EKTA vs GUL khan - Page 3

Created

Last reply

Replies

39

Views

7k

Users

25

Likes

155

Frequent Posters

arvifanalways thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#21

Originally posted by: MAYURFAN001

GUl khan gives her leads such amazing eye locks, sizzling dance numbers... Great gorgeous outfits, lavish sets, and the leads are always together ... Unlike Ekta who separated Arvi even before we could feel their love... Like wth!! Ekta really needs to learn a lot, at creativity


I totally agree with you!! The main difference between the 2 is that the leads are not separated by marrying them to others and they stay in love while facing other problems.
Whereas, Ekta makes it seem like marriage is the end for the couple , therefore she does not want to have them marry or stay together. I think a lot of viewers, like in the case of arvi , would like to see how they face problems TOGETHER after they are married.
nicegirl_good thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 12 years ago
#22
Ekta has her flaws
But she should not be compared with other producers
Sure her mind is a little twisted
But in all honesty , I would rather watch PVR than qubool hai
True I watch QH for KSG
But it's only his scenes I watch like you guys watch rithvik or ashas scenes
I watch rithvik and Shruti's scenes
And we are all entitled to our opinions
Coming to pr forum and being angry with ekta is one thing
But comparing with other producers is quite another
And that too specifically
QH is boring 😆
Pr is more interesting than qubool hai
There were days when I liked QH more
But on a long term basis ekta shows win over GK shows
And stop with bashing everything about the show
You don't like the storyline complain about it
You don't like the messages sent complain about it
Why compare with a newbie producer
Like it or not TV industry's expansion credit 60% goes to ekta
Look at the actors who made it to Bollywood
Rajeev, aamna , sushant are all Ekta's picks
And they are doing well
Her shows have a huge reach , reach outside on India forums and YouTube lol
dolly_11 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago
#23

Originally posted by: pari_roxx

All of Gul's stories have men slapping and emotionally abusing the female lead which is potrayed as the ultimate romance to viewers.
Atleast in Ekta's stories females have an upper hand




Gul makes the best love stories and no the guys are not hurting the female leads in Gul's shows tey are hurting themselves coz when they hurt their love the guilt kills them afterwards..

and don't u please compare ekta shows wit gul's shows
ekta's leads never end up together..they always compromise with some other person they don't love...and in my dream romance compromise sucks ..what's the point in staying with someone u don't love
dolly_11 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago
#24

Originally posted by: ilovedhanjanird

Ekta has her flaws
But she should not be compared with other producers
Sure her mind is a little twisted
But in all honesty , I would rather watch PVR than qubool hai
True I watch QH for KSG
But it's only his scenes I watch like you guys watch rithvik or ashas scenes
I watch rithvik and Shruti's scenes
And we are all entitled to our opinions
Coming to pr forum and being angry with ekta is one thing
But comparing with other producers is quite another
And that too specifically
QH is boring 😆
Pr is more interesting than qubool hai
There were days when I liked QH more
But on a long term basis ekta shows win over GK shows
And stop with bashing everything about the show
You don't like the storyline complain about it
You don't like the messages sent complain about it
Why compare with a newbie producer
Like it or not TV industry's expansion credit 60% goes to ekta
Look at the actors who made it to Bollywood
Rajeev, aamna , sushant are all Ekta's picks
And they are doing well
Her shows have a huge reach , reach outside on India forums and YouTube lol




Ekta has same story in every show
the guy and girl meet they fall in love and then due to some circumstances tey seperate and then some other guy who is oh so sweet and nice comes in the girl's life and she settles with him and compromises..this story is being repeated since kasauti zindagi ki times...
bade achay had the same story and their are several more

Gul Khan creates the best romantic scenes no body can match her in that not even a yash raj movie no wonder she has all the youth gone crazy over her shows and when ever the romance track in her shows comes the show touches the sky in the trp charts

IPKKND was fab and QH is very very entertaining
her characters have psychological insight in their personalities and always fall for a person who is a complete opposite but here the beauty of their love cmes out and the love beats all their complexes and they unite

Gul has got me hooked wit her shows
I am considered a crazy girl in my family coz of IPK and QH just cuz i can't stop blushing and smiling to myslef ..i am so damn involved that they tink i m crazy😳😳
MAYURFAN001 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#25
@ JOSH :The problem with Ekta is she does not where to stop.. Zee tv will never tell EKTA to take her shows of fair even when it is plunging. Eta needs to draw the line of when her show is no longer cool.. Currently PR is competing with QH in every which way.. Almost every PR fan is watching QH and they are drawing a direct comparison between these shows at he PRESENT TIME so it makes no sense to say PR was good in the past etc.. Because TRPS are based on current tracks and storylines .. So Ekta needs to admit that currently compared to QH her show looks like garbage with so many characters and too many love stories being forced down our throats..

I have the remote and I change channels when PR comes on and turn it back on for QH.. That's not the problem.. We are discussing Ekta's obsession with dragging story lines with no logical sense

nicegirl_good thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 12 years ago
#26
Ekta made shows like kis desh too LOL
Yeah sure she drags and repeats storyline
But most of my memorable shows have been Ekta's shows
Be it kahiin to hoga , kis desh and I still watch episodes of kasturi, kahiin to hoga, kis desh
She gave us stars like harshad Chopra , Rajeev Khandelwal , sushant , rithvik, Vivian Dsena , anupriya , aamna , kritika, karan kundra, additi gupta , sanjeeda sheikh, Hiten tejwani , Gauri tejwani , Jennifer Singh, sukriti Kandpal, shabbir ahluwalia, prachi desai, ram kapoor, ronit Roy , etc
Sure she repeats storyline but to say how Gul khan should be her inspiration and she should learn something is plain wrong
Ekta did make good shows ; kis desh, kasturi , PKYEK , kahiin to hoga
Ekta's hit couple Rajeev aamna is STILL remembered after 9 years
Gauri and Hiten , the best Jodi of the decade was her casting
You know if there was no ekta many of you wouldn't have Gul khan to chant on
Star plus became the best channel in co operation with ekta kapoor for YEARS

It's okay to have your views on qubool hai and IPKNND and geet
But it's completely wrong to disrespect Ekta's work
I make fun of ekta and her concepts too
And I think she should stop repeating tracks
But it's her craft. , she is giving us 22 minutes of entertainment
If we can't respect her , we shouldn't disrespect her by comparing her to a complete new director
arvifanalways thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#27

Originally posted by: MAYURFAN001

@ JOSH :The problem with Ekta is she does not where to stop.. Zee tv will never tell EKTA to take her shows of fair even when it is plunging. Eta needs to draw the line of when her show is no longer cool.. Currently PR is competing with QH in every which way.. Almost every PR fan is watching QH and they are drawing a direct comparison between these shows at he PRESENT TIME so it makes no sense to say PR was good in the past etc.. Because TRPS are based on current tracks and storylines .. So Ekta needs to admit that currently compared to QH her show looks like garbage with so many characters and too many love stories being forced down our throats..


I have the remote and I change channels when PR comes on and turn it back on for QH.. That's not the problem.. We are discussing Ekta's obsession with dragging story lines with no logical sense

THANKS for stating exactly how i felt MAYURFAN001 👏😊. I also wanted to add that, we all have remotes to our TV's but that does not man we can't objectively discuss stuff on this public forum. It is our call as to what we want to see and what we want to discuss.
arvifanalways thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#28



Gul makes the best love stories and no the guys are not hurting the female leads in Gul's shows tey are hurting themselves coz when they hurt their love the guilt kills them afterwards..

and don't u please compare ekta shows wit gul's shows
ekta's leads never end up together..they always compromise with some other person they don't love...and in my dream romance compromise sucks ..what's the point in staying with someone u don't love


I agree with you , men in gul's shows are NOTabusing the females and the girls in Gul's shows are much stronger and independent . On the other hand, ekta has women doing unnecessary sacrificing and so called mahantaa. I for one can't relate to these women. If ekta brought the fighter purvi back i will love watching the show, the sacrifice queen mishti is not who i want to see🤢
Edited by arvifanalways - 12 years ago
pallavi25 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 12 years ago
#29
Gul Khan does show more romance in her shows than Ekta does...long eyelocks and heroine always tripping and falling in hero's arms 😆.
But Gul's heros are too dominating and abusive, they insult and abuse the heroine right from day one and the heroine still falls for him and acts like a doormat. I dont like that...insults and emotional abuse? ...all in the name of love?
Ekta's couples are just the opposite, hero starts out as an aggressive, arrogant he-man but becomes a bheegi billi from sher after falling in love with the righteous, lecture-prone heroine. 😆 But I still prefer that to the doormat and abuser love story. 😆

I also curse Ekta when she shows absurd plots and characters, evil people getting away with misdeeds...
BUT I just LOVE Ekta for giving us such evergreen couples as Sujal-Kashish, Angad-Kripa, Pratham-Gauri, Manav-Archana(in their heydays) etc. Shes the best jodimaker in the industry. And she has given us too many great actors and actresses to even count! Gul Khan is a novice before her.
Edited by pallavi25 - 12 years ago
latanzia thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago
#30
Look there is no comparison between these two producer, they each have their own style.
In my opinion Gul does romance best, ekta falter in this department.
I like both of these women equally, but i think the problem with ekta is that she has her hand dip into too many pots, and her show suffer. Pavitra ishta right now is a hot mess, there are too many character and too many side stories, you never know what you will get when u turn on the tv.
Yes this show will be 4 year in june so what , what has it accomplish, a little more emphasis need to be place into this show, they need fresh writers and ideas
Edited by latanzia - 12 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".