No bashing pls (seems like a permanent statement on my posts nowadays ...lol)
Feel free to jump in and comment - just brainstorming here only because for a long time my detective mind is having trouble fitting in the jig-saw puzzle. I know it is a soap so logic is useless but there are too many red flags I am noticing so here goes :
1. Mrs. Kapoor does not, form what I can see, care for Tia's well-being. She has proven that time and again and is both mentally and physically abusive to her. Almost step motherly but with a hidden hatred, as though something about Tia unsettles her. It is almost like she is fine with using Tia and has no issues with how much and to what extent.
** Tia is not her child. She is probably illegimate. Mr. Kapoor's offspring but not hers.
2. Tia seems like she is trying to win her love and will go to any extent to please her. She has these bursts when Dushyant (who I must say I feel sorry for and seems like a nice guy) does matter to her and all she would like to do is 'live happily after' with him. That she truly loves him I do not doubt no matter how much of a vamp she has turned into. Lets use logic and be unemotional here in our deductions.
** Mr. Kapoor is being held as a prisoner and Tia is being blackmailed to do what she is doing. Dushyant has probably joined him so that he stays out of Tia's way **
3. Dushyant had a free pass to Shivvay's house when Tia was only visiting occasionally but he seems to have vanished into thin air. That the man is as obsessive and possessive about Tia as Shivvay is about Annika is something I have mentioned often. Even when said his 'shayari' for the sangeet they had Dushyant in the background and I always thought that was meant as much for him as it was for Shivvay.
** Tied up and locked in some room by Mrs. Kapoor***
4. Mr. Kapoor - I have already mentioned what may have happened to him. he probably opposed the marriage to Shivvay when he came to know Tia is already married. This is a long shot, he probably knows Annika's past and will recognize the bracelet when we finally get to see him.