Soulink thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#1

After watching the two episodes of JDJ3 , I was in such a confounded state of mind and I thought ….was it me or was the judging biased with the few exceptions…..then I came to this forum just to have an idea what's going on in other's mind…….My my my!!!I must say I was too bewildered at first and couldn't believe the tracks of majority of the posts over here………..ROFL!!🤣......I should have known better that this forum will be buzzing w/t only hard core fans of some celebrities…actually a specific one mostly!....LOL!!...😉😆😆

Anyway.....though I couldn't go through all the posts over here, but I definitely got the clear message here……The judging ways were indeed judgmental on the part of the judges!....if I may say so…but it was in all fairness…a true paradoxical statement….I know !😉....but here's why…

Well to begin with the 12 participants in this Reality Show have been randomly selected from various backgrounds except for some few ......(brought in thoughtfully to further a purpose in the most profitable commercial way as usual!……like those have already established their fame in the TV industry namely KSG, Parul and Ram Kapoor) …..I'm purposely omitting to name some others who are also notorious in their fields solely for the reason that they do not actually hold the same amount of interest as their counterparts on this show……..Sony's business heads unquestinably know what they want!!…..

The judges are definitely not born yesterday…..and we are no fools as to fail to notice the huge marginal differences in their assessment of the overall performances of the participants…….the comments coming from the judges were somehow so unmatched for some especially in comparison to good performances versus poor ones…..

Let's retrospect on the really 'low performance levels'….. the magician fellow (Ugesh something)…he hardly did any dance steps and it was pretty obvious it was mostly focused on his magical abilities, then there was this Anand fellow….not too many dance steps either, the cricket star(don't know his name)….good attempt on his part though ,the football player again minimal dance steps and was as stiff as a rod..…well overall I guess that was just an intro with respect to their background...

Shilpa Shukla, Bhagyashree average performers…..Monica was really good enough and was appropriately judged for her performance and Gauhar not too bad either….

Hard Kaur….well what to say about her!……I think her whole performance spoke for itself……absolutely mindblowing!!👏👏👏…….and the judges could not fail to appreciate that…..she was indeed burning the dance floor w/t her choreographer!......very well and most deservingly awarded marks & befitting remarks from the judges...👏

Now let's come to our own real celebrities…our 'idols'……well I'm not going to hide the fact that I'm a die hard fan of Parul and would definitely love to see her as the final winner……..she is undoubtedly a natural and graceful dancer though the choreography was sadly lacking (just as the judges commented so rightly but they could have at least praised her for her talent…..their absolute lack of recognition to this fact was a bit annoying to say the least!😡.....Poor Parul!😔)….she was indisputably among the best performers of the JDJ premiere after Hard Kaur and Monica Bedi…..no two ways about that!!!...

Ram Kapoor could hardly move his heavy weight around but can to some extent vibe well to music…..the judges were very sharp on that spot…..they had to get him working on that and hence the hoop!...LOL!!!...😆😆😆

Karan ( I've heard this name so much and seen the thousands female fans swooning over him that it's hard not to know who he is……sorry though I'm no fan of him..)…but he did perform much better than the rest of the guys for sure…...he does have a rhythm in his body movement….. he'll somehow progress to a great dancer w/t practice……he's definitely not likely going to be eliminated so soon or if ever at all going by endless lines of the hard dying fans on his trail…..😉

Now the coming to the final judging ways……it is pretty much obvious that the judges along w/t the channels administrators thad concurred together to get the show kicking in the right direction……… as we all know that the participants would only be able to proceed ahead to the next level based on the judges marks combined w/t the no. of votes they receive from the audience……well we all can do our maths here….had the judges not been generous and encouraging in their scores and remarks to our 'non idolised' contestants, they will certainly be all out no matter how excellent their performance will be…....except for people like Hard Kaur, she has this charismatic personality of attracting even the most reluctant audience…..her charm, her electrifying screen presence and her overall positive and dynamic attitude can only boost her image in the eyes of even the most passive viewers….but she's is the only exception and some of them who will be able to fend their way up in all fairness will definitely be fighting a lost battle if it's not been for the 'fair' judgment of the highly sensible judges…….

Hats off to them!!!👏👏 …..we need to acknowledge the fact that the responsibilities that they have been bestowed with by Sony Channel ( who we all know only thrives on TRPs!!) have indeed a tremendously challenging job at their stake cognizant to their reputation…….i.e. resorting to the use of strategic assessments!!!

So ,though I can't help being such a big fan of Parul (Thank God for that she can dance!!....and thanks to her I'm posting a topic on a forum other than Bidaai!..), I will now in all fairness support anybody else who deserves my encouragement without any bias from my part!...Hard Kaur to begin with….she is so funny and I love her whacky and carefree attitude!!😆...

But for now let's keep the ball rolling with the spirit of a healthy competition!😛....

Go Parul go!!!👏......

P.S…….. Wow!!..I was not gonna post anything on the JDJ forum and I ended up writing a thesis! …….ROFL!!!!🤣

Created

Last reply

Replies

9

Views

935

Users

5

Frequent Posters

pksanam thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#2

Originally posted by: prat9

Wow!!..I was not gonna post anything on the JDJ forum and I ended up writing a thesis! .ROFL!!!!🤣

good thesis.. 100%.. ⭐️
well, i have my reservations for now, but will wait for a few more episodes.. but definitely Hard Kaur was great.. wonderful performer and i loved her attitude.. 😊
p.s. please keep posting here on the Jhalak forum as well.. i enjoyed reading your post..
Edited by pksanam - 16 years ago
Soulink thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#3

Awww...thank you so much for your appreciation pksanam!!😳....

I will try to post whenever I can but for sure much much shorter version this time....LOL!!😆😆😆

Wrackspurt thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 16 years ago
#4
Very Good Analysis of the show 👏.........Hard Kaur definitely stole the show....loved that gal.........loved her attitude.
pc84 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#5
Paro.. only one word to describe such dept analysis.WOW!! it is soo good yaar.. to be full honest i was getting a little scared in replying to your topic it just seems soo perfect and refined i didn't know how i will be able to reply..
But then again who can stop me from replying.. ahem so here it goes

Originally posted by: prat9

After watching the two episodes of JDJ3 , I was in such a confounded state of mind and I thought .was it me or was the judging biased with the few exceptions..then I came to this forum just to have an idea what's going on in other's mind.My my my!!!I must say I was too bewildered at first and couldn't believe the tracks of majority of the posts over here..ROFL!!🤣......I should have known better that this forum will be buzzing w/t only hard core fans of some celebrities'actually a specific one mostly!....LOL!!...😉😆😆

Well that's what IF does to you! everyone here are opinionated and in their own unique and creative way makes the forum the happening place to be!! I know what u mean by Hard core fans of our celebrity! to be honest one of the reason i love coming here is because i know that they are others like me out there that are as crazy and obssessed about my favorite stars... my family thinks i am crazy the way i go on and on about Parul or Kinshuk or Bidaai (you know what i mean..hence my PM to you are all length and non-sense😆) but here everyone of us will go on and beyond to define our fav stars.. sooo 👏 for everyone..
Anyway.....though I couldn't go through all the posts over here, but I definitely got the clear message here''The judging ways were indeed judgmental on the part of the judges!....if I may say so'but it was in all fairness'a true paradoxical statement'.I know !😉....but here's why'
I dont mind Vaibhahi and Juhi.. i think that Vaibhahi(sorry if i am spelling it wrong) is the only judge that is right 99.9% of the time.. she is supportive and real pleasure to watch on screen. and her choreography is really good.. Juhi is the sweetest judge.. and even if they didn't do well. she is there to encourage them to do better and try their hardest!! BUT (as witnessed by previous post) I am not a fan of Saroj Khan. I had a lot respect for her.. being the legend she is I was expecting her to give her expertise and wisdom to these stars that she have formal training.. whether they be tellywood stars of soccer stars... but after her rude comments and proud attitude i can't give her the same respect and affections i use to feel for her! maybe she will change in the future. but for now.. i dont see her judgement fair and her as a judge is not something i like to see on screen!

Well to begin with the 12 participants in this Reality Show have been randomly selected from various backgrounds except for some few ......(brought in thoughtfully to further a purpose in the most profitable commercial way as usual!what's new.. isn't that how the world turns!!! like those have already established their fame in the TV industry namely KSG, Parul and Ram Kapoor) ..I'm purposely omitting to name some others who are also notorious in their fields solely for the reason that they do not actually hold the same amount of interest as their counterparts on this show certainly on this forum..they will be alot of bias comments.. but the everday janta might think differently! i agree with you.. the fact is that we see these stars 5 days week for 1/2 hour each!! in some way we feel connected to them and want only the best for them..obviously that this forum illustrates it all!! ..Sony's business heads unquestinably know what they want!!.. personal experience. i dont think Sony executives ever know what they want

The judges are definitely not born yesterday..and we are no fools as to fail to notice the huge marginal differences in their assessment of the overall performances of the participants. the comments coming from the judges were somehow so unmatched for some especially in comparison to good performances versus poor ones..

Let's retrospect on the really 'low performance levels'.. the magician fellow (Ugesh something) u knew his first name.. i didn't even know that.. i think the judges were impressed because he combined dancing with his magic skills.. the boy is smart though.. because he knew what his strength are and he used it to his benefit.. have to give him that much credit!! he hardly did any dance steps and it was pretty obvious it was mostly focused on his magical abilities agree, then there was this Anand fellow.not too many dance steps either agree, the cricket star i think he is a socceer star hon(don't know his nameBhaiSoon or something).good attempt on his part though ,the football player again minimal dance steps and was as stiff as a rodawww.. i found him soo cute yaar.. he was soo nervous. he looked like a lost puppy soo cute yaar!!!!..well overall I guess that was just an intro with respect to their background...

Shilpa Shukla, Bhagyashree average performers'..Monica was really good enough and was appropriately judged for her performance and Gauhar not too bad either.agree they were okay!!!

Hard Kaur'.well what to say about her!''I think her whole performance spoke for itself''absolutely mindblowing!!👏👏👏''.and the judges could not fail to appreciate that'..she was indeed burning the dance floor w/t her choreographer!......very well and most deservingly awarded marks & befitting remarks from the judges...👏

u know it was not until i saw today's epi that i really felt for her.. she was really good in epi 1..and she is soo funny..but i thought she was wild..but seeing her today! i really started to like this one.. she has all the ingredients for a star.. her persoality is fun and sweet at the same time!! and she looks like an honest person.. that whatever she does it comes from her heart! and that is what makes an even likable person! for me anyways..
Now let's come to our own real celebrities'our 'idols'''well I'm not going to hide the fact that I'm a die hard fan of Parul love her too!!!and would definitely love to see her as the final winner me too!! or atleast TOP 5.. would love to see Kinshuk visit her on set of JDJ!!!!..she is undoubtedly a natural and graceful dancer though the choreography was sadly lacking i felt the same way.. she was wonderful esp for someone who didn't dance before .. i hate the fate that the judges were hard on the tellywood stars becasue they are "expected" to know how to dance.. they work as hard as anyone on that stage and hence should be given the same standards!!!(just as the judges commented so rightly but they could have at least praised her for her talent.their absolute lack of recognition to this fact was a bit annoying to say the least!😡.annoying is not word.. anger and hatre will sufficient!....Poor Parul!😔)'.she was indisputably among the best performers of the JDJ premiere after Hard Kaur and Monica Bedi'..no two ways about that!!!... Amen to that!!!!!

Ram Kapoor could hardly move his heavy weight around but can to some extent vibe well to music'..the judges were very sharp on that spot'..they had to get him working on that and hence the hoop!...LOL!!!...😆😆😆 awwww.. now i know i am being bias and as you mentioned one of those "idolising" fans.. but Ram Kapoor is like a teddy bear.. soo cute.. and today's Hula Hoop antic was hilarious to watch!! yes his weight is a problem but he pokes at it makes him even more adorable for words!!!

Karan ( I've heard this name so much and seen the thousands female fans swooning over him that it's hard not to know who he is''sorry though I'm no fan of him..)i know.. imagine when i first came to the forum and saw ample amount of posts on KSG.. i was getting a little worried that i might not find any Parul fans!! boy was i wrong.. but he did perform much better than the rest of the guys for sure'...he does have a rhythm in his body movement'.. he'll somehow progress to a great dancer w/t practicei that's wat i dont understand either.. he was good even better than some of the stars and he got yanked on for showing his physique... come on.. we are not living in 1900 anymore!!! he's definitely not likely going to be eliminated so soon or if ever at all going by endless lines of the hard dying fans on his trail'..😉

Now the coming to the final judging ways it is pretty much obvious that the judges along w/t the channels administrators thad concurred together to get the show kicking in the right direction as we all know that the participants would only be able to proceed ahead to the next level based on the judges marks combined w/t the no. of votes they receive from the audience''well we all can do our maths here'.had the judges not been generous and encouraging in their scores and remarks to our 'non idolised' contestants, they will certainly be all out no matter how excellent their performance will be'....i agree to some extend.. if the deserving marks are needed they should give it to them regardless of their popularity!!! that's what the judges are there for..to give advise to them and give them deserving marks.. if they are to give those less popular more marks just so that they can be in the show.. does that mean that our stars will be out sooner than they should? i dont know about that.. i know that i would want to see Parul more than most of the contestants out there..

except for people like Hard Kaur, she has this charismatic personality of attracting even the most reluctant audience'..her charm, her electrifying screen presence and her overall positive and dynamic attitude can only boost her image in the eyes of even the most passive viewers'.but she's is the only exception and some of them who will be able to fend their way up in all fairness will definitely be fighting a lost battle if it's not been for the 'fair' judgment of the highly sensible judges''.
The girl is a mast ladki! she has already won most of the audience with her personality and her jokes.. and the others will soon follow. no doubt!!!

Hats off to them!!!👏👏 '..we need to acknowledge the fact that the responsibilities that they have been bestowed with by Sony Channel ( who we all know only thrives on TRPs!!) have indeed a tremendously challenging job at their stake cognizant to their reputation''.i.e. resorting to the use of strategic assessments!!!

Only to Vaibhahi and Juhi.. Saroj is questionable and well Sony Channel.. okay for giving us JDJ 3 with Parul and HardKaur!!!
So ,though I can't help being such a big fan of Parul (Thank God for that she can dance!!....and thanks to her I'm posting a topic on a forum other than Bidaai!..), I will now in all fairness support anybody else who deserves my encouragement without any bias from my part!...Hard Kaur to begin with'.she is so funny and I love her whacky and carefree attitude!!😆...
Paro!! i know what you mean. I am a huge Parul fan but that doesn't stop me from commenting other contestants who did well! but my first and last vote will be for Parul.. sorry again bias here

But for now let's keep the ball rolling with the spirit of a healthy competition!😛....

Go Parul go!!!👏......

GO PARUL GO!!!

P.S''.. Wow!!..I was not gonna post anything on the JDJ forum and I ended up writing a thesis! ''.ROFL!!!!🤣

I knwo what you mean.. i love you post.. and for now i am going to wait for you post to be on before i start making any!! loved it
hope my comments are not that long.. sorry! i got carried away!
luv pri
pc84 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: mysticwater24

Very Good Analysis of the show 👏.........Hard Kaur definitely stole the show....loved that gal.........loved her attitude.

i know.. everything she does she does with flare!! a joy to watch on screen!
.Supriya. thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 16 years ago
#7
lovely topic and has gr8 way of thinking about the show and i love the karan part yaar awesome
Soulink thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: pc84

i know.. everything she does she does with flare!! a joy to watch on screen!

Hey Pri.....LOL!!!....i couldn't wait 4 tomorrow to c ur 'mini' analysis!!!.....SUPERB yaar!!!!👏👏 and thank you so much for all your 'overdoses' of praises!....but in all seriousness your yourself is no less than anyone yaar!!....What an acute sense of perception!!!!👏
I'm so glad that u added some very powerful points from ur POV!!!....MINDCLOWING!!....even tho' we don't agree on some points al least we r together in this battle for PARUL!!!!
Yeah after watching today's epi, Saroj as a judge has drastically jeopardised her sense of wisdom & maturity in my eyes too!!!...I couldn't believe her reactions to the whole ghastly scene after Parul fainted!...I mean come!...you aren't blind as a bat not to notice Parul's talent and her sincere dedication to this dance talent show!!....I have a feeling she is kind of prejudice due to some misgivings...I don't know what it is but she had better start adopting a positive and a fair attitude in her judging now!!!.....or she'll be soon faced w/t some aggravating criticisms from audience all over not to mention the die hard fans!!!😡😡😡
Edited by prat9 - 16 years ago
Soulink thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#9
Yeah today Hard Kaur captured my heart especially when they showed the mother-daughter clips....she is a very sincere and genuine person too.....Loved Ram!!...I always found him cute and he was indeed hilarious w/t the hula hoop!!!...LOL!!!!!😆
and Parul....she was the ONE to burn the dance floor today and gave a truly billiant performance inspite of her feeling so sick!....WOW!!! Truly rocking!!!.....but when she fainted it was too distressing!!!...
I do hope that she will now take extra care of herself and no matter what we are with you Parul!!!....Your talent is too amazing to go unnoticed!!!...so Go Parul Go!!!👏
pc84 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#10
omg.. you weren't replying at Jannat i knew you would be here reading the analysis!! 😆
thank you so much yaar for that dostage of praise!!! you are too good at this analysis thing.. i will defo give you all my assignment for sure now kidding!!
We do agree on many of the same fact yaar.. ya some odd one here and there.. but majority of it we have the same way of thinking.. it's usually the case with two brilliant minds...they think alike.. kidding..
anyways.. i know what you meawn.. Parul being the really authentic dance tonite would truly deserve a full on 30 if her health did not get in the way! i hope that she recovers and comes with a BANG!! wonder how she is feeling now! is the elimination tomorrow then?
omg.. Saroj have already made into the black list for most of the fans on this forum as well as (i am sure) the indian audience!! Like i said.. she is a legend but right now that is no grounds for such behaviour.. i think she needs to improve her attitude before she loose her crediability!
awww.. i know.. i use to be crazy about Jai Walia! i thought he was a teddy bear i would love to hug!! but now it's all about Parul!! hahah

Kaur story is a sad one.. because of what happened to her and her father. i really would see that she misses him dearly!! but what impressed me about her was the little sentence she said at the end of her "asking voting" bite.. she said Vote me Strictly on Dancing.. wow.. that is somethig yaar! she is a strong girl and i really have new respect for her and Gauhar! after tonite epi i would see her frustration! what's the point of having a choreographer if he is not willing to give you any tips.. she could do that all on her own then!!!
awww.. i love you msg to Parul!! same goes for me!! ALL THE BEST PARUL!! WISHING YOU A SPEEDY RECOVERY!!!
luv pri

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".