Is Shivaay doing the right thing? - Page 2

Originally posted by: EnasZ

actually yes ... i don't think there's anything wrong with wanting to know her past

it's not like he said i will only accept her after knowing ... he didn't even say anything hurtfull

maybe i didn't understand the scene well ... but i don't think there's nothing wrong with finding the truth out ... that is what annika is doing with mahi isn't it?

the fact remains that even if Annika's parents turn out to be as (without NKK) as sahil's parents were then it won't make a difference

plus u can't expect him to just erase the NKK like that from his head ... yet he was clear on the fact that annika matters more or else he wouldn't have sat in the pooja in the first place

she said for Shivaay, NKK matters more than her which is not true or else he wouldn't have returned in the first place so in my opinion nothing is wrong in that

plus shivaay has all rescources to find out about her parents and her family so y shouldn't he do it?

Originally posted by: afghangirl

On the hand Anika is doing the same thing by doing DNA test.

Originally posted by: EnasZ

exactly ... if she can look for mahi's truth since it's connected to shivaay's so y can't he?

Originally posted by: EnasZ

actually yes ... i don't think there's anything wrong with wanting to know her past

it's not like he said i will only accept her after knowing ... he didn't even say anything hurtfull

maybe i didn't understand the scene well ... but i don't think there's nothing wrong with finding the truth out ... that is what annika is doing with mahi isn't it?

the fact remains that even if Annika's parents turn out to be as (without NKK) as sahil's parents were then it won't make a difference

plus u can't expect him to just erase the NKK like that from his head ... yet he was clear on the fact that annika matters more or else he wouldn't have sat in the pooja in the first place

she said for Shivaay, NKK matters more than her which is not true or else he wouldn't have returned in the first place so in my opinion nothing is wrong in that

plus shivaay has all rescources to find out about her parents and her family so y shouldn't he do it?

Originally posted by: --Nargis--

Yes...I think he has a right to want to help her track down her background. Remember Annika alone did not have the means to be able to do it, but SSO has the means and the methods to find information on her background. And like someone above says, how different is it than Annika doing a DNA test on Mahi's blood to see if he is Shivvay's twin?? Woh bhi HAQ se kar rahi hai na??!!

Originally posted by: -JollyJabeen-JB

But she wanted to share it with Shivaay. Seeing his whole reaction to her mentioning Mahi maybe stopped her.. and she wants proof before she makes an accusation. In Annika's case, it was always implied she didn't have any NKK, something Shivaay must have known.. so the sudden resurgance in trying to find out about it's just.. mmm

Sry but cant agree wid u here...wt ever shivaay is doing is right as her hubby...i mean here anika also try to find abt mahi doing DNA test... is it right ?

See here shivaay accepted her as his wife so he's just trying to find her WIFE BG if u see the epi shivaay clearly said that he wants to know his wife BG not anika...he also said that wtever the situation is...anika is not responsible for that...shivaay as SSO for him NKK is very imp but he doesn't care when it comes to his wife...here shivaay galat hota if he tried to find her past before accepting her as his wife but NO first he accepted her then trying to know her past...

If u see yest epi shivaay had no problem when he came to know that sahil parent's was that much poor (as he thought anika sahil has khoon ka rishta) by knowing this he told that he'll make sure ke anika ko wo respect mile jiski wo haqdaar hai ...this shows that he just wanna know about her past...it doesn't matter for him that her parent's is rich or poor ...

So yaa i think wt ever shivaay is doing is right as her husband...he's just trying to know her WIFE BG not anika 😃

Since as now shivaay trying to dig her past...i blv smthing is major coming up...not the illegitimate one but i think her past must be related to oberois as shivaay is instigating...

I might be the odd one out ...But I am with Shivaay at this..!!

Originally posted by: B_Blunt

Sry but cant agree wid u here...wt ever shivaay is doing is right as her hubby...i mean here anika also try to find abt mahi doing DNA test... is it right ?

See here shivaay accepted her as his wife so he's just trying to find her WIFE BG if u see the epi shivaay clearly said that he wants to know his wife BG not anika...he also said that wtever the situation is...anika is not responsible for that...shivaay as SSO for him NKK is very imp but he doesn't care when it comes to his wife...here shivaay galat hota if he tried to find her past before accepting her as his wife but NO first he accepted her then trying to know her past...

If u see yest epi shivaay had no problem when he came to know that sahil parent's was that much poor (as he thought anika sahil has khoon ka rishta) by knowing this he told that he'll make sure ke anika ko wo respect mile jiski wo haqdaar hai ...this shows that he just wanna know about her past...it doesn't matter for him that her parent's is rich or poor ...

So yaa i think wt ever shivaay is doing is right as her husband...he's just trying to know her WIFE BG not anika 😃

Since as now shivaay trying to dig her past...i blv smthing is major coming up...not the illegitimate one but i think her past must be related to oberois as shivaay is instigating...

Originally posted by: DAMZLS

@bold I agree! apart from trying to find out for his own beliefs, he is also doing it to shut everyone's mouth up about her once and for all. Today Pinki ranted to Shivaay about their children questioning Anika's lineage (so dumb really!) and Annika lamented to Shivaay about her struggles and fights to survive the brutal world.

Obviously he'd want to end that uncertainty about Annika by trying to find some answers. And all this only after he has assured her his unwavering support.

Look at him holding her lovingly through all this! He's her biggest support system and in his head wants to end that one insecurity she has about herself. As a husband, he has a right to do that!

He's not wrong here.

😊 yes this is what i m trying to say that he want to shut everyone's mouth...wt ever he's doing is not just only for him but also for anika his wife...the way he holding her today so lovingly clearly shows that he can't see her like this...she's his taaqat strength but right now she's broken from inside...holding her like this shows no matter what but he'll never let her go anywhere...he will not leave her in future so I blv he's right here 😃 😳