I think physical violence is a big no ,no matter how big or small the opponent is. archana had lost her marbles since last wkw after tweets being shown- super desperate for attention. Shiv could well have defended himself but its always the intention . If BB is setting the right example right from the start of the season why is there such a hullaboo. Umarβs was a different case altogether as there were three instance before his that were very bad yet overlooked. Shalin Archana task issue wasnt violence tbh. Hopefully she is evicted for a genuine violence case.