Why didn't Jalal defend himself? - Page 4

Created

Last reply

Replies

45

Views

3.5k

Users

21

Likes

96

Frequent Posters

abhi786 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
#31
Jodha's Ghirna is justified as

1. They looted the temple and also destroying and kiiled soliders in that temple and tried to take away Motibai, who is her best friend..

2. Killed Rajput soliders not in the battle but after they won the war that to brutally...

I think, in flash back, he knew that mandir was looted as he got the flashback...That time he didn't think that much, as that time his main aim to win the war only but now he wants to rule over their hearts..

Whatever intensely she told, Jalaal understood as he is changed a bit, previously that he is thinking and acting accordingly to BK and Maham. But now he wants to change and also win their hearts especially Jodha's as he couldn't bear her hate..


ILTHBEB thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 12 years ago
#32

Originally posted by: munnirony



maybe but tht time BK used to handle evrything, so maybe he dont know how cruel actually his sainiks were. he is definitely guilty, but tht time due to BK many things actually didnt came to him.


perhaps..n this is true he knew mandir has been looted but abt massive havoc he was unaware now heard abt this frm jodha, he over turn felt guilty knowing his own soldiers behavior..but cvs didn't execute this issue plausibly before viewers.
munni_rajatfan thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 12 years ago
#33

Originally posted by: ASRaddictKKG



Oye, i love Jalal. I'm just saying Jodha ke POV se. Remember jab he comes to her room and kind of manhandles her? I'm talking about stuff like that. aur jODha to jhalli hai sirf gandi cheezein yaad rakhti hai.

I love Jodha and Jalal equally yaara!


no actually u said na ki we criticize her "ghrina". we dont criticize her "ghrina", we just wanted say she only notices bad things thts it. when jalal is wrong we criticize him, but just like jalal is not completely "jallad" , jodha is also not fully right.
.GrangerMalfoy. thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago
#34

Originally posted by: munnirony



no actually u said na ki we criticize her "ghrina". we dont criticize her "ghrina", we just wanted say she only notices bad things thts it. when jalal is wrong we criticize him, but just like jalal is not completely "jallad" , jodha is also not fully right.



Jalal completely ni thoda Jallad b nai h. Sweet sa cute sa to h bechara. :*

No one's always completely right or wrong. Dono sai b hai galat b :)
abhi786 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
#35
cou

Originally posted by: munnirony


if he wants to be a monstar he can get worst. he allowed her to practice her religion & in those times tht was a big step. jalal doesnt need to ask for forgiveness from anyone, but still he did it & noone can force him for anything. he is not a monster, he is a person with certain bad qualities. monsters dont feel for anything. she is right, but few point of views need to be changed for sure.



If Jalaal didn't agree to practice her religion, that she would not agreed for the marriage... As before marriage, she has asked for 2 conditions only to escape from the marriage...

Jalaal agreed to the condition, as he wants to marry jodha and even maham opposed later.. But he did it to cut her feather " Par katna and Gurur thodna"... After marriage, he announced before the court to sing and he very well knows she hate him, why he was hurt when Ruqu told Jodha doesn't want jaal or even think about her...

He tried to show her "Neecha" every step with Ruqu help also in chess, in sword fight he got attracted to her beauty...

He didn't used the HAQ of being husband to her, nor touched her, as he was not cruel or Jallad,

Both are right in their perspective thinking about each other... As their marriage itself started with hatred.

After MC and sucide track, he understood her and started his steps in working this marriage while jodha still in the same place, and soon need to take the steps to understand jalaal
Edited by abhi786 - 12 years ago
Super Kool thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago
#36
I guess...because he has it in him to shoulder the responsibility of his men...like a true leader he wouldn't hide behind an excuse and isolate himself...no...he would never do that...he would rectify the problem rather than looking for excuse and indulging in blame game...😳
munni_rajatfan thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 12 years ago
#37

Originally posted by: abhi786

cou

If Jalaal didn't agree to practice her religion, that she would not agreed for the marriage... As before marriage, she has asked for 2 conditions only to escape from the marriage...

Jalaal agreed to the condition, as he wants to marry jodha and even maham opposed later.. But he did it to cut her feather " Par katna and Gurur thodna"... After marriage, he announced before the court to sing and he very well knows she hate him, why he was hurt when Ruqu told Jodha doesn't want jaal or even think about her...

He tried to show her "Neecha" every step with Ruqu help also in chess, in sword fight he got attracted to her beauty...

He didn't used the HAQ of being husband to her, nor touched her, as he was not cruel or Jallad,

Both are right in their perspective thinking about each other... As their marriage itself started with hatred.

After MC and sucide track, he understood her and started his steps in working this marriage while jodha still in the same place, and soon need to take the steps to understand jalaal


plz read my posts carefully. i never said he is pure or he is the saint. i just said he is not a bad person. yes he agreed bcoz he wanted to marry her, but jodha was bond to marry him to save her people whether he agreed or disagreed. 2ndly, he could have stopped her after their marriage also. yes he did few wrong things bcoz of his ego, but tht doesnt mean his gud things should be sidelined.
chak thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#38
Jalal explained Maham about his temple visit "Was it true" r he was just consoling his Badi ammi so that she doesn't feel bad...I wonder whether his dialogues were really true...was it just Satisfactory talks...Pls do comment my dear JAians...
shahbhavini thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 12 years ago
#39
everyone is connecting temple and war together. Temple loote happened way in beginning that time Jalal didn't even heard about Jodha and There was no planning of war at that time. Solider said lot about Jodha so Jalal wanted to see her and their he heard that Jodha wants to kill him to teach her a lesson war happend.
Temple Loot was part of Mugals before Jodha came in his life so he didn't said a word about it... he knew that he was worng.
Autumn_Rose thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 12 years ago
#40

Originally posted by: abhi786

Jodha's Ghirna is justified as

1. They looted the temple and also destroying and kiiled soliders in that temple and tried to take away Motibai, who is her best friend.. Yes.. but she is obsessed with hating him😕Its not normal😆

2. Killed Rajput soliders not in the battle but after they won the war that to brutally..What does she expect.. They cannot kill people with love. War is war.

I think, in flash back, he knew that mandir was looted as he got the flashback...That time he didn't think that much, as that time his main aim to win the war only but now he wants to rule over their hearts..
I still feel its a blooper. The CVs messed up
Whatever intensely she told, Jalaal understood as he is changed a bit, previously that he is thinking and acting accordingly to BK and Maham. But now he wants to change and also win their hearts especially Jodha's as he couldn't bear her hate..
I don't think its because of Jodha. Things were more in control of BK earlier.. Jalal was never interested in looting or torturing his people

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".