Padman challenge? Are you okay with it? - Page 4

Created

Last reply

Replies

109

Views

9k

Users

52

Likes

491

Frequent Posters

1098676 thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#31
Menstruation is as natural as peeing and shitting, so people including men and children are needed to be aware about this issue.

We have no problem exchanging sex jokes or toilet humour, but when it comes to menstruation, even men feel awkward speaking about it. Periods start at a very young age, so children should also know what menstruation really is. And for that, people have to first acknowledge that periods exist.. pads exist!!! Menstruation should be normalized in our society, so that women don't feel ashamed to talk about periods, and a guy doesn't feels awkward hearing about it.

As for the promotion campaign, yes it is fake. The statements and the thoughts of these actors change according to their film releases. AkkI will soon start talking about the importance of Sports and Hockey in our country. He's not interested in creating any awareness, but if this is indeed creating any awareness, then there is no harm in it.
Edited by Luna46 - 7 years ago
bips thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 500 Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 7 years ago
#32
I'm curious - Has the campaign been effective in some way?... I'm not on Twitter anymore so I'm wondering what kind of comments Is the challenge getting?.. What is the general Twitter janta saying?
beingsirius thumbnail
8th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#33
Akshay is learning the liberal all noise no action ropes from Twinkle. Posting pics with pads on social media doesn't achieve anything. Maybe these people ought to go to Nepal and run a campaign there where a girl recently died due to cold in one of the menstruation huts. But no, they will never do anything like that.
Just like the HW elites who will be all #metoo until one of their own is involved, Roman Polanski or Woody Allen,,then they will defend them come hell or high water. And people will cheer their latest twitter challenges and fiery inspirational speeches conveniently ignoring their actions which are completely opposite.
TotalBetty thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 7 years ago
#34

Originally posted by: tanvismile

I find it stupid. Not every thing which is not discussed openly isn't something we r ashamed of and dont people buy pads at stores.? Thats why they r sold in first place. This film isn't introducing first pad in India. It's just narrating the story of who introduced it.



I quite agree... I don't understand their logic either

Btw the film is about a man who made affordable, low cost sanitary pads not the first one in India

Hope the movie also addresses how badly some women are treated during mensuration and how there's no need for that, that's essential instead of just talking about pads
return_to_hades thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 7 years ago
#35

Originally posted by: hippopotamus

I said this campaign is disgusting. Dont twist my topic. I am not 10 IQ lukkha who does not know what he is saying. lol. I only said what is the need to do this campaign and make a joke of the issue with people posing with the pad. Stop forcing and mixing ur issues into my post.


Could you elaborate what about the campaign you find disgusting? Perhaps people made some assumptions. But when you say a campaign like this is disgusting it does feel like you're targeting pads or menstruation. Maybe you could explain your stance better.

Originally posted by: hippopotamus

- normalize pads? is this the way to do it?


Shouldn't pads be normalized? What do you think is the right way to be open about menstruation in India? Or do you think menstruation should be a hush topic?

Growing up it was embarrassing to be on your period. The whole hush nature around it made it awkward to go buy sanitary pads. And then they wrap it up as if its some filthy porn that needs to be hidden.

Here in the United States pads and tampons are displayed on the shelf like any other product. You check out at the register just like anything else. It is normal to see men buy it for their significant others or daughters. Women are comfortable talking about their periods.

I think every woman in the world deserves to grow up with access to menstrual products. Every woman deserves the ability to go buy the product freely and not feel taboo or ostracized due to it. Women deserve the ability to talk about bodily changes like menstruation and menopause as a normal occurrence.

I find it funny that its completely normal for people to talk about getting food poisoning or illness that leads to diarrhea and vomiting, or talk about cuts and injuries that bled a lot. But the second a woman says she is bleeding out of her vagina everyone gets awkard and says TMI. Its normal. It happens every month. It causes a plethora of side affetcs like cramps, migraine, depression, bloating and even fever in some women. You get sick like once or twice a year. Why should women have to have secret talks of something that happens every fucking month.


Originally posted by: hippopotamus


but its my view. u guys can think what u want. but dont assume on my part. i am not some regressive idiot. i just did not find it honest and thought its not needed. and wrong way to approach the issue


Who is forcing men? They do not have to do it. No one is holding a gun to their head.

I agree that it is a total promotional campaign. No one would give a damn if there was no movie to promote. But its bringing an important conversation to the front and thats a good thing no matter what.
Faerydae thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 7 years ago
#36
Promotion ke naam pe kuch bhi🤢
Aur jab movie release ho gayee us ke baad sab drama khatam🤣
Thanks TM for making this much needed post👍🏼
1011128 thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#37
Could you elaborate what about the campaign you find disgusting? Perhaps people made some assumptions. But when you say a campaign like this is disgusting it does feel like you're targeting pads or menstruation. Maybe you could explain your stance better.

I did not like the idea of forcing people or challenging them to post a pic with a pad. I think its fake, i think its not needed, i think its not serious, i think its for movie more than any issue, i think its insincere, i think its crap. I think its disgusting. therefore.


Shouldn't pads be normalized? What do you think is the right way to be open about menstruation in India? Or do you think menstruation should be a hush topic?

I dont know what point they are trying to make. Do women not use it that they are asking them to use it? I am not interested in the message but I dont think this a topic grand enough that needs involvement of men. What can men do? what have the done? what will happen if we talk about it? This is not a topic like lets say rape which needs teaching on all sides..where there needs to be discussion. I just found this angle non serious...this could have been women only campaign and there is no need to make it grand. Even in US i rarely see this topic in discussion. It has become a fashion to make everything open up...this just doest not look to me an issue where there was a need to open up. It seems fake.

Growing up it was embarrassing to be on your period. The whole hush nature around it made it awkward to go buy sanitary pads. And then they wrap it up as if its some filthy porn that needs to be hidden.

Here in the United States pads and tampons are displayed on the shelf like any other product. You check out at the register just like anything else. It is normal to see men buy it for their significant others or daughters. Women are comfortable talking about their periods.

I think every woman in the world deserves to grow up with access to menstrual products. Every woman deserves the ability to go buy the product freely and not feel taboo or ostracized due to it. Women deserve the ability to talk about bodily changes like menstruation and menopause as a normal occurrence.

Whatever it is its women's own choice..i dont think this is one of those things where men have decided things and because of men women are ashamed..its their choice. so message should be tailored to them. that was my only point. i felt like is it some rape issue where someone is giving the message to men that u need to respect women and all that.

I find it funny that its completely normal for people to talk about getting food poisoning or illness that leads to diarrhea and vomiting, or talk about cuts and injuries that bled a lot. But the second a woman says she is bleeding out of her vagina everyone gets awkard and says TMI. Its normal. It happens every month. It causes a plethora of side affetcs like cramps, migraine, depression, bloating and even fever in some women. You get sick like once or twice a year. Why should women have to have secret talks of something that happens every fucking month.

i did not force them...they themselves need to sort it out.


Who is forcing men? They do not have to do it. No one is holding a gun to their head.

Do what? what can we do? what is there need for us to get involved. why does everyone needs to get involved in every issue and without everyone's involvement issue is not complete. the idea that somehow everyone needs to be taught is wrong..because everyone did not make up this issue, everyone cannot help in this issue. however everyone is required to watch the movie and hence making it a everyone topic. lol

I agree that it is a total promotional campaign. No one would give a damn if there was no movie to promote. But its bringing an important conversation to the front and thats a good thing no matter what.

no its not good..if this was an important issue then we should not be happy that ok since movie has brought it up ..its good.

anyway i am not too fussy about it..i just thought that idea of asking everyone challenging them to post a photo looked fake, insincere and more for movie than any true care for women and making it a grand issue just because u need men to watch the movie when it is a women issue and could have been dealth among them. its not some issue where men can help..we are not belittling women...nor we are causing them to feel ashamed.

i need to sleep now lol
behindyou thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 7 years ago
#38
Totally agree with Hippo! I don't want world to know about my periods that does not mean i am regressive .. but as per IF I am 😆 And regarding awareness mostly girls from metro cities use it... but the question is do girls from rural areas use twitter or go to multiplex for a movie ? how's it creating awareness pls sm1 make me understand?? .Should they go to rural areas to promote awareness ..
sunflower52 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 7 years ago
#39
Where is the freedom of choice if ones want to talk about periods, not everything makes regressive or taboo. Not all women are comfortable talking about personal stuff like periods or even sex.

If these actors really want to create awareness, should go to rural areas where the girls or women are not on social media where they lack education. Metro women or girls do not need this campaign.

So I agree with Hippo on this issue, now some are using regressive to freely. Just like freedom of speech has consequences, there are some thing in this life one should not cross lines.
TheRager thumbnail
21st Anniversary Thumbnail Achiever Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 7 years ago
#40
I think its pointless. Taboos related to menstrual hygiene mostly exist in rural areas and its mostly the poor who cant afford pads. What will change if Aamir holds a pad and poses for a picture? At best his fans who are on SM and follow BW news will become aware of a movie like Padman if they already were not. But will it change anything for the people who really need to be aware or change?

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".