ammysamy thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#1
plzzz don't bash me.
it's just my view about current track
I think Mukthi suffered a lot compared to Nandini. Mukti was also in trauma but for some time but after that she managed herself very well.
but Nandini is being so weird. I know any girl will be shaken after whatever happened. but she is behaving as if she was tortured and molested for months or years.
the way she is behaving with manik is not right. there is no relation between her kidnap and music. but she is behaving sooo imamaturely
i'm not liking nandini after kidnapping drama.
and this mangalore track is not at all exciting me.
I think MaNan lose their charm🤢🤢🤢

Created

Last reply

Replies

9

Views

2k

Users

9

Likes

37

Frequent Posters

Paytonlee thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago
#2
Her music teacher is the one who kidnapped her and she is naive and never thought her own teacher who she respected thought of such things. This is the connection with music and her kidnapping

And about how a girl should act after going through the trauma she did i dont think any on us can comment unless we went through what she went through.
Edited by Paytonlee - 10 years ago
ArchRM thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#3
Even i think nandini is over reacting... she's under trauma but how long

I think Navya & Mukti suffered alot but still they overcame..


spnfan thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Most Posts (July 2022) Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 10 years ago
#4

Originally posted by: ArchanaRM

Even i think nandini is over reacting... she's under trauma but how long

I think Navya & Mukti suffered alot but still they overcame..


For us its 2 weeks but in kyy it has only been 2 days...
simidi thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#5
kind of agree with you her blaming herself and going of music is understandable seeing it was her music teacher but the way she is behaving is way ott
and like you said its not like she was raped or was kidnapped for weeks or months it was like an hour
and when first read about the track i thought she will be opposite like not want to go alone anywhere dont want to go to college asking chachi to sleep in her room having nightmare but i dont get the way nandani is behaving.
spnfan thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Most Posts (July 2022) Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 10 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: ArchanaRM

Even i think nandini is over reacting... she's under trauma but how long

I think Navya & Mukti suffered alot but still they overcame..


Mukti and navya suffered coz they were Also involved in whatever happened to them... Nandu was in no way at fault for whatever happened to her...
How long- its been only 2 days...
Compared to mukti - nandu didnt commit suicide or started having anti depression pills or sleep around or bully people or spit hatred around.. So we all know who is handling herself well compared to both of them...
_Manasa_ thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#7
I completely agree with you. Cvs have always shown Nandini as a strong girl who never gives up but what happened now? The way she is overreacting is way too much as if she has been kidnapped and tortured for weeks. I'm also not liking Nandini after kidnapping track.
Sayali_23 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
#8
it's sooo sooo easy to pass judgment...

wow... u want Nandini to react like Mukti?????

Ps: FYI

in case of Mukti took like more then 2 years to get over Harshad and became drug addict... when all that Rocky hangama happened Nandini stood up for her and that gave her confidence... other

in case of Navya again it was Nandini who supported and help her...

as for Nandini... expect for Manik nobody really know what exactly she is going through... can we just show sensitivity to Nandini and give her a break...🤔

Edited by Smiley_23 - 10 years ago
Opti thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 10 years ago
#9
Mukti and Navya invited the trouble on themselves. Mukti used sex as an anti-dote to her depression problem. So sleeping around wasn't new to her. She wasn't molested. She slept with Rocky out of her own free will. She went to the men's hostel out of her own free will. She had to bear the consequences of her promiscuity. While that doesn't justify what Rocky and his friends did, she wasn't an innocent babe in the woods. Even then the entire Fab 5 and Nandini and Navya had to come to her rescue.

Nandu is a traditional girl who believes in the sanctity of the relationship between a teacher and a student. Despite Manik's repeated warnings, she did not see Pandit's true face because she trusted in that relationship. His being her am's student only served to strengthen that trust. So when Pandit kidnapped her and locked her up in a music instrument box, it shook her to the core. Her self belief has been shaken. Her judgment has been shaken. So it is much more than just the physical violation at play here. The damage to her emotional well being is far more severe. It is not that the girl is not trying to overcome her inhibitions and fears. She reached out to Manik, she tries to hug him when he asked for it but the nightmare of Pandit is still fresh. Manik understands this and is ready to wait for her. Who are we to question how real is her pain.


By the way, did Nandu not wait patiently for Manik to heal from the hurt of being 'betrayed' by her when her doubt about Manik's violent nature when it comes to protecting her from harm seems valid considering how many times Manik kept screaming he would have killed Pandit for hurting Nandu in the current track.

True love is patient and tolerant. Nandu taught her man this and he is living it for her.
uniquebluerose thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
#10
Comparison of what Navya, Mukti and Nadini underwent and how they react is totally not fair!!!
Each one reacts to same situation in a different way...and if I remember Navya was also under depression for long time...it was not shown much as she is not the lead...
Nandini by nature is very sensitive person, in the beginning days when for the first time Manik and Dhruv fought she supported Manik just because she felt friends shouldn't fall apart and remember at that time she didn't even know Manik didn't do it that he was nice guy...

She was one person who was most affected when Mukti was insulted...she felt totally disturbed there is scene clearly depicting that...

So no...what Nandini is undergoing is actually realistic...its just that we are so thirsty for romance (all the hugging, touching and kissing) that we are disappointed and frustrated...

and girl blaming herself esp when a person whom she trusts abuses her is most natural reaction

Trying to trivialize such trauma is not fair...

That too because we are Manik fans who want any excuse of romance...which he and of course she brilliantly execute????

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".