Feedback to CVs thread- Story distortion#2 - Page 24

Created

Last reply

Replies

1.1k

Views

97.8k

Users

99

Likes

4.2k

Frequent Posters

srishtisingh thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
@shani I agree cvs donot want to spoil arjun image because there are many people who see dwapar yuga with 21st century lens
nd to my dismay I have encountered such people. if u go by cvs story trend they have been doing this from start.its 21st century mb
I would have preferred dwapar yug perspective because mb for me is not to find out "who is right or wrong".rather it is way to tell" what is right and what is wrong".but hete I really donot blame cvs because unhe sabko khush ralhna h.I want to watch this show because I love mb.this is the epic I am mad abt.not actors not any particular character. I watch it to learn and understand how complex a human mind is.yep this version is halua and pulav.I agree.but nw I try to look at its rather good points than getting irritated by it b/c irritation was futile. to b honest when I watch I am leaving the old mb behind and try watching through cvs lens.how they have intrepreted characters and their dillema or stigma.inconsistencies are there but this is the only serial I watch
Medha.S thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago

Originally posted by: Sabhayata

actually what happens is that arjuna when he is dwarka during his exile falls for subhadra at first sight and it is he who asks krishna ji how he can obtain subhadra which is when krishan ji tells him that balram wants to marry her off to Dury and if he wants to marry subhadra he will have to kidnap her

So its Arjuna who gets attracted to subhadra and wants to marry her and asks krishna ji about it .Its not krishan ji who suggets it.


Ummm, i was reading KMG, and Krishna is the one giving the suggestion and Arjuna isthe one agreeing to it.
WindsOfHeaven thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Banner Contest Winner Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 11 years ago

Originally posted by: Sabhayata

This whole mandap drama is inspired from SP serials where all the marriage drama happens at the mandap only

Dulha's get changed,dulhan's get changed,Dulha's run away and dulhan's run away everything happens at the mandap only

🤣

Btw, the spoiler also mentioned that Bhishma refused to bless Arjuna and Subhadra. I guess even this is inspired from a daily soap. 😆
...Diala... thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago

Originally posted by: Medha.S


Ummm, i was reading KMG, and Krishna is the one giving the suggestion and Arjuna isthe one agreeing to it.



From KMG.. It is Arjuna who fell for Subhadra.. Krishna only suggests the way to get her..


When that delightful festival of immense grandeur commenced, Vasudeva and Partha went about, together, beholding everything around. While wandering there, they saw the handsome daughter of Vasudeva, Bhadra by name, decked with every ornament, in the midst of her maids. As soon as Arjuna beheld her he was possessed by the god of desire.

Then, O Bharata, that tiger among men, Krishna, observing Partha contemplate her with absorbed attention,said with a smile, 'How is this? Can the heart of one that rangeth the woods be agitated by the god of desire? This is my sister, O Partha, and the uterine sister of Sarana. Blest be thou, her name is Bhadra and she is the favourite daughter of my father. Tell me if thy heart is fixed upon her, for I shall then speak to my father myself.'

"Arjuna answered, 'She is Vasudeva's daughter and Vasudeva's (Krishna) sister; endued with so much beauty, whom can she not fascinate? If this thy sister, this maid of the Vrishni race, becometh my wife, truly may I win prosperity in everything. Tell me, O Janardana, by what means I may obtain her. To get her I will achieve anything that is achievable by man.'

"Vasudeva answered, 'O bull amongst men, self-choice hath been ordained for the marriage of Kshatriyas. But that is doubtful (in its consequences), O Partha, as we do not know this girl's temper and disposition. In the case of Kshatriyas that are brave, a forcible abduction for purposes of marriage is applauded, as the learned have said. Therefore O Arjuna, carry away this my beautiful sister by force, for who knows what she may do at a self-choice.'
Edited by ...Diala... - 11 years ago
Justitia thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
Who wrote last week's spoiler article?!? And what were they smoking???
Karna & Arjun almost came to blows right at the entrance of IP!!🤣 - but Arjun was still doing namaste and all...😛
Kitna saara gussa - fantastic bromance!! 😆
Thank heavens Arjun didn't approve of Karna -Vrushali but only talked in terms of her "suraksha" - I mean how awkward would that have been!!😳
Madhav permitted Vrushali to go with Karna - YAY!!
Were the Pandavas actually eavesdropping on Karna & Vrushali?!? 🤣
Awww...looks like Bhrata Bheem is a softie for love-stories!! ❤️
Was that liquid green or blue in colour - spoiler said green, looked like blue...I've gone colour-blind!!
So, the "nagar poojan" thing was basically an excuse for initiating Arjun's exile?!? I mean, as per mamujaan, once the nagar poojan is complete, Pandavas have the green signal to perform the rajsuya yagya...matlab Subhi ka IP aane ke baad rajsuya yagya ka preparation should begin - after next to next week I suppose!!

Monday ko we will see Yudi-Drau ka chausar khel, Takshak ka snake attack, and Arjun exile commencement (possibly)
Edited by shani88 - 11 years ago
guenhwyvar thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago

Originally posted by: -Shruti

🤣

Btw, the spoiler also mentioned that Bhishma refused to bless Arjuna and Subhadra. I guess even this is inspired from a daily soap. 😆

But wait ... Bhishma kidnapped the princesses of Kashi for his younger brother ... what the fork is SP doing with a perfectly nice love story ...

I wonder if they are doing this so Arjun and Subhi can get a "kick" out of telling Abhimanyu there love story...

Arjun: "So Abhi, first what happened is I went to Dwarka where your mother was staying. We met before, 50 years before she was actually supposed to be born, but the creators of StarBharat were so kind to let us meet before and not age a single bit. I wasn't interested in her back then one bit."

Subhi: "Shhh Arya! Tell him the real story, not the emotional aatyachar you caused me by favoring that horsie..."

Arjun: "But Jaanu, that horse was sexy. **Subhi gives him a look** So I go to Dwarka, see your mom, and realize that your uncle - Duryodhan was going to marry her! So I did what any kshatriya is supposed to do - we eloped."

Subhi: "And the genius warrior your father is ... he got lost and instead of going home to IP, he drives us back to Dwarka ..."

Arjun: "But mere praano ke praan! I realized that if I go to IP, then I would have to face Panchali. I figured after we elope, I can just drop you back to your maike and life will be good!"

Subhi: "Really ... we elope and you can drop me back ... what the BEEP is wrong with you"

Abhi: "tell me more mommy and daddy"

Arjun: "Ok kiddo. So after we return to dwarka, we approach the wedding mandak that was meant for your uncle duryodhana and your mother. Your uncle is very very angry and his friend (and my friend too) Karna is there too smiling happily. I bowed to him and a tear rolled down his eyes, he was that happy!"

[Author's note: OMG!! This might be the turning point of Karna-Arjun's bromance..]

Subhi: "So your uncle is like "Kya isko (referring to me) bhi aap paanch me baat diya jayega! and everyone laughs. And your father pulls out his Gandhiva and aims an arrow and yells out "Subhadra ka aapman karne wali, mastak lene ka pran hai mera!!" I was so happy that he said that for me! He married 2 other women, but to this day it's those words that keep me with him!"

Abhi: "But matashri! Jyesth mata Draupadi to kehti hain ke yeh dialogue to uske liya pitashree neh kaha tah. Woh kya line tha: 'Panchaali ka aapman karne wali, mastak lene ka pran hai mera!!'

*Subhadra shoots Arjun a look of anger, Arjun looks sheepish*

Arjun: "aare Abhi beta. Chuup hojawo ... kya aaj bhi tere pitashree ko pitne dekhna chaate ho tere matashree ke haatho se!"

Abhi: "Phir kya hua"

Subhi: "aab kya hoga. Ab aap so ja ... tere pitashree ka aisi ki tesi hogi"

Abhi: "Mujhe be dekhna hai!!"

(was getting long as is ... so decided to stop there)
🤣
Edited by shyam09 - 11 years ago
DrModel thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 11 years ago

Originally posted by: Medha.S


Ummm, i was reading KMG, and Krishna is the one giving the suggestion and Arjuna isthe one agreeing to it.


EXACTLY!! even the one translation considered THE WORD on this forum, where all else is considered conjecture and imagination states that Krishna advises Arjuna that Indraprastha needs to make friends and form relations with other kings so that there can be people who will favor indraprastha as this will help Yudi towards his Samrat goal. Then Kanha adds that marriages are considered a great way of forming alliances.

AND it was ALWAYS Subhi who loved Arjun more than he loved her; ALWAYS, She even waits for him to make his way to Dwarka at the end of his exile,

THEN, to prevent her marrying Duri and to get her married to Parth so that Abhimanyu would come and to work things in favor of a DHARM following and UNIFIED India; it is Krishna who gets them married.

Even the Oxford University School of Hindu Studies critiqued version of The Mahabharat states EXACTLY this.
Edited by DrModel - 11 years ago
Sabhayata thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 11 years ago

Originally posted by: ...Diala...



From KMG.. It is Arjuna who fell for Subhadra.. Krishna only suggests the way to get her..


Thanks for the citation Diala you saved my time.And why Subhadra arjuna even married Chitrangada becuass he liked her.And even Bheem married Valandhara becuase he liked her.But i guess shani is right since this is a modern MB they cant show pandavas falling in love again after being married to Drau
Sabhayata thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 11 years ago

Originally posted by: DrModel


EXACTLY!! even the one translation considered THE WORD on this forum, where all else is considered conjecture and imagination states that Krishna advises Arjuna that Indraprastha needs to make friends and form relations with other kings so that there can be people who will favor indraprastha as this will help Yudi towards his Samrat goal. Then Kanha adds that marriages are considered a great way of forming alliances.

No it doesnt .Read the citation posted by Diala it clealry states first arjuna only asks krishna ji how he can obtain subhadra
Sabhayata thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 11 years ago
@shyam your imaginary converstaion between Arjuna,Subhadra and Abhimanyu
🤣🤣
We met before, 50 years before she was actually supposed to be born, but the creators of StarBharat were so kind to let us meet before and not age a single bit.
So your uncle is like "Kya isko (referring to me) bhi aap paanch me baat diya jayega! and everyone laughs
Abhi: "But matashri! Jyesth mata Draupadi to kehti hain ke yeh dialogue to uske liya pitashree neh kaha tah. Woh kya line tha: 'Panchaali ka aapman karne wali, mastak lene ka pran hai mera!!'

*Subhadra shoots Arjun a look of anger, Arjun looks sheepish*

Arjun: "aare Abhi beta. Chuup hojawo ... kya aaj bhi tere pitashree ko pitne dekhna chaate ho tere matashree ke haatho se!"

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".