Understanding Ishaana | A Contemplation on a Complicated Character - Page 3

Created

Last reply

Replies

54

Views

4.7k

Users

25

Likes

159

Frequent Posters

highonshows thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
#21
Such a beautiful analysis on a complex child woman...
Out of all the pairs I really love Ishaani and Omkara ...they don't only look good together but there is something special about them...

N my second choice is Rudra and somya...there is genuinely childlike innocence I. Rudra who is always protected by his brothers...while somya is mature beyond her age yet refreshing ... Love how they are breaking the stereotypes of a fit guy always falls for a sexy girl...

Anika and shivaay...r supposed to be older...and yet look so immature when fighting inverse silly things...the only thing I like there is the comfy aspect. Their characters need improvement so these wonderful actors can perform them at their full potential.

Thanq for giving us an insight on Ishaana...

Would love to read ur take on Omkara...if u will indulge us.
hi50 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 9 years ago
#22

Originally posted by: LiveEatLove

I loved what you wrote but the major problem lies in the execution by the writers .

They are messing it up. In the latter portion in th mansion where she expresses her desire to steal the vase or showpiece, she came across as a kleptomaniac or thief...I dont know. Ishana is super fun but they need to give her explanations to Om and Ridhima more logic .
And I want the writers to show more of her family problems for the viewers to connect with her predicament.


I agree..!! I blame CVs for this 😕... Looks like they don't think much about Ishana's character..!

I like that she is 'Ishana' with Om..!! And honest in front of him...😊

But what are those baseless dancing coming from? And she uses an iPhone, but clams that she is poor..! 😆😆
And her family, what do they do? Is her sister studying? Does Ishana try to do a job rather that following rich guys? I understand that her father is a gambler and strives on daughter's money that she earns by cheating others..!

These days I simple skip her scenes, hope CVs will seriously work on Ishana soon..


Echo.of.Hope thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 9 years ago
#23
Firstly, brilliant 👏👏👏 Standing ovation

I know that most won't comment on this particular point but I understand your MBTI references so...

I have also thought that Ishana is an E*FP. I was thinking more of ESFP than ENFP. She doesn't seem to generally overthink. If she did overthink everything she did she might have predicted Riddhima's presence and had a backup plan for it.

Omkara seemed more like an INFJ to me. This must be because I have met quite a few INFPs and INFJs and Om struck me as the latter. There hasn't been a situation where he doesn't have a plan or just wings it. After Shivay and Tej I feel that he's the most organized in the family.

ESFP-INFJ or ENFP-INFP, this couple is rare and should be carefully dealt with. If CVs do a good job this couple can set a trend for future E*FP-INF* couples in Indian television.

Since we are on the topic of MBTII though I'll just tell you my categorization of the other characters and you can tell me what you think.

Om- INFJ (Hufflepuff)
Ishana- ESFP (Slytherin)
Shivay - INTJ (Ravenclaw)
Anika- ENFP (Gryffindor)
Rudra- ESFP (Hufflepuff)
Soumya- ENFJ (Gryffindor)
Tej- ENTJ (Slytherin)
Jahnvi- ISFP (Gryffindor)
Pinky- ENF* (Ravenclaw)

I know I added the four houses😳😆
Just saying, I would like to hear you view. Having an MBTI discussion on the characters is awesome. Hope this doesn't bother you.

vidya29 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#24
"She is a beautiful chaos of incomplete thoughts and indecision".indeed.Aptly said.
This was much needed. I feel the reason she is so hated is because she is the closest to being a real person.She isn't perfect,she isn't beyond reach,she is quite ordinarily beautiful.
To top it all off,she has been paired with The Omkaara.A character with immense potential and unreal appeal.He is Draco Malfoy to me.A character written with simple intentions but was elevated by one man's interpretation and appeal of it.People romanticised his character,just like they somewhat justifiably do with Omkaara.Being such a glorious and loved character's better half would warrant some scrutiny.
You brought them forward quite well.If not anyone else I was forced to view Ishana in a different perspective.
Thanks for the post.

-Abhiya- thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
#25
this post was really needed
people were bashing Ishana continously
I hope now they will understand her character through ur post
QueenofGreen thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 9 years ago
#26

Originally posted by: Echo.of.Hope

Firstly, brilliant 👏👏👏 Standing ovation

I know that most won't comment on this particular point but I understand your MBTI references so...

I have also thought that Ishana is an E*FP. I was thinking more of ESFP than ENFP. She doesn't seem to generally overthink. If she did overthink everything she did she might have predicted Riddhima's presence and had a backup plan for it.

Omkara seemed more like an INFJ to me. This must be because I have met quite a few INFPs and INFJs and Om struck me as the latter. There hasn't been a situation where he doesn't have a plan or just wings it. After Shivay and Tej I feel that he's the most organized in the family.

ESFP-INFJ or ENFP-INFP, this couple is rare and should be carefully dealt with. If CVs do a good job this couple can set a trend for future E*FP-INF* couples in Indian television.

Since we are on the topic of MBTII though I'll just tell you my categorization of the other characters and you can tell me what you think.

Om- INFJ (Hufflepuff)
Ishana- ESFP (Slytherin)
Shivay - INTJ (Ravenclaw)
Anika- ENFP (Gryffindor)
Rudra- ESFP (Hufflepuff)
Soumya- ENFJ (Gryffindor)
Tej- ENTJ (Slytherin)
Jahnvi- ISFP (Gryffindor)
Pinky- ENF* (Ravenclaw)

I know I added the four houses😳😆
Just saying, I would like to hear you view. Having an MBTI discussion on the characters is awesome. Hope this doesn't bother you.


Hi! I love a good MBTI discussion! I would love to start a new thread for this, but I'm sure most people will not participate.

For Ishaana, I originally thought ESFP because she quite reminds me of Catwoman who is a very famous ESFP. However, looking deeper into the character, I think Ishaana is more likely an ENFP, but a turbulent one. She is not consistent. She sways between being rash, and overthinking, but more often than not, her emotions get in the way. I think ESFPs are more practical as well, so I'm going to stick with ENFP for Ishaana.

I believed Omkara to be an INFJ at the outset as well, but I can definitely say that he is an INFP, because of all the characters on this show, he is least likely to be a J. He is not judgemental, he is wise, self less and of an escapist mentality. He is easily the mediator of the family, constantly in search of peace and harmony. He is also very open minded, and often too idealistic. My sister is an INFP and I see a striking similarity between these two. They say similar things, believe in very similar ideologies. I also disagree, I don't think Omkara is as organised as you claim him to be. He is an artist, and most artists flourish in messy environments. Even the way he presents himself, is with a complete disregard for what he is wearing and how he is looking. INFPs are not interested in outward appearances.

For the rest of the characters:

Shivaay: ESTJ (My boyfriend is an ESTJ and the likeness between them is uncanny.) He is judgemental and focused on social status. He also has difficulty in expressing himself. At the same time he is very determined, loyal, reliable and organised.

Anika: ESTP

Rudra: ESFJ/ESFP (Undecided)

Saumya: ENFJ

Should I just start a new thread for these? 😆
This is fun!



Edited by parthianglory. - 9 years ago
QueenofGreen thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 9 years ago
#27

Originally posted by: VReSHna

Can i tell you that i love if!!! I havnt told that before!!!

I always knew you were brilliant in Portraying emotions, your analysis, your way of putting thing is jus Par apart!!!
Its Mature yet so Innocent!!!
Its real yet so Pure!!!
I agree with everything you say!!!
Ishana character sure if Faulty but its her faults that makes us so attached to her...
She is Different, Complicated yet she has a Force of Attraction!!!
Yes i find her super complicated, super confused at times too...coz may be thats what she is a Confused soul jus lost amongst the Hardships that life has thrown to her!!!
But then thats what Real life it...it pushes you, makes you question urself but whatever it may be - we gather ourself up, gather courage, determination n move Forward n thats exactly what Ishana is doing- she is tackling her Life with the way that is in reach of her at the moment!
All in All I love Ishana, i love Ishkara n i really hope Makes can produce Diamonds out of them!!! coz they sure have the potential to be the strongest and shine the brightest.. :)

P.S Love You Yar🤗


😳😳😳

Awww thanks lovely!

Ishaana has the potential to be such a memorable character, if only CVs would treat her right!

<333
QueenofGreen thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 9 years ago
#28

Originally posted by: Pinkylibbi

Oh My God...
Girl, take a bow.

This post is so Perfect to T and so wanted at this moment. I am so pissed off seeing Ishana depreciation threads daily in this forum for this reason or that reason. I do respect that people have their own likes and dislikes. But seeing same kind of posts again and again just gets on my nerves... I mean give it some time. Her scenes have not even started properly and here we are making such posts everyday.

And your analysis of Ishana is really beautiful. I bet even the CVs would not have put so much thoughts into this character like you did. With such small amount of scenes, that we got to see about her, you aptly described her character.

And like you said, Ishana and Omkara are so Perfect for each other and we could see that already. They have that connection that simply clicks without any reason. Their story is going to be one hell of an emotional roller coaster ride. But I simply can't wait to enjoy it. This couple have the maximum potential to touch hearts if handled properly. Be it when they are together or before they come together. I just hope and pray that the CVs have something really nice planned for them and they execute it well.

Finally, thank you so much for this post dear. This was much needed in the midst of all the negativity in the forum. After seeing such posts, it's really feeling nice to see some good posts about my favourite character in the show.

Love you girl.. Your name?



Hi! I'm Paridhi!

Thanks for your thoughts and feeback! 😊

I really hope that CVs are going to invest a lot more time and effort into Ishaana, because she is their creation and they need to treat her with pride and respect.

I can't wait for the IshKara relationship to start. They have so much potential!

Thanks again 😳

<33
QueenofGreen thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 9 years ago
#29

Originally posted by: -Abhiya-

this post was really needed

people were bashing Ishana continously
I hope now they will understand her character through ur post


I know. I'm so done with all the Ishaana hate. It's seriously annoying!
Thanks for your input! 😊
QueenofGreen thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 9 years ago
#30

Originally posted by: vidya29

"She is a beautiful chaos of incomplete thoughts and indecision".indeed.Aptly said.

This was much needed. I feel the reason she is so hated is because she is the closest to being a real person.She isn't perfect,she isn't beyond reach,she is quite ordinarily beautiful.
To top it all off,she has been paired with The Omkaara.A character with immense potential and unreal appeal.He is Draco Malfoy to me.A character written with simple intentions but was elevated by one man's interpretation and appeal of it.People romanticised his character,just like they somewhat justifiably do with Omkaara.Being such a glorious and loved character's better half would warrant some scrutiny.
You brought them forward quite well.If not anyone else I was forced to view Ishana in a different perspective.
Thanks for the post.


Hi!

Thanks for your thoughts. I don't like Ishaana's intentions either, but I'm counting on the hope that she won't go through with it, because she cares too much.

I can see your DM analogy, but I feel like Omkara is incomparable as a character. I think Ishaana is more apt to your analogy. She's the Draco Malfoy of this show - loved by many, detested by many and forced into bad choices due to upbringing and bad circumstances.

😊

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".