Scene from the book, that you wanted in the movie

always hoped they showed the whole book of deathly hallows in the movie and the book order of pheonixs 😛

Very interesting topic indeed !

-Gryffindor winning the Quidditch Cup in Harry's 3rd year...

Originally posted by: -HelloHiByeBye-

always hoped they showed the whole book of deathly hallows in the movie and the book order of pheonixs 😛

Oh Order of Phoenix had the most deletion I think...It is the book where the climax actually had begun to build up. Especially the last part, the part where The Trawlney said 'The Dark Lord marks him as equal'...

They never explained it as Fully as the book, which actually was very important...It was not only a revenge story it was more than that...How Harry And Voldy were bound by fate...the one unleased by Voldy himself...like Dumbledore had explained in the book...that this is what and where Tyrants all over the world made mistakes, they themselves created their worst enemy...

This should have been explained,..and showed...I loved the last dialogues in the book between the Teacher and the student ...and missed in the film

Originally posted by: sanahVM

Very interesting topic indeed !

There were lost of scenes, two which strike me right away are -

1). Snape's potion test guarding the philosopher's stone.

2). Harry's realization about the hallows/horcruxes at Shell cottage. This particularly was beautifully described in the book. I was expecting more in the movie.

Will Be back if I remember more !

Sanah

Hi Sanah,,,,Thanks

I also missed the many dialogues in Goblet of Fire...especially they did not show Hermoine and her role in helping Harry...she was also shown as away from the whole thing as Ron...Which was weird because it was because of this ...that the duo was always together to prepare for the tasks that Rita Skeeter had wrote about their alleged affair and all...
Also the sequencess of the scenes were changed..it was shown that Moody turned Malfoy in to a ferret after the break up..Where as it was before ...and the trio were laughing...I loved when Ron said

"Don't talk to me," Ron said quietly to Harry and Hermione as they sat down at the Gryffindor
table a few minutes later, surrounded by excited talk on all sides about what had just happened.

"Why not?" said Hermione in surprise.

"Because I want to fix that in my memory forever," said Ron, his eyes closed and an uplifted
expression on his face. "Draco Malfoy, the amazing bouncing ferret."

This was one of the amazing dialogues between the trio...

Originally posted by: madhu_sridhar

-Gryffindor winning the Quidditch Cup in Harry's 3rd year...

"As a sobbing Wood passed Harry the Cup, as he lifted it into the air, Harry felt he could have produced the world's best Patronus."

It's just a wonderfully written moment that had been building for three books and concluded in a most spectacular way and SHOULD have been in the movies. Its sad that the movie-folks excluded a scene that exuded Gryffindor spirit in every word.

Oh Wood's Character was so cut off after the third film..and he was never shown as the worrying leader that he was...and Fred and George pulling his leg...Somewhere they said 'He is taking a shower, we think he is trying to drown himself'...These were so missing...

And ofcourse the word 'Prongs rode again tonight'...I wanted to see Dumbledore saying that...It was such a classic Dumbledore statement when he learns that his students had outsmarted him all those years and now the son of one of them had just managed to produce the Patronus which turned into one of them...Only Dumbledore can see love and hope in this blatant memory of indiscipline and pranks...

@Madhu...On a side note...Are you A Gulaal fan...Gosh I am so glad whenever I run into one...😳

Originally posted by: -Srushti-

And ofcourse the word 'Prongs rode again tonight'...I wanted to see Dumbledore saying that...It was such a classic Dumbledore statement when he learns that his students had outsmarted him all those years and now the son of one of them had just managed to produce the Patronus which turned into one of them...Only Dumbledore can see love and hope in this blatant memory of indiscipline and pranks...

@Madhu...On a side note...Are you A Gulaal fan...Gosh I am so glad whenever I run into one...😳

there is the scene of the weasleys realising that Harry Potter is on the train after Fred and George help him get his trunk onto the train.

the most messed up was Half-blood prince movie...and bout ur topic...deres r list of scenes i want to see in d mve...i dnno u agree or not but i reaoly think they cud have shown harry suffrng detention from snape and den cmes to the common room without thnking kissed ginny...they cud have gone by the book...but they in this particular mve they messed up a lot...and also after this. i wud have love to see the harry voldy duel in the hall in frnt of everyone...and harry revealing snape's love for his mother and his true allegiance at everyone's presence and harry talking to dumbledore's portrait at the end of the war in part 2 of part 7...and also they shud hve shwed how it was written like harry repairing his old wand and telling dumbledore to return the wand in his grave and all...and deres r many many more!!!