserved how many marks, so can she...and the one thing she does have is experience, of having danced in a dozen movies and worked with many choreographers...so she's not entirely alien to the field either...

cheers!

ditto nandini !!😃😃

Quote

Glinda Elizabeth Kushero

@Ezria_Fan_4ever

Inactive

+ 4

Posted: 16 years ago

yeah karan didnt deserve 29 on 30,
he deserved 30 on 30

Quote

@-dramaholic-

Inactive

+ 6

Posted: 16 years ago

I agreee with you anon, i expected a lot more from Saroj & Vaibhavi, esp after Nach Baliye seasons, i don't know why they are being to light to these people..:|

Juhi Chawla just seems like evil under a pretty face, her comments don't correspond to her marks, and she gives lower marks than the other 2 when her comments are always the sweet ones:| She makes me feel confused..

Quote

Judging Analysis - 14th March

Related Topics

Explore Topics