JTHJ Movie discussion thread 3. - Page 113

Originally posted by: Terenaina

actually a parent and a child can look exactly alike. I have seen that with a co-worker who her husband and her son look carbon copy of each other

yeh ive seem parents and children who look almost the same or alarmingly similar ofcourse...

but i havent ever seen them be as identical as twins...its not exactly the most plausible or logical situation in the world...😆

but no one cares coz ppl remember anil, sridevi, waheeda and anupama from tht movie...

I know two sisters who are 3yrs apart and look exactly the same, it is scary at times

I actually know a family where the mom and daughter look SUPER ALIKE. It's kinda creepy. But yeah not totally identical. That's really not possible since our DNA's are supposed to be a mix of both parents, not just one. 😆

But I agree if another actress like maybe Kajol Or rani could've been part of this movie...it would've been different

Originally posted by: myLuvShahid-ji

Anu ko importance hie nahin de

Anushka was an integral part of the movie, but not as much as say karisma was in DTPH

Originally posted by: pathaka

yeh ive seem parents and children who look almost the same or alarmingly similar ofcourse...

but i havent ever seen them be as identical as twins...its not exactly the most plausible or logical situation in the world...😆

but no one cares coz ppl remember anil, sridevi, waheeda and anupama from tht movie...

Originally posted by: pathaka

^^see come to think of it, although yash chopras past films were gr8, they still had faults like JTHJ did...Sisila had a ridiculous climax, Kabhie kabhie had some annoying characters whoz motivations werent clear, Lamhe had a lolitaesque story line where mother n daughter look exactly the same...those films werent exactly logical either...

but those had gr8 actors to lift the film and make us feel all the emotions, the love, the romance etc...there was a dramatic conflict point...like infidelity, or age difference/borderline incestious nature of the relationship like in lamhe...that made those stories more interesting and we actually rooted for the characters...

but here u have kat "leaving" srk like she "leaves" chocolates n ciggarates... thts the importance u give to ur so called love of life?...hes equatable to an inatimate object thts just a medium of pleasure tht u can "give up" for the sake of a wish?

the entire notion of love in the movie rings soo hollow...

That is EXACTLY my point! Yash Chopra's films weren't really the most logical ones around. Chandni was hialrious...remember how Rishi Kapoor got paralyzed? 🤣 SO OTT!! But Rishi Kapoor, Sridevi, and all the actors of a Yash Chopra film always made us feel, so that even if it was cheesy and silly, you didn't mind it as much!

Here, Katrina just can't do it...and the silliness stares at you even MORE than usual in a YC film.

@red
And that's why I wanted Samar to die, go with Akira, or live alone, be with anyone BUT Meera. He loved her I understood, but I never could feel that she gave a crap about him. The whole post-amnesia scenes are supposed to make us feel that she does actually love him but they fall flat because Miss Blank face can't emote. Heck, even Zain--Samar's friend showed he cared more for Samar than Meera did. 😕

Originally posted by: blue-ice

Oh please...nothing can be as illogical as a RAW agent and an ISI agent falling in love...everything else is possible...this one is not😆😆...

when did i say tht was logical? 😆...


@ choco...i remember chandni...i soo wanted sridevi to end up with smexy vinod khanna...instead of pudgy rishi...😆...i love both the actors but rishi's character was kind of a douche to her in the movie...

Originally posted by: chocolover89

That is EXACTLY my point! Yash Chopra's films weren't really the most logical ones around. Chandni was hialrious...remember how Rishi Kapoor got paralyzed? 🤣 SO OTT!! But Rishi Kapoor, Sridevi, and all the actors of a Yash Chopra film always made us feel, so that even if it was cheesy and silly, you didn't mind it as much!

Here, Katrina just can't do it...and the silliness stares at you even MORE than usual in a YC film.

@red
And that's why I wanted Samar to die, go with Akira, or live alone, be with anyone BUT Meera. He loved her I understood, but I never could feel that she gave a crap about him. The whole post-amnesia scenes are supposed to make us feel that she does actually love him but they fall flat because Miss Blank face can't emote. Heck, even Zain--Samar's friend showed he cared more for Samar than Meera did. 😕